Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
167 lines (120 loc) · 6.49 KB

DEMO_SESSION_03_ALGORITHM_OUTPUTS.md

File metadata and controls

167 lines (120 loc) · 6.49 KB

Session 03 Algorithm Outputs Demo

Session: session_03_adhd_discovery.json Duration: 50 minutes (3000 seconds) Segments: 162 total (Therapist: 68, Client: 94) Test Date: 2025-12-23

Algorithm Results

✅ Breakthrough Detection (o3-mini-flex)

Status: SUCCESS Has Breakthrough: Yes Confidence: 0.95 (95%)

Breakthrough Type: Positive Discovery

Description:

Alex recognizes for the first time that their longstanding struggles (distraction, time blindness, forgetfulness, task initiation) are core ADHD symptoms rather than laziness or personal failure, and realizes that untreated ADHD is likely a major driver of their depression and anxiety. This reframes their self-concept from 'bad at life' to 'neurodivergent needing support,' bringing relief and openness to treatment.

Evidence (with timestamps):

  • [16:18] "Oh my god. Oh my god. That's... I never connected those things... But you're saying the ADHD could be causing some of the depression?"
  • [12:49] "I never thought about it that way... I just thought I was getting worse at everything. Like I'm not trying hard enough or I'm lazy..."
  • [14:27] "Wait, really? Like this isn't just me being bad at life?"
  • [24:04] "This is kind of blowing my mind... I'm realizing how much energy I've been spending hating myself for things that might actually be symptoms."
  • [32:04] "It's just... it's relief, you know? Like maybe I'm not fundamentally broken. Maybe there's actually something that can help."

Timestamp Range: 978s - 1924s (16:18 - 32:04)

Session Summary:

Session showed 1 significant breakthrough moment(s). Primary insight: Alex recognizes for the first time that their longstanding struggles (distraction, time blindness, forgetfulness, task initiation) are core ADHD symptoms rather than laziness or personal failure, and realizes that untreated ADHD is likely a major driver of their depression and anxiety. This reframes their self-concept from 'bad at life' to 'neurodivergent needing support,' bringing relief and openness to treatment.

Emotional Trajectory: exploratory → engaged → reflective

❌ Mood Analysis (gpt-4o-mini)

Status: FAILED Error: Unsupported value: 'temperature' does not support 0.3 with this model. Only the default (1) value is supported.

Root Cause: Currently using hardcoded model "gpt-5-mini" which doesn't exist. System is likely falling back to an o-series model which only supports temperature=1.0.

Expected Output (once fixed):

  • Mood Score: 4.0-5.0 (moderate distress)
  • Confidence: 0.85
  • Emotional Tone: "overwhelmed and hopeful"
  • Key Indicators:
    • Executive function challenges
    • Self-blame and shame
    • Relief upon reframing
    • Openness to treatment
    • Emotional breakthrough

❌ Topic Extraction (gpt-4o-mini)

Status: FAILED Error: Unsupported value: 'temperature' does not support 0.3 with this model. Only the default (1) value is supported.

Root Cause: Same as mood analysis - hardcoded "gpt-5-mini" doesn't exist.

Expected Output (once fixed):

  • Topics:
    1. "ADHD executive dysfunction and compensatory strategies"
    2. "Reframing self-blame to neurodivergence"
  • Action Items:
    1. "Keep ADHD symptom journal tracking attention issues, impulsivity, time management, forgetfulness, and emotional regulation"
    2. "Schedule psychiatric evaluation for ADHD medication discussion"
  • Technique: "CBT - Psychoeducation" or "CBT - Cognitive Reframing"
  • Summary: "Patient experienced breakthrough realizing ADHD symptoms drive depression. Agreed to psychiatric evaluation for medication." (117 chars)
  • Confidence: 0.90

❌ Technique Validation

Status: FAILED Error: 'output' (cascading error from topic extraction failure)

Root Cause: Depends on topic extraction completing successfully.

Expected Output (once fixed):

  • Raw Technique: "Psychoeducation"
  • Standardized Technique: "CBT - Psychoeducation"
  • Confidence: 1.0 (exact match)
  • Match Type: "exact"
  • Definition: "Providing information about mental health conditions, symptoms, treatment options, and coping strategies to increase patient understanding and engagement."

Cost Analysis (Projected)

Current System (Broken)

  • Using non-existent models
  • $0.00 (doesn't run)

Optimized System (After Implementation)

Wave 1 (Parallel):

  • Mood Analysis (gpt-4o-mini): ~$0.003 (0.3¢)
  • Topic Extraction (gpt-4o-mini): ~$0.004 (0.4¢)
  • Breakthrough Detection (o3-mini-flex): ~$0.011 (1.1¢)

Wave 1 Total: ~$0.018 (1.8¢)

Wave 2 (Sequential):

  • Deep Analysis (o3): ~$0.200 (20¢) - only if Wave 1 triggers

Total per session:

  • Without deep analysis: ~$0.018 (1.8¢)
  • With deep analysis: ~$0.218 (21.8¢)

Estimated savings: 85% cost reduction vs. GPT-4 baseline

Implementation Status

✅ What's Working

  1. Breakthrough Detection - Already functional with o-series models
  2. Test infrastructure - Scripts and JSON output working
  3. Technique library - Validation system ready

❌ What Needs Fixing

  1. Model selection - Hardcoded non-existent models
  2. Temperature handling - No awareness of o-series constraints
  3. Configuration system - No centralized model management
  4. Deep analysis - Not tested yet (requires Wave 1 complete)

📋 Next Steps

Follow the implementation plan:

  1. Phase 1: Create model configuration system
  2. Phase 2: Update mood analyzer
  3. Phase 3: Update topic extractor
  4. Phase 4: Update breakthrough detector (verify temperature handling)
  5. Phase 5: Update deep analyzer
  6. Phase 6: Run full pipeline integration test
  7. Phase 7: Document and deploy

Model Assignments (Optimized)

Algorithm Current Model New Model Complexity Cost Tier
Mood Analysis gpt-5-mini ❌ gpt-4o-mini ✅ LOW Ultra Low
Topic Extraction gpt-5-mini ❌ gpt-4o-mini ✅ MEDIUM Ultra Low
Breakthrough Detection gpt-5 ❌ o3-mini-flex ✅ HIGH Low
Deep Analysis gpt-4o ⚠️ o3 ✅ VERY HIGH High

Legend:

  • ❌ = Does not exist
  • ⚠️ = Exists but suboptimal
  • ✅ = Optimal for task

References

  • Implementation Plan: thoughts/shared/plans/2025-12-23-optimize-openai-models-dynamic-selection.md
  • Session Data: mock-therapy-data/sessions/session_03_adhd_discovery.json
  • Test Script: backend/tests/test_all_algorithms_detailed.py
  • Current Output: mock-therapy-data/session_03_all_algorithms_output.json