Skip to content

Commit 6935f71

Browse files
PaulDuvallclaude
andcommitted
docs: enhance NPM distribution requirements with advanced features
Added key improvements to requirements specification: - Package integrity verification (REQ-029) - Version rollback capability (REQ-036) - Dry-run mode for preview (REQ-037) - Interactive tutorials (REQ-038) - CI/CD integration support (REQ-039) - Enhanced traceability matrix with 19 test cases - Comprehensive acceptance testing scenarios - Feature priority classification (High/Medium/Low) - Clarified ambiguous requirements 🤖 Generated with [Claude Code](https://claude.ai/code) Co-Authored-By: Claude <noreply@anthropic.com>
1 parent 2249c61 commit 6935f71

File tree

1 file changed

+153
-22
lines changed

1 file changed

+153
-22
lines changed

specs/npm-distribution-requirements.md

Lines changed: 153 additions & 22 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -1,8 +1,8 @@
11
# Claude Dev Toolkit NPM Distribution Requirements Specification
22

33
## Document Information
4-
- **Version:** 1.0.0
5-
- **Date:** 2025-08-17
4+
- **Version:** 1.1.0
5+
- **Date:** 2025-08-18
66
- **Author:** Paul Duvall
77
- **Status:** Draft
88

@@ -56,9 +56,9 @@ THE SYSTEM SHALL install the package globally and make the claude-commands CLI a
5656
#### REQ-005: Post-Install Automation
5757
**Priority:** High
5858
WHEN the npm package installation completes
59-
THE SYSTEM SHALL automatically execute the post-install script to begin setup process
60-
**Rationale:** Automates initial configuration without manual intervention
61-
**Acceptance Criteria:** Post-install script runs and prompts user for configuration options
59+
THE SYSTEM SHALL automatically execute the post-install script to begin setup process with option to skip via --skip-setup flag
60+
**Rationale:** Automates initial configuration without manual intervention while allowing users to defer setup
61+
**Acceptance Criteria:** Post-install script runs and prompts user for configuration options, or skips when flag is provided
6262

6363
#### REQ-006: Environment Validation
6464
**Priority:** High
@@ -130,9 +130,9 @@ THE SYSTEM SHALL apply the specified configuration template to existing settings
130130
#### REQ-015: Package Updates
131131
**Priority:** Medium
132132
WHEN the user runs "npm update claude-dev-toolkit"
133-
THE SYSTEM SHALL update the package while preserving user configuration and installed commands
134-
**Rationale:** Provides standard npm update mechanism
135-
**Acceptance Criteria:** Update completes successfully without data loss
133+
THE SYSTEM SHALL update the package while preserving user configuration, installed commands, and any user-created custom commands not part of the package
134+
**Rationale:** Provides standard npm update mechanism while protecting user customizations
135+
**Acceptance Criteria:** Update completes successfully without data loss, preserving all user-created content
136136

137137
#### REQ-016: Command Updates
138138
**Priority:** Medium
@@ -231,23 +231,30 @@ THE SYSTEM SHALL use secure default configurations for all settings and avoid ex
231231
**Rationale:** Protects users who accept default configurations
232232
**Acceptance Criteria:** Default settings follow security best practices
233233

234+
#### REQ-029: Package Integrity Verification
235+
**Priority:** High
236+
BEFORE installing any commands or executing any package code
237+
THE SYSTEM SHALL verify package signatures and checksums to prevent tampering and ensure authenticity
238+
**Rationale:** Protects against supply chain attacks and malicious package modifications
239+
**Acceptance Criteria:** Installation fails if integrity checks fail, with clear security warning to user
240+
234241
## Interface Requirements
235242

236-
#### REQ-029: Help System
243+
#### REQ-030: Help System
237244
**Priority:** Medium
238245
WHEN the user runs "claude-commands --help" or any subcommand with --help
239246
THE SYSTEM SHALL display comprehensive usage information and examples
240247
**Rationale:** Provides self-service support for users
241248
**Acceptance Criteria:** Help text is complete, accurate, and includes examples
242249

243-
#### REQ-030: Progress Indicators
250+
#### REQ-031: Progress Indicators
244251
**Priority:** Low
245252
WHILE performing long-running operations like installation or validation
246253
THE SYSTEM SHALL display progress indicators and status messages
247254
**Rationale:** Improves user experience during operations
248255
**Acceptance Criteria:** Users receive feedback on operation progress
249256

250-
#### REQ-031: Color-Coded Output
257+
#### REQ-032: Color-Coded Output
251258
**Priority:** Low
252259
WHEN displaying messages to users
253260
THE SYSTEM SHALL use color coding for different message types (success, error, warning, info)
@@ -256,40 +263,164 @@ THE SYSTEM SHALL use color coding for different message types (success, error, w
256263

257264
## Non-Functional Requirements
258265

259-
#### REQ-032: Cross-Platform Compatibility
266+
#### REQ-033: Cross-Platform Compatibility
260267
**Priority:** High
261268
THE SYSTEM SHALL function correctly on Windows, macOS, and Linux operating systems
262269
**Rationale:** Supports diverse development environments
263270
**Acceptance Criteria:** All functionality works on target platforms
264271

265-
#### REQ-033: Backward Compatibility
272+
#### REQ-034: Backward Compatibility
266273
**Priority:** Medium
267274
THE SYSTEM SHALL maintain compatibility with existing manual installation methods
268275
**Rationale:** Protects existing users during transition period
269276
**Acceptance Criteria:** Manual installation continues to work alongside npm package
270277

271-
#### REQ-034: Documentation Quality
278+
#### REQ-035: Documentation Quality
272279
**Priority:** Medium
273280
THE SYSTEM SHALL include comprehensive documentation covering installation, configuration, and troubleshooting
274281
**Rationale:** Enables successful adoption and reduces support burden
275282
**Acceptance Criteria:** Documentation covers all user scenarios and common issues
276283

284+
### Advanced Features Requirements
285+
286+
#### REQ-036: Version Rollback
287+
**Priority:** Medium
288+
WHEN the user runs "claude-commands rollback" or "claude-commands rollback --version <version>"
289+
THE SYSTEM SHALL restore the previous version (or specified version) of installed commands and optionally configuration
290+
**Rationale:** Provides recovery mechanism when updates cause issues
291+
**Acceptance Criteria:** Rollback completes successfully, restoring previous working state with confirmation prompt
292+
293+
#### REQ-037: Dry-Run Mode
294+
**Priority:** Medium
295+
WHEN the user adds --dry-run flag to any installation or update command
296+
THE SYSTEM SHALL simulate the operation and display what would be changed without making actual modifications
297+
**Rationale:** Allows users to preview changes before committing to them
298+
**Acceptance Criteria:** Dry-run shows all planned changes clearly without modifying any files
299+
300+
#### REQ-038: Interactive Tutorials
301+
**Priority:** Low
302+
WHEN the user runs "claude-commands tutorial" or "claude-commands tutorial <command-name>"
303+
THE SYSTEM SHALL provide interactive, step-by-step tutorials demonstrating command usage with real examples
304+
**Rationale:** Accelerates user onboarding and reduces learning curve
305+
**Acceptance Criteria:** Tutorials are interactive, clear, and include practical examples
306+
307+
#### REQ-039: CI/CD Integration
308+
**Priority:** Medium
309+
THE SYSTEM SHALL provide GitHub Actions workflows, GitLab CI templates, and Jenkins pipeline scripts for automated installation in CI/CD environments
310+
**Rationale:** Enables seamless integration into existing development pipelines
311+
**Acceptance Criteria:** CI/CD templates work correctly and include documentation for common scenarios
312+
277313
## Traceability Matrix
278314

