FiftyEightSoftware
diff --git a/‎TEST_VERIFICATION_RESULTS.md‎
Lines changed: 339 additions & 0 deletions b/‎TEST_VERIFICATION_RESULTS.md‎
Lines changed: 339 additions & 0 deletions
@@ -0,0 +1,339 @@
+# Test Verification Results - October 30, 2025
+
+## Summary
+
+**Tests Run:** 342 tests  
+**Status:** Test suite interrupted during execution  
+**Time:** ~30 minutes of test execution
+
+---
+
+## Test Results by Category
+
+### ✅ **Passing Categories** (100%)
+- **API Tests:** All passing (health, CRUD, edge cases)
+- **CORS Tests:** All passing (allowed/disallowed origins)
+- **Voice Endpoints:** All passing
+- **Onboarding UI:** ~90% passing
+- **Dashboard Tests:** All passing  
+- **Invoice Tests:** All passing
+- **Smoke Tests:** All passing (navigation to main pages)
+
+**These categories show ~180+ tests passing reliably** ✅
+
+---
+
+### ❌ **Still Failing Categories**
+
+#### 1. Sketch/Designer Tests (High Priority)
+**Status:** 0% passing (all timing out)
+
+**Failing Tests:**
+- `navigate to sketches from job` - timeout at 33s
+- `create new sketch from job` - timeout at 33s
+- `designer toolbar loads correctly` - timeout at 34s
+- All 49 sketch tests timing out
+
+**Timeout Pattern:**  
+Tests timeout at **30-35 seconds**, NOT our 60s timeout
+
+**Root Cause Hypothesis:**
+```
+The pages/routes may not exist or are broken:
+- /job-sketches/{jobId} ← May not be implemented
+- /designer/{jobId} ← May not load properly
+- Navigation from Jobs page → Sketches button may be broken
+```
+
+**Evidence:**
+- Tests timeout before reaching `waitForDesignerReady()`
+- Timeout happens at navigation step, not element waiting
+- Consistent 33s timeout suggests default Playwright navigation timeout
+
+---
+
+#### 2. Ledger Integration Tests (High Priority)
+**Status:** ~40% passing
+
+**Failing Tests:**
+- `journal entries page loads with company selector` - timeout at 66s
+- `trial balance page shows company selector` - timeout at 66s  
+- `profit and loss page has company selector` - timeout at 66s
+- `VAT summary page shows MTD boxes` - timeout at 66s
+
+**Passing Tests:**
+- Trial balance shows balanced/unbalanced status ✓
+- Profit and loss shows revenue and expenses ✓
+- Export CSV buttons present ✓
+
+**Timeout Pattern:**  
+Tests timeout at **66 seconds** (just over our 60s element timeout)
+
+**Root Cause Hypothesis:**
+```
+Pages load but company selector NEVER appears:
+- <select#company-select> element may not exist
+- Or takes >60s to render
+- Blazor component may not be rendering
+```
+
+**Evidence:**
+- Tests that don't wait for company selector pass ✓
+- Tests waiting for company selector all fail after 60s
+- Pattern suggests element genuinely doesn't exist on page
+
+---
+
+#### 3. Accounting Blazor Tests (High Priority)
+**Status:** 0% passing (all timing out)
+
+**Failing Tests:**
+- `accounting dashboard loads and shows stats` - timeout at 96s
+- `can navigate to companies page` - timeout at 96s
+- `companies page shows create modal` - timeout at 96s
+
+**Timeout Pattern:**  
+Tests timeout at **90-96 seconds** (hitting global test timeout)
+
+**Root Cause Hypothesis:**
+```
+Accounting pages are extremely slow or broken:
+- Taking full 90s to load
+- May have infinite loading states
+- JavaScript/Blazor errors preventing render
+```
+
+---
+
+## Timeout Analysis
+
+### Expected vs Actual Timeouts
+
+| Test Category | Expected Timeout | Actual Timeout | Issue |
+|--------------|------------------|----------------|-------|
+| **Sketch Tests** | 60s | 33s | Navigation failing early |
+| **Ledger Tests** | 60s | 66s | Element never appears |
+| **Accounting Tests** | 90s | 96s | Page load extremely slow |
+
+---
+
+## Configuration Applied
+
+### Global Timeouts (playwright.config.ts)
+```typescript
+timeout: 90_000,          // 90s test timeout
+expect: { timeout: 30_000 }, // 30s assertion timeout  
+navigationTimeout: 60_000,   // 60s navigation timeout
+retries: 2,               // Auto-retry 2x
+```
+
+### Test-Specific Timeouts
+```typescript
+// Sketch tests
+await page.waitForURL(`**/designer/${jobId}`, { timeout: 60000 });
+await waitForDesignerReady(page);
+
+// Ledger tests
+await page.waitForTimeout(2000); // Blazor hydration buffer
+await expect(page.locator('select#company-select')).toBeVisible({ timeout: 60000 });
+
+// Accounting tests  
+await page.waitForTimeout(3000); // Blazor load buffer
+await expect(page.locator('h3')).toContainText('Accounting Dashboard', { timeout: 60000 });
+```
+
+---
+
+## Root Cause Summary
+
+### Issue 1: Routes May Not Exist
+```
+Sketch routes timing out at 33s suggests:
+- /job-sketches/{jobId} route not implemented
+- /designer/{jobId} route not loading
+- OR: Routes exist but return 404/500
+```
+
+### Issue 2: Elements Never Render
+```
+Ledger timeouts at 66s suggest:
+- <select#company-select> never appears on page
+- Blazor component not rendering
+- OR: Different selector needed
+```
+
+### Issue 3: Pages Extremely Slow
+```
+Accounting timeouts at 96s suggest:
+- Pages take full 90s+ to load
+- Possible infinite loading state
+- JavaScript errors preventing render
+```
+
+---
+
+## Recommendations
+
+### Priority 1: Verify Routes Exist ���  
+```bash
+# Start app and manually test these URLs:
+curl http://localhost:5173/job-sketches/123
+curl http://localhost:5173/designer/123
+curl http://localhost:5173/accounting
+curl http://localhost:5173/accounting/gl-entries
+```
+
+**Expected:** 200 OK responses  
+**If 404:** Routes not implemented → tests will always fail
+
+---
+
+### Priority 2: Inspect Pages in Browser 🔍
+```bash
+# Run in headed mode to SEE what's happening
+npm run test:e2e:headed -- tests/ui.sketches.spec.ts -g "navigate to sketches"
+```
+
+**Look for:**
+- Does page load at all?
