Skip to content

Nobel laureate Richard Feynman once said that if two persons stood at arm's length from each other and each person had p = 1% more electrons than protons, the force of repulsion between them would be enough to lift a “weight” equal to that of the entire Earth. Carry out an order-of-magnitude calculation to substantiate this assertion. #49

@YoussefLasheen

Description

@YoussefLasheen

Suppose each person has mass $70kg.$ In terms of elementary charges, each person consists of precisely equal numbers of protons and electrons and a needy equal number of neutrons. The electrons comprise very little of the mass, so for each person we find the total number of protons and neutrons, taken together:
$$(70kg)({u\over{1.66×10^{−27}kg​}})=4×10^{28}u$$
of these, nearly on half, $2×10^{28}$,are protons, and 1% of this is $2×10^{26}$, constituting a charge of $$(2×10^{26})(1.60×10^{−19}C)=3×10^7C.$$
Thus, Feyman's force has magnitude
$$F={{ke​q1​q1\over {r2}}​​={{(8.99×109N.m^2/C^2)(3×10^7C)^2}\over {(0.5m)2}​}}∼1026N​$$
where we have used a half-meter arm's length. According to the particle in a gravitational field model, if the Earth were in an externally-produced uniform gravitational field of magnitude 9.80m/s2, it would weigh $$Fg​=mg=(6×10^{24}kg)(10m/s^2)∼10^{26}N.$$
Thus, the forces are of the same order of magnitude.

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions