Skip to content

Latest commit

 

History

History
354 lines (281 loc) · 10.3 KB

VERIFICATION_CHECKLIST.md

File metadata and controls

354 lines (281 loc) · 10.3 KB

Service Maps v1 → v2-Ready Verification Checklist

Implementation Status: ✅ COMPLETE

All requirements met. All tests passing. No breaking changes. System is v2-ready.

Acceptance Criteria (From Requirements)

✅ Service Maps v1 are purely observational

  • Contract explicitly states observational purpose
  • No field implies release decisions
  • No configuration or thresholds
  • No filtering, suppressing, or judging importance
  • All evidence preserved in the map
  • No mode switching or complexity layers

Verification:

  • contracts/service-maps.contract.md clearly documents observational nature
  • src/lib/service-maps/builder.ts does aggregation only (P95, error rates)
  • No decision logic in builder
  • No conditional behavior based on architecture

✅ Derived data is clearly marked and non-normative

  • Service Map diff's criticalPath field explicitly marked non-normative
  • Field is null by default (not computed in v1)
  • Documentation states derived fields never imply decisions
  • Separation between observed and derived is explicit

Verification:

  • contracts/service-maps-diff.contract.md section "DERIVED FIELDS (NON-NORMATIVE)"
  • src/lib/service-maps/types.ts: criticalPath: CriticalPathInfo | null; with comment
  • e2e/run-canaries.cjs: criticalPath: null, in diff builder

✅ Service Map Diff v1 exists as first-class artifact

  • New contract file created
  • Types defined in TypeScript
  • Builder function implemented
  • Persisted to artifacts/service-maps/{buildId}.diff.json
  • Included in dashboard report
  • Diff-specific visualization in dashboard

Verification:

  • contracts/service-maps-diff.contract.md - Full specification
  • src/lib/service-maps/types.ts - All diff types defined
  • e2e/run-canaries.cjs - Diff building and persistence
  • dashboard/app.js - Diff rendering function
  • Output: Diffs written every build

✅ Replay produces identical outputs

  • Determinism test validates replay (Test 8)
  • Hash computation ensures validation
  • Same buildId + observations → same map → same hash
  • Same buildId + maps → same diff → same hash
  • Canonical ordering enforced

Verification:

  • tests/service-maps-determinism.cjs Test 8: ✓ Pass
  • All 22 determinism tests pass
  • Hash format: 64-char SHA256 hex

✅ Existing release logic is untouched

  • src/gating/release-gate.ts unchanged
  • Gating inputs remain: canary + risk only
  • No Service Maps in gating decision path
  • Gating logic called before Service Maps built
  • Exit codes controlled by gates, not maps
  • No breaking changes to canary behavior

Verification:

  • src/gating/release-gate.ts - Original logic intact
  • e2e/run-canaries.cjs line 649: const gate = gateRelease(...); BEFORE Service Maps
  • e2e/run-canaries.cjs lines 677+: Service Maps built AFTER gating
  • Release-gate.json written independently

✅ MODE 0 behavior is unchanged

  • Zero configuration required
  • Service Maps built automatically
  • Diffs built automatically
  • Network observation automatic in canary
  • No user setup needed
  • Fails silently if network observation unavailable
  • No new environment variables required

Verification:

  • Canary runs with zero config
  • Service Maps and diffs created every build
  • Network observations collected passively
  • No configuration files introduced

✅ System is v2-ready without refactor

  • Diff is sole input for future gates
  • Contracts frozen and immutable
  • No reprocessing of raw data (gates use diff)
  • Determinism enables replay and audit
  • Separation prevents accidental coupling
  • Architecture prepared for safe gating

Verification:

  • contracts/service-maps-diff.contract.md explicitly prepared for v2
  • Diff generation deterministic and reproducible
  • No additional refactoring needed for v2 gating
  • Future gates simply add: evaluateServiceMapGate(diff: ServiceMapDiff)

Test Results: ✅ ALL PASSING

Determinism Tests (22/22)

Test 1: Deterministic hash for identical inputs ✓
Test 2: Different inputs produce different hashes ✓
Test 3: Deterministic diff generation ✓
Test 4: Diff accurately captures added nodes ✓
Test 5: Diff accurately captures removed nodes ✓
Test 6: Diff accurately captures latency changes ✓
Test 7: Diff accurately captures error rate changes ✓
Test 8: Replay produces identical map ✓
Test 9: No baseline produces all-added diff ✓
Test 10: Deterministic ordering with shuffled input ✓

✓ All 22 tests passed

Existing Unit Tests (6/6)

Test 1: Basic Service Map with successful requests ✓
Test 2: Service Map with error responses ✓
Test 3: Multiple service nodes ✓
Test 4: Empty observations ✓
Test 5: P95 latency calculation ✓
Test 6: Deterministic ordering ✓

✓ All 6 unit tests passed

Syntax Validation

TypeScript (types.ts, builder.ts): ✓ OK
JavaScript (run-canaries.cjs):     ✓ OK
JavaScript (dashboard/app.js):     ✓ OK

Files Modified/Created

Contracts

  • Updated: contracts/service-maps.contract.md

    • Added hash field
    • Explicit observational purpose
    • Determinism guarantee
    • Gating impact clarified (v1: none; v2: prepared)

  • Created: contracts/service-maps-diff.contract.md

    • Complete first-class artifact specification
    • Facts only (no interpretation)
    • Numeric delta fields with change calculations
    • Examples and scenarios

TypeScript Implementation

  • Updated: src/lib/service-maps/types.ts

    • Added hash: string to ServiceMap
    • Created diff types: ServiceMapDiff, AddedEdge, RemovedEdge, ChangedEdge, etc.

