Skip to content

Commit ca0c51f

Browse files
committed
Adapt GMCI quest
1 parent 8cb88ac commit ca0c51f

File tree

2 files changed

+113
-24
lines changed

2 files changed

+113
-24
lines changed

extras/config/storylines/lovedataweek.yml

Lines changed: 74 additions & 24 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -906,7 +906,7 @@ quests:
906906
en: "Thank you so much for helping to find new datasets to be added to the GMCI community!"
907907
- text:
908908
en: "Once the new datasets are submitted, the MaRDI team will review them and add them to the GMCI platform."
909-
set: [ 'quest.gmci.done', 'pnt.empathy.gmci' , 'op.quest.gmci']
909+
set: [ 'quest.gmci.done', 'pnt.graph.gmci' , 'op.quest.gmci']
910910
- prompt:
911911
en: "Find people who have datasets to share."
912912
counter:
@@ -946,39 +946,71 @@ quests:
946946
thenText:
947947
en: "Are you sure? That sounds like Gibberish to me. Maybe you should ask at the MaRDI help desk, which format is best."
948948
Barista:
949+
- type: sequence
950+
items:
951+
- cond: 'op.nodata.barista'
952+
type: sequence
953+
items:
954+
- text:
955+
en: "You already talked to me. We agreed my data is not suitable for the GMCI community."
956+
- text:
957+
en: "I have now uploaded it to Zenodo, the free, open-access repository, so it is publicly available and can be linked, for example with the corresponding algorithms nodes in the MathAlgoDB knowledge graph."
958+
- cond: '^op.nodata.barista'
959+
type: sequence
960+
items:
961+
- text:
962+
en: "I have collected quite some data benchmarking coffee brewing algorithms for performance (e.g., optimization accuracy or speed)."
963+
- text:
964+
en: "All the data is in a big excel sheet. Do you think it would be appropriate to share with the GMCI community?"
965+
responses:
966+
- text:
967+
en: "I am not sure."
968+
thenText:
969+
en: "Please ask the MaRDI help desk, if this kind of data is appropriate for the GMCI community. I will wait for you here."
970+
- text:
971+
en: "Your data is not suitable."
972+
thenText:
973+
en: "You are right. The data is more algorithm evaluation than causal inference, and therefore not suitable for the GMCI community."
974+
then: nodata
975+
- text:
976+
en: "Your data is perfect for the GMCI community."
977+
thenText:
978+
en: "Well, actually, I don't think so. It is more algorithm evaluation than causal inference, so not suitable for the GMCI community."
979+
then: nodata
980+
- text:
981+
en: "Yes, an excel sheet is fine."
982+
thenText:
983+
en: "I was more worried about the data itself. Please ask the MaRDI help desk, if this kind of data is appropriate for the GMCI community."
984+
- cond: '^op.nodata.barista'
985+
id: nodata
986+
type: sequence
987+
items:
988+
- text:
989+
en: "However, I talked to some researchers during the coffe break already. They told me about some interesting datasets they have. You can ask them to share their datasets with the GMCI community."
990+
set: [ 'op.nodata.barista' ]
991+
MathPerson2:
949992
- type: sequence
950993
items:
951994
- text:
952-
en: "I have collected quite some data benchmarking coffee brewing algorithms for performance (e.g., optimization accuracy or speed)."
995+
en: "I have a simulation dataset that includes variables such as fluid viscosity, thermal conductivity, density, Prandtl number, and measured heat transfer coefficient."
996+
- text:
997+
en: "With such data, you can analyze whether changes in viscosity causally influence heat transfer performance (possibly mediated through the Prandtl number)."
953998
- text:
954-
en: "All the data is in a big excel sheet. Do you really think it would be appropriate to share with the GMCI community?"
999+
en: "I am considering sharing this dataset with the GMCI community. However, can you tell me, if data files can be versioned?"
9551000
responses:
9561001
- text:
9571002
en: "I am not sure."
9581003
thenText:
959-
en: "Please ask the MaRDI help desk, if this kind of data is appropriate for the GMCI community. I will wait for you here."
1004+
en: "Please ask the MaRDI help desk, if data files can be versioned in the GMCI community. I will wait for you here."
9601005
- text:
961-