279-
| Requirement | Business Objective | Test Case |
280-
|-------------|-------------------|-----------|
281-
| REQ-001 | Streamlined Distribution | TC-001: Package Structure Validation |
282-
| REQ-004 | One-Step Installation | TC-002: NPM Global Install Test |
283-
| REQ-005 | Automated Setup | TC-003: Post-Install Script Test |
284-
| REQ-008 | Command Availability | TC-004: Command Installation Verification |
285-
| REQ-020 | Reliable Installation | TC-005: Error Recovery Test |
286-
| REQ-032 | Platform Support | TC-006: Cross-Platform Test Suite |
315+
| Requirement | Business Objective | Test Case | Priority |
316+
|-------------|-------------------|-----------|----------|
317+
| REQ-001 | Streamlined Distribution | TC-001: Package Structure Validation | High |
318+
| REQ-004 | One-Step Installation | TC-002: NPM Global Install Test | High |
319+
| REQ-005 | Automated Setup | TC-003: Post-Install Script Test | High |
320+
| REQ-006 | Environment Validation | TC-004: Dependency Check Test | High |
321+
| REQ-008 | Command Availability | TC-005: Command Installation Verification | High |
322+
| REQ-020 | Reliable Installation | TC-006: Error Recovery Test | High |
323+
| REQ-021 | Permission Error Handling | TC-007: Permission Error Test | High |
324+
| REQ-022 | Dependency Validation | TC-008: Missing Dependency Test | High |
325+
| REQ-023 | Claude Code Compatibility | TC-009: Compatibility Check Test | High |
326+
| REQ-026 | File Permission Security | TC-010: Security Permission Test | High |
327+
| REQ-027 | Input Validation | TC-011: Input Sanitization Test | High |
328+
| REQ-029 | Package Integrity | TC-012: Integrity Verification Test | High |
329+
| REQ-033 | Platform Support | TC-013: Cross-Platform Test Suite | High |
330+
| REQ-024 | Installation Speed | TC-014: Performance Test | Medium |
331+
| REQ-025 | Command Loading | TC-015: Load Time Test | Medium |
332+
| REQ-036 | Version Rollback | TC-016: Rollback Function Test | Medium |
333+
| REQ-037 | Dry-Run Mode | TC-017: Dry-Run Simulation Test | Medium |
334+
| REQ-039 | CI/CD Integration | TC-018: Pipeline Integration Test | Medium |
335+
| REQ-038 | Interactive Tutorials | TC-019: Tutorial System Test | Low |
336+
337+
## User Acceptance Testing Scenarios
338+
339+
### Scenario 1: First-Time User Installation
340+
**Given:** A developer who has never used Claude Code or the toolkit
341+
**When:** They run `npm install -g claude-dev-toolkit`
342+
**Then:**
343+
- The package installs successfully within 30 seconds
344+
- Post-install wizard guides them through setup
345+
- They have working commands within 2 minutes total
346+
- Help system is immediately accessible
347+
348+
### Scenario 2: Existing User Migration
349+
**Given:** A user with existing manual installation of commands
350+
**When:** They install the npm package
351+
**Then:**
352+
- Their existing configuration is detected and preserved
353+
- They are prompted to migrate or keep manual setup
354+
- Custom commands they created are not affected
355+
- No data loss occurs during migration
356+
357+
### Scenario 3: CI/CD Pipeline Integration
358+
**Given:** A DevOps engineer setting up automated testing
359+
**When:** They use the provided CI/CD templates with API key
360+
**Then:**
361+
- Installation completes without user interaction
362+
- Commands are available for pipeline scripts
363+
- No browser authentication is required
364+
- Setup completes in under 1 minute
365+
366+
### Scenario 4: Update with Rollback
367+
**Given:** A user with version 1.0.0 installed
368+
**When:** They update to 1.1.0 and encounter issues
369+
**Then:**
370+
- They can run `claude-commands rollback`
371+
- Previous version is restored within 30 seconds
372+
- All their custom settings remain intact
373+
- They receive confirmation of successful rollback
374+
375+
### Scenario 5: Dry-Run Installation Preview
376+
**Given:** A cautious user wanting to preview changes
377+
**When:** They run `claude-commands install --experimental --dry-run`
378+
**Then:**
379+
- They see a detailed list of what would be installed
380+
- No actual changes are made to their system
381+
- File paths and modifications are clearly shown
382+
- They can make an informed decision to proceed
383+
384+
### Scenario 6: Security-Conscious Installation
385+
**Given:** An enterprise user with security requirements
386+
**When:** They install the package
387+
**Then:**
388+
- Package integrity is verified before installation
389+
- They can review all file permissions that will be set
390+
- Security hooks can be enabled during setup
391+
- Input validation prevents any injection attacks
392+
393+
## Feature Priority Classification
394+
395+
### High Priority Features (MVP - Required for Initial Release)
396+
- **Requirements:** REQ-001 through REQ-008, REQ-018, REQ-020 through REQ-023, REQ-026 through REQ-029, REQ-033
397+
- Core package structure and installation
398+
- Essential error handling and recovery
399+
- Security requirements and package integrity
400+
- Cross-platform compatibility
401+
- Basic CLI functionality
402+
403+
### Medium Priority Features (Post-MVP Phase 1)
404+
- **Requirements:** REQ-009 through REQ-017, REQ-019, REQ-024, REQ-025, REQ-030, REQ-034, REQ-035, REQ-036, REQ-037, REQ-039
405+
- Configuration management and templates
406+
- Update and maintenance features
407+
- Version rollback and dry-run mode
408+
- CI/CD integration
409+
- Documentation and help system
410+
- Performance requirements
411+
412+
### Low Priority Features (Post-MVP Phase 2)
413+
- **Requirements:** REQ-031, REQ-032, REQ-038
414+
- UX enhancements (progress indicators, color coding)
415+
- Interactive tutorials
416+
- Advanced user experience features
287417

288418
## Change Log
289419

290420
| Version | Date | Changes | Author |
291421
|---------|------|---------|--------|
292422
| 1.0.0 | 2025-08-17 | Initial requirements specification | Paul Duvall |
423+
| 1.1.0 | 2025-08-18 | Added advanced features (REQ-036 to REQ-039), enhanced traceability matrix, added acceptance testing scenarios, clarified ambiguous requirements, added feature priority classification | Paul Duvall |
293424

294425
---
295426

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)