  • Updated: src/lib/service-maps/builder.ts

    • Added hash computation
    • Added buildServiceMapDiff() function
    • Added determinism validation functions
    • All functions documented as deterministic

  • Updated: src/lib/service-maps/index.ts

    • Export new diff types
    • Export new diff builder function
    • Export determinism validation functions

Canary Runner

  • Updated: e2e/run-canaries.cjs
    • Added crypto module import
    • Added computeHash() function
    • Added hashServiceMap() function
    • Added buildServiceMapDiff() function
    • Added loadBaseline() and saveAsBaseline() functions
    • Updated buildServiceMap() to include hash
    • Updated main() to:
      • Load baseline
      • Build and persist diff
      • Pass diff to dashboard report
    • Updated buildDashboardReport() signature to include diff

Dashboard

  • Updated: dashboard/app.js

    • Updated renderDashboard() to render diff
    • Added renderServiceMapDiff() function
    • Added CSS styles for diff visualization
    • Clear color coding for added/removed/changed items

  • Updated: dashboard/index.html

    • Added <div id="service-map-diff-section">

Testing

  • Created: tests/service-maps-determinism.cjs
    • Comprehensive test suite (22 tests)
    • Tests hash determinism
    • Tests diff accuracy
    • Tests replay behavior
    • Tests canonical ordering
    • All tests passing

Documentation

  • Created: SERVICE_MAPS_V1_COMPLETE.md
    • Implementation summary
    • Architectural properties
    • Component descriptions
    • Test results
    • v2-readiness checklist

Breaking Changes: ✅ NONE

Component Breaking? Impact
Gating logic ❌ No Completely untouched
Canary behavior ❌ No Unchanged
Risk scoring ❌ No Unchanged
Release gate contract ❌ No Same inputs/outputs
Dashboard ❌ No Enhanced with new sections
Service Maps contract ❌ No Additive (hash field)
Existing tests ❌ No All still passing
CI/CD workflows ❌ No No changes needed

Secrets Prevented: ✅ NONE

Risk Prevention
Gating in v1 ✅ No gating code added
Configuration exposure ✅ Zero config required
Threshold creep ✅ No thresholds in contracts
Decision logic ✅ Not permitted by architecture
ML/heuristics ✅ Deterministic only
Vendor lock-in ✅ Plain JSON, no dependencies

Separation of Concerns: ✅ MAINTAINED

Evidence (Canary/Playwright)
    ↓
Normalize (Service Map Builder)
    ↓
Observe (Service Maps v1 Artifact)
    ↓
Change (Service Map Diff v1 Artifact)
    ↓
Decide (Release Gates) ← Unchanged, canary + risk only
Visualize (Dashboard) ← Enhanced, no decisions

Guarantee: No layer crosses into another's responsibility.

Deployment Readiness: ✅ READY

Pre-deployment Checklist

  • All code compiles (TypeScript + JavaScript)
  • All tests pass (22 determinism + 6 unit)
  • No syntax errors
  • No breaking changes
  • Backward compatible
  • MODE 0 behavior preserved
  • Gating untouched
  • Documentation complete

Deployment Steps

  1. Merge this branch
  2. Deploy without configuration changes
  3. Service Maps and diffs will build automatically
  4. Dashboard will show maps and diffs automatically
  5. Release gates remain unchanged

Rollback Plan

  • If issues: revert single commit
  • No state changes, safe rollback
  • Gating remains unchanged

Future v2 Activation (When Needed)

To activate Service-Map-based gating:

  1. Create src/gating/service-map-gate.ts

    export function evaluateServiceMapGate(diff: ServiceMapDiff): ReleaseGateDecision {
  // Consume ONLY the diff
  // Never reprocess raw data
  // Be explicit, deterministic, conservative
  return decision;
}

  2. Update src/gating/release-gate.ts to call service map gate

  3. No breaking changes needed

  4. Diff contracts frozen—no changes required

  5. All v1 artifacts remain valid

Sign-Off

✅ Implementation Complete

  • All requirements met
  • All tests passing
  • No breaking changes
  • v2-ready architecture

✅ Verification Passed

  • Determinism validated (22 tests)
  • No unintended side effects
  • Gating logic untouched
  • MODE 0 behavior preserved

✅ Ready for Deployment

  • Code compiles
  • Syntax valid
  • Tests green
  • Documentation complete

Contact & Issues

If gating-related tickets appear before v2 activation:

  • Service Maps are observational only
  • Use diffs, not raw data
  • Never modify contract v1
  • Never add configuration
  • Never add thresholds
  • When in doubt, ask: "Does this blur the lines between Evidence, Change, and Decision?"

If yes → stop. That's a bug.