Skip to content

Question, chapter 14, Code / ReservationManager / Implementation choice (p291) #9

@ntalbs

Description

@ntalbs

Chapter 14 > Code > ReservationManager (p291)

Implementation choice: We chose a Set to store Reservation objects because its unique
entry enforcement prevents duplicate bookings, aligning with the need to manage
reservations accurately. An alternative could use a List, which allows simpler iteration but risks
duplicates unless additional checks are added, or a Map with time-based keys, which could
speed up lookups but complicate removal by requiring keys that combine multiple fields,
like time, party size, and name, less suited for the system’s focus on reservation uniqueness.

List

Regarding the explanation about List and Map, can you clarify what the above sentences mean?
My understanding is that iterating over a list or a set is the same:

// iterate over a set
for (var e : set) {
 ...
}

// iterate over a list
for (var e : list) {
  ...
}

I am not quite sure what the clause "a List, which allows simpler iteration" means.

Map

The explanation about using Map is even more confusing. It states that a map with type-based keys could speed up lookups, but then insists that it requires combined keys with multiple fields, which doesn't look make sense. Can you clarify the explanation?

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions