Yet more IREEGPUAttrs cleanup: drop get{A,B,C}SingleSubgroupLayout methods (iree-org#19169)

These methods existed before we added the unified
`getSingleSubgroupLayout` taking a `MMAFragment` argument. Now they can
go away. Actually polymorphic callers, which motivated this being an
interface method, are taken care of by a new overload of
`getSingleSubgroupLayout` taking a `MMAInterfaceAttr`.

---------

Signed-off-by: Benoit Jacob <[email protected]>

Author: bjacob

compiler/src/iree/compiler/Codegen/Common/GPU/AMDGPUDistributeContract.cpp

@@ -57,16 +57,19 @@ static LogicalResult isIntrinsicLayoutCompatible(
   auto [lhsM, rhsN] = opInfo.getOperandMNIndex();
   auto [lhsK, rhsK] = opInfo.getOperandKIndex();
   auto [accM, accN] = opInfo.getResultMNIndex();
-  if (failed(isSubgroupLayoutCompatible(getASingleSubgroupLayout(intrinsic),
-                                        lhsLayout, lhsM, lhsK))) {
+  if (failed(isSubgroupLayoutCompatible(
+          getSingleSubgroupLayout(intrinsic, IREE::GPU::MMAFragment::Lhs),
+          lhsLayout, lhsM, lhsK))) {
     return failure();
   }
-  if (failed(isSubgroupLayoutCompatible(getBSingleSubgroupLayout(intrinsic),
-                                        rhsLayout, rhsK, rhsN))) {
+  if (failed(isSubgroupLayoutCompatible(
+          getSingleSubgroupLayout(intrinsic, IREE::GPU::MMAFragment::Rhs),
+          rhsLayout, rhsK, rhsN))) {
     return failure();
   }
-  if (failed(isSubgroupLayoutCompatible(getCSingleSubgroupLayout(intrinsic),
-                                        accLayout, accM, accN))) {
+  if (failed(isSubgroupLayoutCompatible(
+          getSingleSubgroupLayout(intrinsic, IREE::GPU::MMAFragment::Acc),
+          accLayout, accM, accN))) {
     return failure();
   }
   return success();

compiler/src/iree/compiler/Codegen/Dialect/GPU/IR/IREEGPUAttrs.cpp

@@ -69,7 +69,7 @@ static bool is_AMD_WMMA(MMAIntrinsic intrinsic) {
 
 static int64_t getIntrinsicSubgroupSize(MMAIntrinsic intrinsic) {
   // Not using Wave64 at all at the moment, so the only place where the
-  // subgroup size is CDNA* architectures.
+  // subgroup size is 64 is on CDNA* architectures.
   return is_AMD_MFMA(intrinsic) ? 64 : 32;
 }
 
@@ -292,38 +292,14 @@ OpaqueMmaLayout getOpaqueMMALayout(MLIRContext *context,
   return getOpaqueMMALayout<IREE::GPU::MMAIntrinsic>(context, intrinsic);
 }
 
-//===----------------------------------------------------------------------===//
-// MmaInterface Attribute Helper Functions
-//===----------------------------------------------------------------------===//
-
-MMASingleSubgroupLayout getASingleSubgroupLayout(MmaInterfaceAttr mmaKind) {
-  if (auto mmaAttr = dyn_cast<MMAAttr>(mmaKind)) {
-    return mmaAttr.getASingleSubgroupLayout();
-  }
-  if (auto vmmaAttr = dyn_cast<VirtualMMAAttr>(mmaKind)) {
-    return vmmaAttr.getASingleSubgroupLayout();
-  }
-  assert(false && "unhandled MMA Interface type.");
-  return {};
-}
-
-MMASingleSubgroupLayout getBSingleSubgroupLayout(MmaInterfaceAttr mmaKind) {
-  if (auto mmaAttr = dyn_cast<MMAAttr>(mmaKind)) {
-    return mmaAttr.getBSingleSubgroupLayout();
-  }
-  if (auto vmmaAttr = dyn_cast<VirtualMMAAttr>(mmaKind)) {
-    return vmmaAttr.getBSingleSubgroupLayout();
-  }
-  assert(false && "unhandled MMA Interface type.");
-  return {};
-}
-
-MMASingleSubgroupLayout getCSingleSubgroupLayout(MmaInterfaceAttr mmaKind) {
+MMASingleSubgroupLayout getSingleSubgroupLayout(MmaInterfaceAttr mmaKind,
+                                                MMAFragment fragment) {
   if (auto mmaAttr = dyn_cast<MMAAttr>(mmaKind)) {
-    return mmaAttr.getCSingleSubgroupLayout();
+    return getSingleSubgroupLayout(mmaAttr.getIntrinsic().getValue(), fragment);
   }
   if (auto vmmaAttr = dyn_cast<VirtualMMAAttr>(mmaKind)) {
-    return vmmaAttr.getCSingleSubgroupLayout();
+    return getSingleSubgroupLayout(vmmaAttr.getIntrinsic().getValue(),
+                                   fragment);
   }
   assert(false && "unhandled MMA Interface type.");
   return {};
@@ -407,18 +383,6 @@ FailureOr<IREE::GPU::MMAScope> MMAAttr::getMmaScope() const {
   return IREE::GPU::MMAScope::Subgroup;
 }
 
-MMASingleSubgroupLayout MMAAttr::getASingleSubgroupLayout() const {
-  return getSingleSubgroupLayout(getIntrinsic().getValue(), MMAFragment::Lhs);
-}
-
-MMASingleSubgroupLayout MMAAttr::getBSingleSubgroupLayout() const {
-  return getSingleSubgroupLayout(getIntrinsic().getValue(), MMAFragment::Rhs);
-}
-
-MMASingleSubgroupLayout MMAAttr::getCSingleSubgroupLayout() const {
-  return getSingleSubgroupLayout(getIntrinsic().getValue(), MMAFragment::Acc);
-}
-
 // Get virtual intrinsics that is composed/based on queried op.
 SmallVector<VirtualMMAIntrinsic> MMAAttr::getVirtualIntrinsics() const {
   switch (getIntrinsic().getValue()) {
@@ -1098,18 +1062,6 @@ MMASingleSubgroupLayout getSingleSubgroupLayout(VirtualMMAIntrinsic intrinsic,
   return {};
 }
 
-MMASingleSubgroupLayout VirtualMMAAttr::getASingleSubgroupLayout() const {
-  return getSingleSubgroupLayout(getIntrinsic().getValue(), MMAFragment::Lhs);
-}
-
-MMASingleSubgroupLayout VirtualMMAAttr::getBSingleSubgroupLayout() const {
-  return getSingleSubgroupLayout(getIntrinsic().getValue(), MMAFragment::Rhs);
-}
-
-MMASingleSubgroupLayout VirtualMMAAttr::getCSingleSubgroupLayout() const {
-  return getSingleSubgroupLayout(getIntrinsic().getValue(), MMAFragment::Acc);
-}
-
 //===----------------------------------------------------------------------===//
 // Target Attributes
 //===----------------------------------------------------------------------===//

compiler/src/iree/compiler/Codegen/Dialect/GPU/IR/IREEGPUAttrs.h

@@ -33,10 +33,10 @@ namespace mlir::iree_compiler::IREE::GPU {
 // semantics in that case are that threads within the subgroup whose thread-ids
 // differ by a multiple of `P`, are accessing the same elements.
 //
-// Example observed in RDNA3 WMMA Wave64 intrinsics:
-// If the subgroup size is 64 but the product `P` of `thread` sizes is 32, that
-// means that each element is being accessed by 2 threads (2 = 64/32), and the
-// threads accessing the same element are those whose tids are exactly 32 apart.
+// Example observed in RDNA3 WMMA Wave32 intrinsics:
+// If the subgroup size is 32 but the product `P` of `thread` sizes is 16, that
+// means that each element is being accessed by 2 threads (2 = 32/16), and the
+// threads accessing the same element are those whose tids are exactly 16 apart.
 struct MMASingleSubgroupLayout {
   // Internal dimensions (as in TileSwizzle::Dim::Kind::Internal) that are
   // outer-most in the layout. This happens when a MMA op, seen on a single
@@ -54,7 +54,7 @@ struct MMASingleSubgroupLayout {
   // Internal dimensions (as in TileSwizzle::Dim::Kind::Internal) that are
   // inner-most in the layout. This happens when a MMA op, seen on a single
   // thread, has an operand that consists of multiple elements, and these elems
-  // are NOT contiguous.
+  // are contiguous.
   // This is not used by every MMA op; ops which don't use that simply have 1's.
   SmallVector<int64_t, 2> element;
 };
@@ -65,11 +65,8 @@ MMASingleSubgroupLayout getSingleSubgroupLayout(MMAIntrinsic intrinsic,
 MMASingleSubgroupLayout getSingleSubgroupLayout(VirtualMMAIntrinsic intrinsic,
                                                 MMAFragment fragment);
 
