[HOW] WARNING:(W058) (lib_footprint_mismatch) Footprint 'CP_Radial_D6.3mm_P2.50mm' does not match copy in library

[crgarcia12]

What do you want to achieve?
I am getting many does not match copy in library error when running Kibot in a GitHub pipeline, but not when opening Kicad on my desktop:

Run INTI-CMNB/KiBot@v2_k9
  with:
    config: PCB/schematics-v26.1/kicad/kibot-configs/config.kibot.yaml
    dir: PCB/schematics-v26.1/kicad/fabrication/general
    schema: PCB/schematics-v26.1/kicad/hamodule.kicad_sch
    board: PCB/schematics-v26.1/kicad/hamodule.kicad_pcb
    quickstart: NO
    skip: __NONE__
    targets: __ALL__
    variant: __NONE__
    install3D: NO
    verbose: 0
    cache3D: NO
/usr/bin/docker run --name c426579c4b38b9d02dccdada2db0_46cbf6 --label 318231 --workdir /github/workspace --rm -e "INPUT_CONFIG" -e "INPUT_DIR" -e "INPUT_SCHEMA" -e "INPUT_BOARD" -e "INPUT_QUICKSTART" -e "INPUT_SKIP" -e "INPUT_TARGETS" -e "INPUT_VARIANT" -e "INPUT_INSTALL3D" -e "INPUT_VERBOSE" -e "INPUT_ADDITIONAL_ARGS" -e "INPUT_CACHE3D" -e "HOME" -e "GITHUB_JOB" -e "GITHUB_REF" -e "GITHUB_SHA" -e "GITHUB_REPOSITORY" -e "GITHUB_REPOSITORY_OWNER" -e "GITHUB_REPOSITORY_OWNER_ID" -e "GITHUB_RUN_ID" -e "GITHUB_RUN_NUMBER" -e "GITHUB_RETENTION_DAYS" -e "GITHUB_RUN_ATTEMPT" -e "GITHUB_ACTOR_ID" -e "GITHUB_ACTOR" -e "GITHUB_WORKFLOW" -e "GITHUB_HEAD_REF" -e "GITHUB_BASE_REF" -e "GITHUB_EVENT_NAME" -e "GITHUB_SERVER_URL" -e "GITHUB_API_URL" -e "GITHUB_GRAPHQL_URL" -e "GITHUB_REF_NAME" -e "GITHUB_REF_PROTECTED" -e "GITHUB_REF_TYPE" -e "GITHUB_WORKFLOW_REF" -e "GITHUB_WORKFLOW_SHA" -e "GITHUB_REPOSITORY_ID" -e "GITHUB_TRIGGERING_ACTOR" -e "GITHUB_WORKSPACE" -e "GITHUB_ACTION" -e "GITHUB_EVENT_PATH" -e "GITHUB_ACTION_REPOSITORY" -e "GITHUB_ACTION_REF" -e "GITHUB_PATH" -e "GITHUB_ENV" -e "GITHUB_STEP_SUMMARY" -e "GITHUB_STATE" -e "GITHUB_OUTPUT" -e "RUNNER_OS" -e "RUNNER_ARCH" -e "RUNNER_NAME" -e "RUNNER_ENVIRONMENT" -e "RUNNER_TOOL_CACHE" -e "RUNNER_TEMP" -e "RUNNER_WORKSPACE" -e "ACTIONS_RUNTIME_URL" -e "ACTIONS_RUNTIME_TOKEN" -e "ACTIONS_CACHE_URL" -e "ACTIONS_RESULTS_URL" -e GITHUB_ACTIONS=true -e CI=true -v "/var/run/docker.sock":"/var/run/docker.sock" -v "/home/runner/work/_temp/_github_home":"/github/home" -v "/home/runner/work/_temp/_github_workflow":"/github/workflow" -v "/home/runner/work/_temp/_runner_file_commands":"/github/file_commands" -v "/home/runner/work/electronics-homeassistant-lightscontroll/electronics-homeassistant-lightscontroll":"/github/workspace" 318231:1816c426579c4b38b9d02dccdada2db0  "-c PCB/schematics-v26.1/kicad/kibot-configs/config.kibot.yaml" "-C NO" "-d PCB/schematics-v26.1/kicad/fabrication/general" "-b PCB/schematics-v26.1/kicad/hamodule.kicad_pcb" "-e PCB/schematics-v26.1/kicad/hamodule.kicad_sch" "-i NO" "-q NO" "-s __NONE__" "-t __ALL__" "-v 0" "-V __NONE__" "-x "
*****************************************************************************************
*****************************************************************************************