en: "Your data is not suitable."
1006+
en: "No, data files cannot be versioned."
9621007
thenText:
963-
en: "You are right. The data is more algorithm evaluation than causal inference."
1008+
en: "This doesn't sound right. MaRDI is using a modern approach, I am pretty sure that data files can be versioned in the GMCI community. Please ask the MaRDI help desk, I will wait for you here."
9641009
- text:
965-
en: "Your data is perfect for the GMCI community."
1010+
en: "Yes, data files can be versioned."
9661011
thenText:
967-
en: "Well, actually, I don't think so. It is more algorithm evaluation than causal inference, so not suitable for the GMCI community."
968-
- text:
969-
en: "Yes, an excel sheet is fine."
970-
thenText:
971-
en: "I was more worried about the data itself. Please ask the MaRDI help desk, if this kind of data is appropriate for the GMCI community."
972-
MathPerson2:
973-
- type: sequence
974-
items:
975-
- text:
976-
en: "I have a simulation dataset that includes variables such as fluid viscosity, thermal conductivity, density, Prandtl number, and measured heat transfer coefficient."
977-
- text:
978-
en: "With such data, you can analyze whether changes in viscosity causally influence heat transfer performance (possibly mediated through the Prandtl number)."
979-
- text:
980-
en: "I am happy to share this dataset with the GMCI community."
981-
set: [ 'op.data.math2' ]
1012+
en: "Great! I will share my dataset with the GMCI community. Versioning is important for datasets, because it allows to track changes, revert to previous versions if needed, and maintain a history of the dataset's evolution."
1013+
set: [ 'op.data.math2' ]
9821014
webBrowser:
9831015
- text:
9841016
en: "Where do you want to go?"
@@ -1017,12 +1049,28 @@ quests:
10171049
en: "What is 'Graphical Modelling and Causal Inference'?"
10181050
then: gmci
10191051
- text:
1020-
en: "How is ownership handled in the GMCI community?"
1021-
thenText: "When uploading to the community no ownership rights are transferred as well as no licence transfer. The dataset will be attributed to you as the contributor, and you will retain ownership of your data."
1052+
en: "I have a different question."
1053+
then: more
10221054
- text:
10231055
en: "No, I am all set, thank you!"
10241056
thenText:
10251057
en: "Great! Come back anytime if you have more questions."
1058+
- id: more
1059+
type: sequence
1060+
items:
1061+
- text:
1062+
en: "Please ask your question, and I will do my best to answer it or find the right person to answer it for you."
1063+
responses:
1064+
- text:
1065+
en: "How is ownership handled in the GMCI community?"
1066+
thenText: "When uploading to the community no ownership rights are transferred as well as no licence transfer. The dataset will be attributed to you as the contributor, and you will retain ownership of your data."
1067+
- text:
1068+
en: "Can the data files be versioned?"
1069+
thenText: "Yes, data files can be versioned. You can maintain a history of changes and ensure that users can access the most up-to-date version of your dataset while still preserving the original version for reference."
1070+
- text:
1071+
en: "I don't have any more questions, thank you!"
1072+
thenText:
1073+
en: "Great! Come back anytime if you have more questions."
10261074
- id: gmci
10271075
type: sequence
10281076
items:
@@ -1032,6 +1080,8 @@ quests:
10321080
en: "It allows researchers to distinguish correlation from causation and to answer questions like “What happens if we change X?” by modeling explicit cause–effect structures."
10331081
- text:
10341082
en: "Suppose we draw a simple graph: Rain → Wet Ground. Graphical modelling represents this relationship with an arrow, and causal inference lets us ask: 'If we could make it rain, would the ground become wet?'"
1083+
- text:
1084+
en: "It is not simply plotting data and observing that two variables move together without modeling whether one actually causes the other. Such data would not be suitable for the GMCI community."
10351085
MathPerson3:
10361086
- type: sequence
10371087
items:
Lines changed: 39 additions & 0 deletions
Loading

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)