[FEATURE] Slack App Improvements #15999
Conversation
|
The latest updates on your projects. Learn more about Vercel for Git ↗︎ 3 Skipped Deployments
|
WalkthroughThe pull request refactors multiple Slack integration components by updating version numbers and replacing nested SDK method calls with direct ones. Additionally, many actions now support pagination through the addition of Changes
Sequence Diagram(s)sequenceDiagram
participant User
participant ListChannelsAction
participant SlackAPI
User->>ListChannelsAction: Trigger list-channels with pageSize & numPages
loop While next page exists and pageCount < numPages
ListChannelsAction->>SlackAPI: Request conversations list (with limit & cursor)
SlackAPI-->>ListChannelsAction: Return channels batch & next cursor
ListChannelsAction->>ListChannelsAction: Append channels and update cursor
end
ListChannelsAction->>User: Return complete list of channels
Assessment against linked issues
Suggested labels
Suggested reviewers
Poem
Warning There were issues while running some tools. Please review the errors and either fix the tool’s configuration or disable the tool if it’s a critical failure. 🔧 ESLint
components/slack/actions/kick-user/kick-user.mjsOops! Something went wrong! :( ESLint: 8.57.1 Error [ERR_MODULE_NOT_FOUND]: Cannot find package 'jsonc-eslint-parser' imported from /eslint.config.mjs components/slack/actions/invite-user-to-channel/invite-user-to-channel.mjsOops! Something went wrong! :( ESLint: 8.57.1 Error [ERR_MODULE_NOT_FOUND]: Cannot find package 'jsonc-eslint-parser' imported from /eslint.config.mjs components/slack/actions/get-file/get-file.mjsOops! Something went wrong! :( ESLint: 8.57.1 Error [ERR_MODULE_NOT_FOUND]: Cannot find package 'jsonc-eslint-parser' imported from /eslint.config.mjs
✨ Finishing Touches
🪧 TipsChatThere are 3 ways to chat with CodeRabbit:
Note: Be mindful of the bot's finite context window. It's strongly recommended to break down tasks such as reading entire modules into smaller chunks. For a focused discussion, use review comments to chat about specific files and their changes, instead of using the PR comments. CodeRabbit Commands (Invoked using PR comments)
Other keywords and placeholders
CodeRabbit Configuration File (
|
![coderabbitai[bot]](https://avatars.githubusercontent.com/in/347564?s=60&v=4){kind=small}
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 1
🧹 Nitpick comments (8)
components/slack/actions/list-files/list-files.mjs (1)
31-42: Addition ofpageSizeandnumPagesprops boosts pagination flexibility.These new props provide fine-grained control over file retrieval. Consider adding usage guidance or maximum safe limits to protect against excessive requests from unusually large inputs.
components/slack/actions/list-replies/list-replies.mjs (2)
29-34: Validate the upper bound fornumPages.
Consider capping the page count or providing a default ifnumPagesis undefined.
45-52: Consider adding rate-limit handling.
The do-while loop is fine, but Slack rate limiting might require retries or backoff to avoid errors for extensive pagination.components/slack/actions/list-members-in-channel/list-members-in-channel.mjs (2)
29-34: ValidatenumPagesusage.
Enforcing a practical limit could prevent excessive API calls.
44-52: Recommend rate-limit awareness.
Slack API calls in a do-while loop can trigger rate-limit errors on large channels. Consider adding retries or backoff strategies.components/slack/actions/list-channels/list-channels.mjs (2)
17-22: Check constraints onnumPages.
A bounded maximum helps avoid long-running loops.
25-38: Consider Slack rate-limit handling.
The do-while approach is effective for pagination, but large requests may hit Slack’s limits.components/slack/actions/list-group-members/list-group-members.mjs (1)
47-54: Implementing do...while pagination
The loop correctly checks forparams.cursorand limits the iteration count viapage < this.numPages. This approach should handle large user groups efficiently, assuming the Slack API honors the providedlimit.It may be helpful to check if
usersis returned and avoid pushingundefinedif the response is empty.