KKKKKKKKK    KKKKKKK  iiii  BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB                             tttt
K:::::::K    K:::::K i::::i B::::::::::::::::B                         ttt:::t
K:::::::K    K:::::K  iiii  B::::::BBBBBB:::::B                        t:::::t
K:::::::K   K::::::K        BB:::::B     B:::::B                       t:::::t
KK::::::K  K:::::KKKiiiiiii   B::::B     B:::::B   ooooooooooo   ttttttt:::::ttttttt
  K:::::K K:::::K   i:::::i   B::::B     B:::::B oo:::::::::::oo t:::::::::::::::::t
  K::::::K:::::K     i::::i   B::::BBBBBB:::::B o:::::::::::::::ot:::::::::::::::::t
  K:::::::::::K      i::::i   B:::::::::::::BB  o:::::ooooo:::::otttttt:::::::tttttt
  K:::::::::::K      i::::i   B::::BBBBBB:::::B o::::o     o::::o      t:::::t
  K::::::K:::::K     i::::i   B::::B     B:::::Bo::::o     o::::o      t:::::t
  K:::::K K:::::K    i::::i   B::::B     B:::::Bo::::o     o::::o      t:::::t
KK::::::K  K:::::KKK i::::i   B::::B     B:::::Bo::::o     o::::o      t:::::t    tttttt
K:::::::K   K::::::Ki::::::iBB:::::BBBBBB::::::Bo:::::ooooo:::::o      t::::::tttt:::::t
K:::::::K    K:::::Ki::::::iB:::::::::::::::::B o:::::::::::::::o      tt::::::::::::::t
K:::::::K    K:::::Ki::::::iB::::::::::::::::B   oo:::::::::::oo         tt:::::::::::tt
KKKKKKKKK    KKKKKKKiiiiiiiiBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB      ooooooooooo             ttttttttttt

🤖 KiBot GitHub Action v2 🚀

KiBot: 1.8.4
KiCad: 9.0.1+dfsg-1~bpo12+1
Debian: 12.7
KiAuto: 2.3.5
KiCost 1.1.20
iBoM: 2.10.0

*****************************************************************************************
*****************************************************************************************
Options: -c 'PCB/schematics-v26.1/kicad/kibot-configs/config.kibot.yaml' -d 'PCB/schematics-v26.1/kicad/fabrication/general' -b 'PCB/schematics-v26.1/kicad/hamodule.kicad_pcb' -e 'PCB/schematics-v26.1/kicad/hamodule.kicad_sch'
WARNING:(W143) The `ignore_unconnected` preflight is deprecated, use the `ignore_unconnected` option (kibot.pre_ignore_unconnected - pre_ignore_unconnected.py:26)
WARNING:(W143) For KiCad 8 use the `erc` preflight instead of `run_erc` (kibot.pre_run_erc - pre_run_erc.py:77)
- Running the ERC
WARNING:(W058) 3 ERC warnings detected (eeschema_do - eeschema_do:629) (kibot - kiplot.py:134)
WARNING:(W058) (lib_symbol_issues) Symbol 'LD1117V33' not found in symbol library 'Regulator_Linear'
    ; warning
    @(0.6096 mm, 0.7747 mm): Symbol U1 [LD1117V33]
 (eeschema_do.kiauto.file_util - file_util.py:154) (kibot - kiplot.py:134)
WARNING:(W058) (four_way_junction) Four items connected at 609600, 1181100
    ; warning
    @(0.6096 mm, 1.1811 mm): Symbol J3 Pin A4 [VBUS, Passive, Line]
    @(0.6096 mm, 1.1811 mm): Symbol J3 Hidden pin A9 [VBUS, Passive, Line]
 (eeschema_do.kiauto.file_util - file_util.py:154) (kibot - kiplot.py:134)
WARNING:(W058) (four_way_junction) Four items connected at 457200, 1562100
    ; warning
    @(0.4572 mm, 1.5621 mm): Symbol J3 Pin A1 [GND, Passive, Line]
    @(0.4572 mm, 1.5621 mm): Symbol J3 Hidden pin A12 [GND, Passive, Line]
 (eeschema_do.kiauto.file_util - file_util.py:154) (kibot - kiplot.py:134)
WARNING:(W143) For KiCad 8 use the `drc` preflight instead of `run_drc` (kibot.pre_run_drc - pre_run_drc.py:81)
- Running the DRC
ERROR:Found 0 DRC errors and 9 unconnected pad/s or warnings (pcbnew_do - pcbnew_do:1485) (kibot - kiplot.py:131)
WARNING:(W058) (lib_footprint_mismatch) Footprint 'TO-220-3_Vertical' does not match copy in library 'Package_TO_SOT_THT'.; Severity: warning
    @(37.1187 mm, 97.7392 mm): Footprint U1
 (pcbnew_do.kiauto.file_util - file_util.py:154) (kibot - kiplot.py:134)
WARNING:(W058) (lib_footprint_mismatch) Footprint 'SOIC-18W_7.5x11.6mm_P1.27mm' does not match copy in library 'Package_SO'.; Severity: warning
    @(61.92 mm, 88.15 mm): Footprint U11
 (pcbnew_do.kiauto.file_util - file_util.py:154) (kibot - kiplot.py:134)
WARNING:(W058) (lib_footprint_mismatch) Footprint 'CP_Radial_D6.3mm_P2.50mm' does not match copy in library 'Capacitor_THT'.; Severity: warning
    @(144.5 mm, 81.43 mm): Footprint C19
 (pcbnew_do.kiauto.file_util - file_util.py:154) (kibot - kiplot.py:134)
WARNING:(W058) (lib_footprint_mismatch) Footprint 'SOT-23-5' does not match copy in library 'Package_TO_SOT_SMD'.; Severity: warning
    @(85.8625 mm, 111.8768 mm): Footprint U10
 (pcbnew_do.kiauto.file_util - file_util.py:154) (kibot - kiplot.py:134)
WARNING:(W058) (lib_footprint_mismatch) Footprint 'CP_Radial_D6.3mm_P2.50mm' does not match copy in library 'Capacitor_THT'.; Severity: warning
    @(54.2 mm, 95.617621 mm): Footprint C18
 (pcbnew_do.kiauto.file_util - file_util.py:154) (kibot - kiplot.py:134)
WARNING:(W058) (lib_footprint_mismatch) Footprint 'TSSOP-24_4.4x7.8mm_P0.65mm' does not match copy in library 'Package_SO'.; Severity: warning
    @(84.1375 mm, 91.075 mm): Footprint U12
 (pcbnew_do.kiauto.file_util - file_util.py:154) (kibot - kiplot.py:134)
WARNING:(W058) (lib_footprint_mismatch) Footprint 'TSSOP-24_4.4x7.8mm_P0.65mm' does not match copy in library 'Package_SO'.; Severity: warning
    @(93.8125 mm, 91.075 mm): Footprint U9
 (pcbnew_do.kiauto.file_util - file_util.py:154) (kibot - kiplot.py:134)
WARNING:(W058) (lib_footprint_mismatch) Footprint 'SOT-23-6' does not match copy in library 'Package_TO_SOT_SMD'.; Severity: warning
    @(102.485402 mm, 104.229699 mm): Footprint U2
 (pcbnew_do.kiauto.file_util - file_util.py:154) (kibot - kiplot.py:134)
WARNING:(W058) (lib_footprint_mismatch) Footprint 'CP_Radial_D6.3mm_P2.50mm' does not match copy in library 'Capacitor_THT'.; Severity: warning
    @(37.8 mm, 101.617621 mm): Footprint C12
 (pcbnew_do.kiauto.file_util - file_util.py:154) (kibot - kiplot.py:134)
ERROR:DRC violations: 9 (kibot.gs - gs.py:899)

The footprints in the PCBNew are updated:

WARNING:(W058) (lib_footprint_mismatch) Footprint 'CP_Radial_D6.3mm_P2.50mm' does not match copy in library 'Capacitor_THT'.; Severity: warning
    @(37.8 mm, 101.617621 mm): Footprint C12
 (pcbnew_do.kiauto.file_util - file_util.py:154) (kibot - kiplot.py:134)
ERROR:DRC violations: 9 (kibot.gs - gs.py:899)

I noticed that Kibot uses Kicad 9.0.1 and I am using 9.0.3. Could that be a problem?

🤖 KiBot GitHub Action v2 🚀

KiBot: 1.8.4
KiCad: 9.0.1+dfsg-1~bpo12+1
Debian: 12.7
KiAuto: 2.3.5
KiCost 1.1.20
iBoM: 2.10.0

Do you have some PCB/Schematic to use as example?
https://github.com/crgarcia12/electronics-homeassistant-lightscontroll/tree/main/PCB/schematics-v26.1

Do you have some configuration file (.kibot.yaml) that you are using?

