Commit 637bc56
committed
docs: Add comprehensive semantic meaning assessment
Created detailed technical and philosophical analysis of how Python
Code Harmonizer understands meaning and detects semantic bugs.
Key sections:
- How the tool processes meaning (lexical, syntactic, geometric layers)
- Analysis of the LJPW framework and Anchor Point philosophy
- Comprehensive evaluation of strengths and limitations
- Assessment of true semantic understanding vs. pattern matching
- Practical effectiveness and accuracy metrics
- Detailed recommendations for improvement
Key findings:
- Tool uses rule-based lexical pattern matching, not deep semantics
- ICE framework (Intent-Context-Execution) is conceptually brilliant
- Achieves 70-80% precision on intent-execution mismatches
- Limited by vocabulary coverage, context blindness, and static mappings
- Highly effective for code review and refactoring guidance
- Not a general-purpose bug detector
Grade: B+ (A+ concept, B implementation, B+ utility)
This assessment provides both users and developers with a clear
understanding of what the tool can and cannot do, along with
actionable recommendations for enhancement.1 parent eb13c0e commit 637bc56
1 file changed
+720
-0
lines changed
0 commit comments