- 
                Notifications
    You must be signed in to change notification settings 
- Fork 17
Closed
Description
Context:
Currently, clients cannot force the deletion of individual pieces from their datasets without storage provider (SP) cooperation. This creates a problematic scenario where:
- Client submits off-chain delete request → SP receives deletion request from client
- SP can refuse to process deletion on-chain → SP has economic incentive to ignore deletion since they get paid less after deletion
- Client has no recourse → No way for client to force the deletion on-chain themselves
- SP continues getting paid → For data that was supposed to be deleted
Approaches:
During the 2025-08-19 eng sync, two approaches were discussed:
Payment-Based Enforcement
Withhold/reduce payments until SP complies with deletion requests
- Client signals deletion request, payment rail reduces funds for non-deleted pieces
- SP incentivized to delete to resume full payment
- Preferred because not all implementations use the same payment mechanisms
Service Freezing
Block proving progress until SP processes deletion
- Next proving period is blocked until deletion requests are processed
- SP cannot submit proofs until compliance, effectively shutting down service
- No new proofs or payments processed until deletion completed
Based on the discussion, it leaned towards the payment-based enforcement approach. But @aarshkshah1992 will take ownership of this, and further flesh out the technical approach.
This change is also a breaking change, which means that we will need this to be completed in the M2.5 milestone.
wjmelementsSgtPooki
Metadata
Metadata
Assignees
Labels
No labels
Type
Projects
Status
🎉 Done