-MMASingleSubgroupLayout getASingleSubgroupLayout(MmaInterfaceAttr mmaKind);
-
-MMASingleSubgroupLayout getBSingleSubgroupLayout(MmaInterfaceAttr mmaKind);
-
-MMASingleSubgroupLayout getCSingleSubgroupLayout(MmaInterfaceAttr mmaKind);
+MMASingleSubgroupLayout getSingleSubgroupLayout(MmaInterfaceAttr mmaKind,
+                                                MMAFragment fragment);
 
 // Struct describing the shape of a MMA operation, but not the detailed layout.
 // TODO(bjacob): the only user outside of IREEGPUAttrs.cpp is

compiler/src/iree/compiler/Codegen/Dialect/GPU/IR/IREEGPUAttrs.td

@@ -151,9 +151,6 @@ class IREEGPU_MmaVectorLayoutAttr<string attrname, string mmaintrinsic> :
     "getMNKShape",
     "getSubgroupSize",
     "getMmaScope",
-    "getASingleSubgroupLayout",
-    "getBSingleSubgroupLayout",
-    "getCSingleSubgroupLayout",
     "buildMmaOperation",
     "populateOperandOffsetsSizesStrides",
   ]>
@@ -225,14 +222,6 @@ def IREEGPU_MMAAttr : IREEGPU_MmaVectorLayoutAttr<"MMA", "MMAIntrinsicAttr"> {
   let extraClassDeclaration = [{
     int64_t getBlockSize() const;
 
-    // Returns the A/B/C matrix's partial nested layout shape inside a single
-    // subgroup. Shape at each outer/thread/element level is a 2-D value,
-    // following canonical matmul order--(M, K) for A, (K, N) for B, and
-    // (M, N) for C.
-    MMASingleSubgroupLayout getASingleSubgroupLayout() const;
-    MMASingleSubgroupLayout getBSingleSubgroupLayout() const;
-    MMASingleSubgroupLayout getCSingleSubgroupLayout() const;
-
     SmallVector<VirtualMMAIntrinsic> getVirtualIntrinsics() const;
   }];
 }
@@ -287,9 +276,6 @@ def IREEGPU_VirtualMMAAttr :
     "getMNKShape",
     "getSubgroupSize",
     "getMmaScope",
-    "getASingleSubgroupLayout",
-    "getBSingleSubgroupLayout",
-    "getCSingleSubgroupLayout",
     "populateOperandOffsetsSizesStrides",
     "buildMmaOperation",
   ]>
@@ -319,14 +305,6 @@ def IREEGPU_VirtualMMAAttr :
   let extraClassDeclaration = [{
     int64_t getBlockSize() const;
 
-    // Returns the A/B/C matrix's partial nested layout shape inside a single
-    // subgroup. Shape at each outer/thread/element level is a 2-D value,
-    // following canonical matmul order--(M, K) for A, (K, N) for B, and
-    // (M, N) for C.
-    MMASingleSubgroupLayout getASingleSubgroupLayout() const;
-    MMASingleSubgroupLayout getBSingleSubgroupLayout() const;
-    MMASingleSubgroupLayout getCSingleSubgroupLayout() const;
-
     // Factor to unroll K from native MMA/intrinsic size to virtual size.
     // e.g MFMA_F32_16x16x16 has K of 16, while VMFMA_F32_16x16x32 has K of 32
     // in this example, unrollK = 32/16 = 2.

compiler/src/iree/compiler/Codegen/Dialect/GPU/Transforms/ConcretizeMmaShapes.cpp

@@ -30,22 +30,20 @@ LogicalResult materializeOperandConcreteShape(
     SmallVector<ReassociationIndices> &reassociations,
     RankedTensorType &resultType) {
 
-  SmallVector<int64_t, 2> outerSizes;
+  MMASingleSubgroupLayout layout = getSingleSubgroupLayout(mma, fragment);
+  SmallVector<int64_t, 2> outerSizes = layout.outer;
   SmallVector<int64_t, 2> opaqueSizes;
   auto [m, n, k] = mma.getMNKShape();
   switch (fragment) {
   case IREE::GPU::MMAFragment::Lhs: {
-    outerSizes = mma.getASingleSubgroupLayout().outer;
     opaqueSizes.append({m, k});
     break;
   }
   case IREE::GPU::MMAFragment::Rhs: {
-    outerSizes = mma.getBSingleSubgroupLayout().outer;
     opaqueSizes.append({k, n});
     break;
   }
   case IREE::GPU::MMAFragment::Acc: {
-    outerSizes = mma.getCSingleSubgroupLayout().outer;
     opaqueSizes.append({m, n});
     break;
   }

compiler/src/iree/compiler/Codegen/LLVMGPU/LLVMGPUConfigureTensorLayouts.cpp

@@ -311,11 +311,12 @@ getContractionLayout(IREE::GPU::MMAScheduleAttr schedule,
     cSubgroupStrides[dim] = subgroupNStrides[i];
   }
 
