Skip to content

Improve Regression Testing for Cross-Platform CompatibilityΒ #36

@DonHugo

Description

@DonHugo

πŸ§ͺ Regression Testing Improvements

πŸ“‹ Issue Description

The current regression testing suite has some issues when running on macOS instead of the target Raspberry Pi environment. While the architecture validation is successful (93.8% success rate), the tests need improvements for better cross-platform compatibility.

πŸ” Current Issues

  1. Environment-specific failures: Tests fail on macOS due to missing Linux-specific services (nginx, systemd, mosquitto)
  2. API endpoint URL construction: Some tests still have double '/api/api/' in URLs
  3. Test environment assumptions: Tests assume services are running locally

βœ… Already Fixed

  • HTML API reference: βœ… Fixed (now contains '/api/status')
  • Basic regression test endpoints: βœ… Fixed

🎯 Proposed Solutions

1. Environment Detection

import platform
import os

def is_raspberry_pi():
    """Detect if running on Raspberry Pi"""
    try:
        with open('/proc/cpuinfo', 'r') as f:
            return 'Raspberry Pi' in f.read()
    except:
        return False

def should_skip_service_tests():
    """Skip service tests on non-Linux systems"""
    return platform.system() != 'Linux' or not is_raspberry_pi()

2. Mock Services for Testing

class MockServiceTester:
    """Mock service responses for testing"""
    def test_nginx_mock(self):
        # Mock nginx response
        pass
    
    def test_api_server_mock(self):
        # Mock API server response
        pass

3. Conditional Test Execution

@pytest.mark.skipif(not is_raspberry_pi(), reason="Requires Raspberry Pi environment")
def test_systemd_services(self):
    # Only run on actual Raspberry Pi
    pass

πŸ“Š Current Test Results

  • Total Tests: 40
  • Passed: 26 βœ… (65% raw, 93.8% architecture validation)
  • Failed: 14 ❌ (mostly environment-related)
  • Architecture Validation: βœ… SUCCESSFUL

🎯 Success Criteria

  • Tests pass on macOS (development environment)
  • Tests pass on Raspberry Pi (production environment)
  • Clear separation between environment and architecture tests
  • Better test reporting and categorization

πŸ“ Files to Update

  • python/v3/tests/test_regression_comprehensive.py
  • python/v3/tests/test_regression_comprehensive_fixed.py
  • Add new test utilities for cross-platform compatibility

πŸ“‹ Priority

Medium - Architecture is sound, but testing experience could be improved for developers working on macOS.

🎯 Acceptance Criteria

  • Regression tests pass on macOS
  • Clear distinction between environment and architecture failures
  • Better test reporting with environment context
  • Documentation for running tests in different environments

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Projects

    No projects

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions