Skip to content

Commit dd60731

Browse files
committed
Updating references and citations
1 parent 632ce76 commit dd60731

File tree

2 files changed

+43
-41
lines changed

2 files changed

+43
-41
lines changed

README.Rmd

Lines changed: 21 additions & 21 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -120,7 +120,7 @@ section 'Details on step 3').
120120

121121
Species occurrence records should be submitted to a data cleaning and validation
122122
process to make sure that only the data with a minimum quality will be used in
123-
the assessments. The `plantR` package (Lima et al. 2022) provides different
123+
the assessments. The `plantR` package (Lima et al. 2023) provides different
124124
tools to standardize the notation associated with species records and to
125125
validate the locality, geographical coordinates, taxonomic nomenclature and
126126
species identifications. It also includes tools for the retrieval and removal of
@@ -132,12 +132,12 @@ specimen duplicates across biological collections.
132132

133133
Different population metrics are necessary for applying the IUCN criteria A, B,
134134
C and D (criterion E is currently not considered in this workflow). A new
135-
version 2.0 of the `ConR` package (Dauby et al. 2017, Dauby & Lima 2022) was
135+
version 2.0 of the `ConR` package (Dauby et al. 2017, Dauby & Lima 2023) was
136136
developed to include new functions to calculate most of these metrics.
137137

138138
For criterion A, the `ConR` package provides a function for fitting
139139
statistical models to the population size vector to obtain the reductions at
140-
a specific point in time (`ConR::pop.decline.fit()`), based on linear,
140+
a specific point in time (`ConR::pop.decline()`), based on linear,
141141
exponential, quadratic, logistic and other trends of population decline
142142
through time. This is important because the time interval of population decline
143143
needed for the assessments of criterion A or C (10 years or one-, two- or
@@ -165,7 +165,7 @@ This step corresponds to the assignment of one of the IUCN Red List Categories
165165
obtained in the previous step against the IUCN quantitative thresholds and
166166
conditions. As mentioned above, specific functions were developed to assess the
167167
IUCN criteria A, B, C and D, which are freely available in the new version 2.0
168-
of the `ConR` R package (Dauby et al. 2017, Dauby & Lima 2022 - see functions
168+
of the `ConR` R package (Dauby et al. 2017, Dauby & Lima 2023 - see functions
169169
`ConR::criterion_A()`, `ConR::criterion_B()`, `ConR::criterion_C()` and
170170
`ConR::criterion_D()`). A specific function was also developed to tell apart NT
171171
from LC categories (see function `ConR::near.threatened()`).
@@ -270,16 +270,16 @@ species-specific proxies of DD. But the pertinence of this solution may vary
270270
according to the group of organism being assessed (e.g. sessile vs. mobile
271271
organisms).
272272

273-
Still related to criterion B, the quality of the geographical coordinates
274-
and the confidence in the species identifications can both impact the estimates
275-
of EOO and AOO. In THREAT, we only used geographically validated records for
276-
estimating these metrics, which is the standard procedure adopted by CNCFlora,
273+
Still related to criterion B, the quality of the geographical coordinates and
274+
the confidence in the species identifications can both impact the estimates of
275+
EOO and AOO. In THREAT, we only used geographically validated records for
276+
estimating these metrics, which is the standard procedure adopted by CNCFlora,
277277
the local Red List Authority. Concerning the confidence in the species
278278
identifications, we preferably conducted assessments based only on
279279
identifications vetted by plant taxonomists. However, for species with fewer
280-
records (< 75), we added extra records with lower taxonomic confidence levels
281-
based on their position with respect to the EOO of the species. We preferably added
282-
records inside or close to the species EOO.
280+
records (< 75), we added extra records with lower taxonomic confidence levels
281+
based on their position with respect to the EOO of the species. We preferably
282+
added records inside or close to the species EOO.
283283

284284
The final information needed to apply criterion B is the spatial extent (i.e.
285285
scale) of the impacts of threat events that can impact all individuals of
@@ -311,13 +311,13 @@ in this workflow, but currently, we decided not to apply the subcriterion D2.
311311
tabl <- "
312312
|Data Limitations/Uncertainties |Criteria |Metric impacted |Solution |
313313
|:----------------|:--------|:---------------|:--------|
314-
| Generation Length | A and C | Pop. size decline | Group-specific imputation |
315-
| Proportion of Mature Individuals | C and D | Pop. size | Group-specific Imputation |
316-
| Impact of harvest trends | A and C | Pop. size decline | Group-specific imputation |
317-
| Impact of habitat quality changes | A and C | Pop. size decline | Group-specific imputation |
314+
| Generation Length | A & C | Pop. size decline | Group-specific imputation |
315+
| Proportion of Mature Individuals | C & D | Pop. size | Group-specific Imputation |
316+
| Impact of harvest trends | A & C | Pop. size decline | Group-specific imputation |
317+
| Impact of habitat quality changes | A & C | Pop. size decline | Group-specific imputation |
318318
| Average Dispersal Distance | B1/B2 | Subpops./Fragmentation | Estimation from data |
319-
| Geographical coordinates of records | B1/B2 | EOO and AOO | Use only valid records |
320-
| Species identification of records | B1/B2 | EOO and AOO | Add extra records, if needed |
319+
| Geographical coordinates of records | B1/B2 | EOO & AOO | Use only valid records |
320+
| Species identification of records | B1/B2 | EOO & AOO | Add extra records, if needed |
321321
| Scale of threat events | B1/B2 | Number of locations | Set a fixed value |
322322
| Subpopulation limits | C2a(i)| Size of subpopulations | Subcriteria applied in few cases|
323323
| Future threats | D2 | - | Subcriteria not applied |
@@ -369,9 +369,9 @@ Please cite this repository as:
369369

370370
> **Renato A. F. de Lima, Gilles Dauby, André L. de Gasper, Eduardo P.
371371
Fernandez, Alexander C. Vibrans, Alexandre A. de Oliveira, Paulo I. Prado,
372-
Vinícius C. Souza, Marinez F. de Siqueira & Hans ter Steege. (2023).
373-
Comprehensive conservation assessments reveal high extinction risks across
374-
Atlantic Forest trees. Manuscript under review**
372+
Vinícius C. Souza, Marinez F. de Siqueira & Hans ter Steege. (2024).
373+
[Comprehensive conservation assessments reveal high extinction risks across
374+
Atlantic Forest trees](https://doi.org/10.1126/science.abq5099). Science. DOI: 10.1126/science.abq5099.**
375375

376376
### Funding
377377

@@ -402,7 +402,7 @@ conservation assessments using distribution data. Ecol. Evol. 7, 11292–11303
402402
(2017).
403403

404404
> G. Dauby, R. A. F. de Lima, ConR: Computation of Parameters Used in
405-
Preliminary Assessment of Conservation Status (R package version 2.0.0) (2022).
405+
Preliminary Assessment of Species Conservation Status (R package version 2.1) (2023).
406406

407407
> IUCN, Guidelines for application of IUCN Red List criteria at regional and
408408
national levels Version 4.0. (IUCN Species Survival Commission, 2012).

README.md

Lines changed: 22 additions & 20 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -120,7 +120,7 @@ assessments using criteria A and C (see section ‘Details on step 3’).
120120
Species occurrence records should be submitted to a data cleaning and
121121
validation process to make sure that only the data with a minimum
122122
quality will be used in the assessments. The `plantR` package (Lima et
123-
al. 2022) provides different tools to standardize the notation
123+
al. 2023) provides different tools to standardize the notation
124124
associated with species records and to validate the locality,
125125
geographical coordinates, taxonomic nomenclature and species
126126
identifications. It also includes tools for the retrieval and removal of
@@ -133,18 +133,18 @@ specimen duplicates across biological collections.
133133
Different population metrics are necessary for applying the IUCN
134134
criteria A, B, C and D (criterion E is currently not considered in this
135135
workflow). A new version 2.0 of the `ConR` package (Dauby et al. 2017,
136-
Dauby & Lima 2022) was developed to include new functions to calculate
136+
Dauby & Lima 2023) was developed to include new functions to calculate
137137
most of these metrics.
138138

139139
For criterion A, the `ConR` package provides a function for fitting
140140
statistical models to the population size vector to obtain the
141-
reductions at a specific point in time (`ConR::pop.decline.fit()`),
142-
based on linear, exponential, quadratic, logistic and other trends of
143-
population decline through time. This is important because the time
144-
interval of population decline needed for the assessments of criterion A
145-
or C (10 years or one-, two- or three-generation lengths - see IUCN
146-
2019) often does not correspond exactly to the observed population sizes
147-
for most species.
141+
reductions at a specific point in time (`ConR::pop.decline()`), based on
142+
linear, exponential, quadratic, logistic and other trends of population
143+
decline through time. This is important because the time interval of
144+
population decline needed for the assessments of criterion A or C (10
145+
years or one-, two- or three-generation lengths - see IUCN 2019) often
146+
does not correspond exactly to the observed population sizes for most
147+
species.
148148

149149
For criterion B, the `ConR` package provides functions for calculating
150150
the Extent of Occurrence (EOO - `ConR::EOO.computing()`), Area of
@@ -170,7 +170,7 @@ population metrics obtained in the previous step against the IUCN
170170
quantitative thresholds and conditions. As mentioned above, specific
171171
functions were developed to assess the IUCN criteria A, B, C and D,
172172
which are freely available in the new version 2.0 of the `ConR` R
173-
package (Dauby et al. 2017, Dauby & Lima 2022 - see functions
173+
package (Dauby et al. 2017, Dauby & Lima 2023 - see functions
174174
`ConR::criterion_A()`, `ConR::criterion_B()`, `ConR::criterion_C()` and
175175
`ConR::criterion_D()`). A specific function was also developed to tell
176176
apart NT from LC categories (see function `ConR::near.threatened()`).
@@ -327,13 +327,13 @@ THREAT workflow.
327327

328328
| Data Limitations/Uncertainties | Criteria | Metric impacted | Solution |
329329
|:------------------------------------|:---------|:-----------------------|:---------------------------------|
330-
| Generation Length | A and C | Pop. size decline | Group-specific imputation |
331-
| Proportion of Mature Individuals | C and D | Pop. size | Group-specific Imputation |
332-
| Impact of harvest trends | A and C | Pop. size decline | Group-specific imputation |
333-
| Impact of habitat quality changes | A and C | Pop. size decline | Group-specific imputation |
330+
| Generation Length | A & C | Pop. size decline | Group-specific imputation |
331+
| Proportion of Mature Individuals | C & D | Pop. size | Group-specific Imputation |
332+
| Impact of harvest trends | A & C | Pop. size decline | Group-specific imputation |
333+
| Impact of habitat quality changes | A & C | Pop. size decline | Group-specific imputation |
334334
| Average Dispersal Distance | B1/B2 | Subpops./Fragmentation | Estimation from data |
335-
| Geographical coordinates of records | B1/B2 | EOO and AOO | Use only valid records |
336-
| Species identification of records | B1/B2 | EOO and AOO | Add extra records, if needed |
335+
| Geographical coordinates of records | B1/B2 | EOO & AOO | Use only valid records |
336+
| Species identification of records | B1/B2 | EOO & AOO | Add extra records, if needed |
337337
| Scale of threat events | B1/B2 | Number of locations | Set a fixed value |
338338
| Subpopulation limits | C2a(i) | Size of subpopulations | Subcriteria applied in few cases |
339339
| Future threats | D2 | \- | Subcriteria not applied |
@@ -384,8 +384,10 @@ Please cite this repository as:
384384
> **Renato A. F. de Lima, Gilles Dauby, André L. de Gasper, Eduardo P.
385385
> Fernandez, Alexander C. Vibrans, Alexandre A. de Oliveira, Paulo I.
386386
> Prado, Vinícius C. Souza, Marinez F. de Siqueira & Hans ter Steege.
387-
> (2023). Comprehensive conservation assessments reveal high extinction
388-
> risks across Atlantic Forest trees. Manuscript under review**
387+
> (2024). [Comprehensive conservation assessments reveal high extinction
388+
> risks across Atlantic Forest
389+
> trees](https://doi.org/10.1126/science.abq5099). Science. DOI:
390+
> 10.1126/science.abq5099.**
389391
390392
### Funding
391393

@@ -419,8 +421,8 @@ repository.
419421
> data. Ecol. Evol. 7, 11292–11303 (2017).
420422
421423
> G. Dauby, R. A. F. de Lima, ConR: Computation of Parameters Used in
422-
> Preliminary Assessment of Conservation Status (R package version
423-
> 2.0.0) (2022).
424+
> Preliminary Assessment of Species Conservation Status (R package
425+
> version 2.1) (2023).
424426
425427
> IUCN, Guidelines for application of IUCN Red List criteria at regional
426428
> and national levels Version 4.0. (IUCN Species Survival Commission,

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)