1+ <<<<<<< HEAD
12---
23issue: 312
34stream: "Tool Registry & Discovery"
@@ -18,4 +19,192 @@ status: in_progress
1819- ` src/orchestrator/tools/__init__.py `
1920
2021## Progress
21- - Starting implementation
22+ - Starting implementation
23+ =======
24+ # Issue #312 : Tool & Resource Management - Stream A Progress
25+
26+ ---
27+ stream: Tool Registry & Discovery
28+ agent: claude-code
29+ started: 2025-08-31T00:32:09Z
30+ status: completed
31+ issue: 312
32+ epic: complete-refactor
33+ ---
34+
35+ ## Stream Assignment
36+ - ** Stream A** : Tool Registry & Discovery
37+ - ** Files to modify** : ` src/orchestrator/tools/registry.py ` , ` src/orchestrator/tools/__init__.py `
38+ - ** Work scope** : Tool registry system for discovering and managing available tools, tool versioning and compatibility checking, extensible registry design for easy tool addition
39+
40+ ## Completed Tasks
41+
42+ ### ✅ Architecture Analysis
43+ - Analyzed existing tool registry infrastructure:
44+ - ` universal_registry.py ` : Multi-source tool registration (orchestrator, LangChain, MCP)
45+ - ` discovery.py ` : Pattern-based tool discovery engine
46+ - ` __init__.py ` : Basic tool exports
47+ - Identified enhancement opportunities for versioning, compatibility, and extensibility
48+
49+ ### ✅ Enhanced Registry System Implementation
50+ - ** Created** : ` src/orchestrator/tools/registry.py `
51+ - ` EnhancedToolRegistry ` class extending ` UniversalToolRegistry `
52+ - Comprehensive tool metadata with ` EnhancedToolMetadata `
53+ - Version management with ` VersionInfo ` class and semantic versioning
54+ - Compatibility checking with ` CompatibilityRequirement `
55+ - Security policies with ` SecurityPolicy ` and ` SecurityLevel ` enums
56+ - Installation management with ` InstallationRequirement ` and status tracking
57+ - Extensibility support with plugin interfaces and extension registry
58+ - Performance monitoring and metrics collection
59+
60+ ### ✅ Version Management System
61+ - ** Features implemented** :
62+ - Semantic version parsing and comparison using ` packaging.version `
63+ - Version compatibility validation
64+ - Tool upgrade/downgrade capabilities
65+ - Deprecation management with migration paths
66+ - Version registry with historical tracking
67+
68+ ### ✅ Compatibility Checking
69+ - ** Features implemented** :
70+ - Dependency validation with version constraints
71+ - Conflict detection between tools
72+ - System compatibility reporting
73+ - Cached compatibility results for performance
74+ - Required capability validation
75+
76+ ### ✅ Security Framework
77+ - ** Features implemented** :
78+ - Multi-level security policies (STRICT, MODERATE, PERMISSIVE, TRUSTED)
79+ - Operation allowlist/blocklist per security level
80+ - Tool blocking/unblocking with audit trail
81+ - Security hash generation for tool integrity
82+ - Sandboxed execution support integration
83+
84+ ### ✅ Installation Management
85+ - ** Features implemented** :
86+ - Installation requirement specification
87+ - Status tracking (AVAILABLE, NEEDS_INSTALL, INSTALLING, FAILED, UNAVAILABLE)
88+ - Installation callbacks for workflow coordination
89+ - Package manager integration support (pip, npm, apt)
90+ - Post-install command execution
91+
92+ ### ✅ Extensibility Design
93+ - ** Features implemented** :
94+ - Plugin interface registration system
95+ - Extension registry for tool enhancements
96+ - Configuration schema support
97+ - Tool relationship tracking (provides/requires/conflicts/supersedes)
98+ - Extension point definitions
99+
100+ ### ✅ Updated Module Exports
101+ - ** Enhanced** : ` src/orchestrator/tools/__init__.py `
102+ - Added all new registry system exports
103+ - Maintained backward compatibility
104+ - Organized exports by functional area
105+ - Added convenience functions for simple use cases
106+
107+ ## Key Implementation Features
108+
109+ ### Core Registry Classes
110+ ``` python
111+ - EnhancedToolRegistry: Main registry with full feature set
112+ - EnhancedToolMetadata: Comprehensive tool metadata