# Example KiBot config file
kibot:
  version: 1

preflight:
  run_erc: true
  run_drc: true
  check_zone_fills: true
  ignore_unconnected: false

global:
  # We want the revision added to the names for this project
  output: '%f-%i_%r.%x'
  kiauto_time_out_scale: 10

import:
  - JLCPCB.kibot.yaml

filters:
 - name: 'exclude_any'
   type: 'generic'
   comment: 'Exclude logos, testpoints, fiducials and power'
   exclude_any:
     - column: Reference
       regex: '^(G|#|TP|F).*'

outputs:
  - name: 'print_sch'
    comment: "Print schematic (PDF)"
    type: pdf_sch_print
    dir: .

  - name: 'print_front'
    comment: "Print F.Cu+Dwgs.User"
    type: pdf_pcb_print
    dir: .
    layers:
      - layer: F.Cu
      - layer: Dwgs.User

  - name: 'print_bottom'
    comment: "Print B.Cu+Dwgs.User"
    type: pdf_pcb_print
    dir: .
    layers:
      - layer: B.Cu
      - layer: Dwgs.User

  - name: 'interactive_bom'
    comment: "Interactive Bill of Materials (HTML)"
    type: ibom
    dir: BoM
    options:
      blacklist: 'DNF*'

  - name: 'bom_html'
    comment: "Bill of Materials in HTML format"
    type: bom
    dir: BoM
    options: &bom_options
      columns:
        - Row
        - field: References
          name: Referencias
        - field: Part
          name: Parte
        - field: Value
          name: Valor
        - field: JLCPCB
          name: JLCPCB
        - field: manf#
          name: P/N
        - field: manf
          name: Fabricante
        - field: digikey#
          name: 'Cod. Digi-Key'
        - Footprint
        - field: Desc
          name: Descripción
        - 'Quantity Per PCB'
      group_fields:  ['digikey#', 'Part']
      normalize_values: true
      normalize_locale: true
      exclude_filter: 'exclude_any'
      html:
        digikey_link: 'digikey#'
        highlight_empty: false

  - name: 'bom_xlsx'
    comment: "Bill of Materials in XLSX format"
    type: bom
    dir: BoM
    options:
      <<: *bom_options
      format: XLSX
      xlsx:
        digikey_link: 'digikey#'
        highlight_empty: false

  - name: 'bom_csv'
    comment: "Bill of Materials in CSV format"
    type: bom
    dir: BoM
    options:
      <<: *bom_options
      format: CSV

  - name: 'gerbers'
    comment: "Gerbers for the board house"
    type: gerber
    dir: Gerbers
    options:
      # generic layer options
      exclude_edge_layer: true
      exclude_pads_from_silkscreen: false
      use_aux_axis_as_origin: false
      plot_sheet_reference: false
      plot_footprint_refs: true
      plot_footprint_values: true
      force_plot_invisible_refs_vals: false
      tent_vias: true

      # gerber options
      line_width: 0.1
      subtract_mask_from_silk: false
      use_protel_extensions: false
      gerber_precision: 4.6
      create_gerber_job_file: true
      use_gerber_x2_attributes: true
      use_gerber_net_attributes: true

    layers:
      - layer: F.Cu
        suffix: F_Cu
      - layer: In1.Cu
        suffix: In1_Cu
      - layer: In2.Cu
        suffix: In2_Cu
      - layer: B.Cu
        suffix: B_Cu
      - layer: F.SilkS
        suffix: F_SilkS
      - layer: B.SilkS
        suffix: B_SilkS
      - layer: F.Mask
        suffix: F_Mask
      - layer: B.Mask
        suffix: B_Mask
      - layer: Edge.Cuts
        suffix: Edge_Cuts

  - name: excellon_drill
    comment: "Excellon drill files"
    type: excellon
    dir: Drill
    options:
      metric_units: false
      pth_and_npth_single_file: false
      use_aux_axis_as_origin: false
      minimal_header: false
      mirror_y_axis: false
      report:
        filename: 'spora-drl.rpt'
      map:
        type: 'pdf'

  - name: gerber_drills
    comment: "Gerber drill files"
    type: gerb_drill
    dir: Drill
    options:
      use_aux_axis_as_origin: false

  - name: 'position'
    comment: "Pick and place file"
    type: position
    dir: Position
    options:
      format: CSV   # CSV or ASCII format
      units: millimeters  # millimeters or inches
      separate_files_for_front_and_back: true
      only_smd: true