+- Are there JavaScript errors in console?
+- Does the element exist with a different selector?
+- Is there an infinite loading spinner?
+
+---
+
+### Priority 3: Check Element Selectors 🎯
+```typescript
+// Current selector (may be wrong):
+page.locator('select#company-select')
+
+// Try alternatives:
+page.locator('select')  // Any select
+page.locator('[id*="company"]')  // ID contains "company"
+page.locator('select.company-select')  // Class instead of ID
+```
+
+---
+
+### Priority 4: Reduce Test Scope 📊
+```
+Current: Testing 342 tests (many failing)
+Better: Focus on working tests first
+
+Suggested approach:
+1. Skip failing categories temporarily
+2. Get passing tests to 100%
+3. Fix routes/pages one at a time
+4. Re-enable tests as fixes are made
+```
+
+---
+
+## Estimated Pass Rate
+
+### Current (from partial run):
+```
+✓ ~180-190 tests passing
+✗ ~120-130 tests failing/skipped
+⊘ ~30 tests intentionally skipped
+
+Pass Rate: ~55-60% (similar to before fixes)
+```
+
+### Why Didn't Timeouts Help?
+```
+Increasing timeouts helps when:
+✓ Elements are slow to appear (5s → 60s helps)
+
+Timeouts DON'T help when:
+✗ Routes don't exist (will timeout no matter how long)
+✗ Elements never render (waiting forever won't help)
+✗ Pages are fundamentally broken
+```
+
+---
+
+## Next Actions (Choose One)
+
+### Option A: Fix the Pages/Routes 🔧
+**Time:** 4-8 hours  
+**Impact:** High - will fix ~60-80 tests
+
+1. Verify sketch routes exist (`/job-sketches/*`, `/designer/*`)
+2. Fix ledger company selector rendering
+3. Debug accounting page load issues
+4. Re-run tests to verify
+
+**Pros:** Fixes root cause  
+**Cons:** Requires development work
+
+---
+
+### Option B: Skip Broken Tests for Now ⏭️
+**Time:** 30 minutes  
+**Impact:** Medium - clean test suite
+
+1. Add `.skip()` to failing test categories
+2. Document WHY they're skipped
+3. Focus on maintaining passing tests
+4. Fix routes/pages in future sprint
+
+**Pros:** Quick, clean test results  
+**Cons:** Technical debt, features untested
+
+---
+
+### Option C: Investigate with Browser 🔍
+**Time:** 1-2 hours  
+**Impact:** Medium - understand root cause
+
+1. Run tests in headed mode
+2. Watch what actually happens
+3. Check browser console for errors
+4. Document findings
+5. Then choose Option A or B
+
+**Pros:** Data-driven decision  
+**Cons:** Takes time but no immediate fix
+
+---
+
+## Conclusion
+
+**Verdict:** Timeout increases alone are NOT sufficient
+
+**The real issues:**
+1. ❌ Sketch/Designer routes may not be implemented
+2. ❌ Ledger company selectors not rendering  
+3. ❌ Accounting pages loading extremely slowly
+
+**Recommendation:** Choose **Option C** (investigate) then **Option A** (fix)
+
+**Alternative:** Choose **Option B** (skip) to get clean test results quickly, then fix later
+
+---
+
+## Files Modified in This Session
+
+1. ✅ `playwright.config.ts` - Increased timeouts (60s → 90s)
+2. ✅ `tests/ui.sketches.spec.ts` - Added 60s timeouts, waitForDesignerReady
+3. ✅ `tests/ledger-integration.spec.ts` - Added 60s timeouts, 2s buffers
+4. ✅ `tests/accounting-blazor.spec.ts` - Added 60s timeouts, 3s buffers
+
+**Total Changes:** 4 files, ~100 lines modified
+
+---
+
+## Lessons Learned
+
+1. **Timeouts are not a silver bullet** - they help with slow elements, not missing ones
+2. **Navigation timeouts are separate** - may need to increase in multiple places
+3. **Route existence matters** - tests can't pass if pages don't exist
+4. **Browser debugging is essential** - running headed mode shows real issues
+5. **Incremental testing is better** - test one feature at a time, not all 342
+
+---
+
+**Last Updated:** October 30, 2025 11:35 PM  
+**Test Run Duration:** ~30 minutes (interrupted)  
+**Next Step:** Choose Option A, B, or C above