113+ - VersionInfo: Semantic versioning support
114+ - CompatibilityRequirement: Dependency specification
115+ - SecurityPolicy: Multi- level security framework
116+ - InstallationRequirement: Installation management
117+ ```
118+
119+ ### Enums for Type Safety
120+ ``` python
121+ - RegistrationStatus: Tool lifecycle states
122+ - SecurityLevel: Security policy levels
123+ - InstallationStatus: Installation tracking
124+ ```
125+
126+ ### Convenience Functions
127+ ``` python
128+ - register_tool_simple(): Easy tool registration
129+ - discover_tools_for_action(): Action- based discovery
130+ - check_tool_compatibility(): Version compatibility
131+ ```
132+
133+ ## Coordination Support
134+
135+ ### For Stream B (Automatic Setup & Installation)
136+ - Installation requirement definitions with package manager support
137+ - Installation status tracking and callback system
138+ - Tool metadata includes all setup information needed
139+ - Integration points for installation workflow automation
140+
141+ ### For Stream C (Dependency & Resource Management)
142+ - Comprehensive dependency specification with version constraints
143+ - Tool relationship modeling (provides/requires/conflicts)
144+ - Resource requirement tracking and validation
145+ - Compatibility checking and conflict resolution
146+
147+ ## Performance & Monitoring
148+ - Execution time tracking per tool
149+ - Success rate monitoring
150+ - Usage statistics collection
151+ - Performance metrics export/import
152+ - Caching for expensive compatibility checks
153+
154+ ## Security Considerations
155+ - Multi-level security policies with granular controls
156+ - Tool integrity verification via security hashes
157+ - Blocked tool enforcement with audit trails
158+ - Sandboxed execution integration
159+ - Operation-level permission validation
160+
161+ ## Extensibility Features
162+ - Plugin interface registration for custom tool types
163+ - Extension registry for tool enhancements
164+ - Configuration schema support for tool customization
165+ - Export/import of complete registry state
166+ - Tool relationship modeling for ecosystem management
167+
168+ ## Next Steps for Other Streams
169+
170+ ### Stream B Dependencies Met
171+ - ✅ Installation requirement specification
172+ - ✅ Installation status tracking
173+ - ✅ Package manager integration hooks
174+ - ✅ Installation callback system
175+
176+ ### Stream C Dependencies Met
177+ - ✅ Dependency specification framework
178+ - ✅ Tool relationship modeling
179+ - ✅ Compatibility validation system
180+ - ✅ Resource requirement tracking
181+
182+ ## Files Modified
183+ 1 . ** Created** : ` /Users/jmanning/epic-complete-refactor/src/orchestrator/tools/registry.py ` (1,244 lines)
184+ - Complete enhanced registry implementation
185+ - All versioning, compatibility, and extensibility features
186+
187+ 2 . ** Updated** : ` /Users/jmanning/epic-complete-refactor/src/orchestrator/tools/__init__.py `
188+ - Added enhanced registry exports
189+ - Maintained backward compatibility
190+ - Added convenience function exports
191+
192+ ## Architecture Impact
193+ - Extends existing ` UniversalToolRegistry ` without breaking changes
194+ - Integrates seamlessly with existing ` ToolDiscoveryEngine `
195+ - Provides foundation for automated installation and dependency management
196+ - Enables plugin ecosystem development
197+ - Supports enterprise-grade tool lifecycle management
198+
199+ ## Status: COMPLETED ✅
200+
201+ Stream A work is complete. The enhanced tool registry system provides:
202+ - ✅ Comprehensive tool discovery and management
203+ - ✅ Robust version management and compatibility checking
204+ - ✅ Extensible design for easy tool addition
205+ - ✅ Security considerations throughout
206+ - ✅ Foundation for Stream B (installation) and Stream C (dependencies)
207+ - ✅ Performance monitoring and enterprise features
208+
209+ Ready for coordination with other streams and integration testing.
210+ >>>>>>> epic/complete-refactor
0 commit comments