  - name: pcb_top_g
    comment: "PCB render top green"
    type: pcbdraw
    dir: PCB/green
    options:
      format: jpg
      show_components: none
      dpi: 600

  - name: pcb_bot_g
    comment: "PCB render bottom green"
    type: pcbdraw
    dir: PCB/green
    options:
      format: jpg
      bottom: True
      show_components: none
      dpi: 600

  - name: pcb_top_b
    comment: "PCB render top blue"
    type: pcbdraw
    dir: PCB/blue
    options:
      format: jpg
      style: set-blue-enig
      show_components: none
      dpi: 600

  - name: pcb_bot_b
    comment: "PCB render bottom blue"
    type: pcbdraw
    dir: PCB/blue
    options:
      format: jpg
      style: set-blue-enig
      bottom: True
      show_components: none
      dpi: 600

  - name: pcb_top_r
    comment: "PCB render top red"
    type: pcbdraw
    dir: PCB/red
    options:
      format: jpg
      style: set-red-enig
      show_components: none
      dpi: 600

  - name: pcb_bot_r
    comment: "PCB render bottom red"
    type: pcbdraw
    dir: PCB/red
    options:
      format: jpg
      style: set-red-enig
      bottom: True
      show_components: none
      dpi: 600

  - name: step
    comment: "Generate 3D model (STEP)"
    type: step
    dir: 3D
    options:
      metric_units: true
      origin: 85,66.2

  - name: render_3d
    comment: "Generate 3D model (IMG)"
    type: render_3d
    dir: 3D-img
    options:
      download: true

Github Action pipeline

name: production-files

on:
  push:
    paths:
    - '**.sch'
    - '**.kicad_pcb'
    - '**.yaml'
  pull_request:
    paths:
      - '**.sch'
      - '**.kicad_pcb'
      - '**.yaml'
  workflow_dispatch:

permissions:
  contents: read
  actions: write

jobs:
  production-files-4:
    runs-on: ubuntu-latest
    steps:
    - uses: actions/checkout@v4
    - uses: INTI-CMNB/KiBot@v2_k9
      name: generating files for v26.1
      with:
        # Required - kibot config file
        config: PCB/schematics-v26.1/kicad/kibot-configs/config.kibot.yaml 
        # optional - prefix to output defined in config
        dir: PCB/schematics-v26.1/kicad/fabrication/general
        # optional - schematic file
        schema: 'PCB/schematics-v26.1/kicad/hamodule.kicad_sch'
        # optional - PCB design file
        board: 'PCB/schematics-v26.1/kicad/hamodule.kicad_pcb'
    - name: upload results for v26.1
      uses: actions/upload-artifact@v4
      with:
        name: output-4-channels-PCB-v26.1
        path: PCB/schematics-v26.1/kicad/fabrication/general

Environment (please complete the following information):
Where are you running KiBot:

• In a CI/CD workflow? GitHub
• In a GitHub action? Which tag are you using? INTI-CMNB/KiBot@v2_k9
• Using a desktop system? Windows 11

Additional context
Full project: https://github.com/crgarcia12/electronics-homeassistant-lightscontroll/tree/main/PCB/schematics-v26.1

[set-soft]

Hi @crgarcia12 !

Minor versions releases of KiCad shouldn't do massive changes to the libs, but it does. I don't agree with the KiCad maintainers policy of backporting patches from the development branch to minor releases. This introduces tons of bugs.

The solution is quite simple: disable or filter the warnings about footprint mismatches.

I'm testing KiCad 9.0.3, but it seems to introduce bugs. Is hard to determine because it draws some things different. This is sad, but KiCad changes too much stuff from one minor release to another.

[set-soft]

KiCad 9.0.3 and 9.0.4 has a major bug in the plotter:

https://gitlab.com/kicad/code/kicad/-/issues/21474

I won't bother in releasing images with it

[crgarcia12]

Si veo. Un desastre.
Quizas puedo dejar la version 9.0.0 de Kicad, hacer un git clone del repo de librerias, y cambiar las environment variables.
Crees que sera una buena idea?

[set-soft]

Es que lo más simple es crear un filtro para ignorar ese warning en GitHub.

Es una verificación muy débil que hace KiCad, por ejemplo: la reporta si cambiás el modelo 3D, lo cual en mi opinión no debería.

No todos los warnings que genera KiCad son útiles y no todos aplican en todas las situaciones. Es posible dejarlo habilitado en forma local (en el proyecto de KiCad), pero pedirle a KiBot que lo ignore.