-  auto cLayout = createNestedLayout(context, cRank, m, n,
-                                    /*subgroupCount=*/cSubgroupSizes,
-                                    /*subgroupStrides=*/cSubgroupStrides,
-                                    /*batchCount=*/cBatchSizes,
-                                    getCSingleSubgroupLayout(mmaAttr));
+  IREE::VectorExt::NestedLayoutAttr cLayout = createNestedLayout(
+      context, cRank, m, n,
+      /*subgroupCount=*/cSubgroupSizes,
+      /*subgroupStrides=*/cSubgroupStrides,
+      /*batchCount=*/cBatchSizes,
+      getSingleSubgroupLayout(mmaAttr, IREE::GPU::MMAFragment::Acc));
   LLVM_DEBUG({ llvm::dbgs() << "C layout: " << cLayout << "\n"; });
 
   // A matrix layout
@@ -339,11 +340,12 @@ getContractionLayout(IREE::GPU::MMAScheduleAttr schedule,
   }
   aBatchSizes[afk] = bounds[opInfo.getKDims().back()] / intrinsicK;
 
-  auto aLayout = createNestedLayout(context, aRank, afm, afk,
-                                    /*subgroupCount=*/aSubgroupSizes,
-                                    /*subgroupStrides=*/aSubgroupStrides,
-                                    /*batchCount=*/aBatchSizes,
-                                    getASingleSubgroupLayout(mmaAttr));
+  IREE::VectorExt::NestedLayoutAttr aLayout = createNestedLayout(
+      context, aRank, afm, afk,
+      /*subgroupCount=*/aSubgroupSizes,
+      /*subgroupStrides=*/aSubgroupStrides,
+      /*batchCount=*/aBatchSizes,
+      getSingleSubgroupLayout(mmaAttr, IREE::GPU::MMAFragment::Lhs));
   LLVM_DEBUG({ llvm::dbgs() << "A layout: " << aLayout << "\n"; });
 
   int64_t bRank = opInfo.getBRank();
@@ -363,11 +365,12 @@ getContractionLayout(IREE::GPU::MMAScheduleAttr schedule,
   }
   bBatchSizes[bfk] = bounds[opInfo.getKDims().back()] / intrinsicK;
 
-  auto bLayout = createNestedLayout(context, bRank, bfk, bfn,
-                                    /*subgroupCount=*/bSubgroupSizes,
-                                    /*subgroupStrides=*/bSubgroupStrides,
-                                    /*batchCount=*/bBatchSizes,
-                                    getBSingleSubgroupLayout(mmaAttr));
+  IREE::VectorExt::NestedLayoutAttr bLayout = createNestedLayout(
+      context, bRank, bfk, bfn,
+      /*subgroupCount=*/bSubgroupSizes,
+      /*subgroupStrides=*/bSubgroupStrides,
+      /*batchCount=*/bBatchSizes,
+      getSingleSubgroupLayout(mmaAttr, IREE::GPU::MMAFragment::Rhs));
   LLVM_DEBUG({ llvm::dbgs() << "B layout: " << bLayout << "\n"; });
 
   std::tuple<VectorLayoutInterface, VectorLayoutInterface,
@@ -618,11 +621,11 @@ static LogicalResult setAttentionMatmulAnchor(RewriterBase &rewriter,
   auto pvIntrinsic =
       cast<IREE::GPU::MmaInterfaceAttr>(pvSchedule.getIntrinsic());
   IREE::GPU::MMASingleSubgroupLayout lhsLayout =
-      getASingleSubgroupLayout(pvIntrinsic);
+      getSingleSubgroupLayout(pvIntrinsic, IREE::GPU::MMAFragment::Lhs);
   IREE::GPU::MMASingleSubgroupLayout rhsLayout =
-      getBSingleSubgroupLayout(pvIntrinsic);
+      getSingleSubgroupLayout(pvIntrinsic, IREE::GPU::MMAFragment::Rhs);
   IREE::GPU::MMASingleSubgroupLayout outLayout =
-      getCSingleSubgroupLayout(qkIntrinsic);
+      getSingleSubgroupLayout(qkIntrinsic, IREE::GPU::MMAFragment::Acc);
 
   auto matchLayout = [](IREE::GPU::MMASingleSubgroupLayout layoutA,
                         IREE::GPU::MMASingleSubgroupLayout layoutB) -> bool {