📜 Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
Plan: Pro
⛔ Files ignored due to path filters (1)
pnpm-lock.yamlis excluded by!**/pnpm-lock.yaml
📒 Files selected for processing (47)
components/slack/actions/add-emoji-reaction/add-emoji-reaction.mjs(2 hunks)components/slack/actions/approve-workflow/approve-workflow.mjs(2 hunks)components/slack/actions/archive-channel/archive-channel.mjs(2 hunks)components/slack/actions/common/send-message.mjs(1 hunks)components/slack/actions/create-channel/create-channel.mjs(2 hunks)components/slack/actions/create-reminder/create-reminder.mjs(2 hunks)components/slack/actions/delete-file/delete-file.mjs(2 hunks)components/slack/actions/delete-message/delete-message.mjs(2 hunks)components/slack/actions/find-message/find-message.mjs(1 hunks)components/slack/actions/find-user-by-email/find-user-by-email.mjs(2 hunks)components/slack/actions/get-file/get-file.mjs(2 hunks)components/slack/actions/invite-user-to-channel/invite-user-to-channel.mjs(2 hunks)components/slack/actions/kick-user/kick-user.mjs(2 hunks)components/slack/actions/list-channels/list-channels.mjs(1 hunks)components/slack/actions/list-files/list-files.mjs(3 hunks)components/slack/actions/list-group-members/list-group-members.mjs(2 hunks)components/slack/actions/list-members-in-channel/list-members-in-channel.mjs(2 hunks)components/slack/actions/list-replies/list-replies.mjs(2 hunks)components/slack/actions/list-users/list-users.mjs(2 hunks)components/slack/actions/reply-to-a-message/reply-to-a-message.mjs(1 hunks)components/slack/actions/send-block-kit-message/send-block-kit-message.mjs(1 hunks)components/slack/actions/send-large-message/send-large-message.mjs(2 hunks)components/slack/actions/send-message-advanced/send-message-advanced.mjs(1 hunks)components/slack/actions/send-message-to-channel/send-message-to-channel.mjs(1 hunks)components/slack/actions/send-message-to-user-or-group/send-message-to-user-or-group.mjs(1 hunks)components/slack/actions/send-message/send-message.mjs(1 hunks)components/slack/actions/set-channel-description/set-channel-description.mjs(2 hunks)components/slack/actions/set-channel-topic/set-channel-topic.mjs(2 hunks)components/slack/actions/set-status/set-status.mjs(2 hunks)components/slack/actions/update-group-members/update-group-members.mjs(2 hunks)components/slack/actions/update-message/update-message.mjs(2 hunks)components/slack/actions/update-profile/update-profile.mjs(2 hunks)components/slack/actions/upload-file/upload-file.mjs(2 hunks)components/slack/actions/verify-slack-signature/verify-slack-signature.mjs(1 hunks)components/slack/common/constants.mjs(1 hunks)components/slack/package.json(1 hunks)components/slack/slack.app.mjs(26 hunks)components/slack/sources/common/base.mjs(6 hunks)components/slack/sources/new-channel-created/new-channel-created.mjs(1 hunks)components/slack/sources/new-direct-message/new-direct-message.mjs(1 hunks)components/slack/sources/new-interaction-event-received/new-interaction-event-received.mjs(1 hunks)components/slack/sources/new-keyword-mention/new-keyword-mention.mjs(1 hunks)components/slack/sources/new-message-in-channels/new-message-in-channels.mjs(1 hunks)components/slack/sources/new-reaction-added/new-reaction-added.mjs(1 hunks)components/slack/sources/new-saved-message/new-saved-message.mjs(1 hunks)components/slack/sources/new-user-added/new-user-added.mjs(1 hunks)components/slack/sources/new-user-mention/new-user-mention.mjs(1 hunks)
⏰ Context from checks skipped due to timeout of 90000ms (3)
- GitHub Check: pnpm publish
- GitHub Check: Publish TypeScript components
- GitHub Check: Verify TypeScript components
🔇 Additional comments (148)
components/slack/package.json (1)
3-3: Version Bump to 0.9.2 Approved.
The version update in this file is correctly applied and aligns with the coordinated release across Slack components. Ensure that all dependent modules that reference this package are updated accordingly.components/slack/actions/find-message/find-message.mjs (1)
7-7: Version Update to 0.0.23 Confirmed.
The version bump to "0.0.23" is applied correctly. While no other changes were made in this file, please double-check that any consumers of this action are aware of the version‐update for compatibility purposes.components/slack/actions/send-block-kit-message/send-block-kit-message.mjs (1)
10-10: Version Bump to 0.4.4 Looks Good.
The version update to "0.4.4" is straightforward and consistent with similar changes in other Slack action modules. No issues observed; ensure that documentation reflects this update if necessary.components/slack/actions/verify-slack-signature/verify-slack-signature.mjs (1)
8-8: Signature Verification Version Update to 0.0.16 Confirmed.
The version change to "0.0.16" is correctly implemented. Since this module handles security-critical functionality, please ensure that sufficient tests validate the signature verification logic remains intact after these changes.components/slack/sources/new-keyword-mention/new-keyword-mention.mjs (1)
9-9: Version Update to 0.0.7 Approved.
The version bump in this source module is correctly updated to "0.0.7". Ensure that any downstream integrations consuming this source are aligned with this new version for proper event handling.components/slack/sources/new-user-mention/new-user-mention.mjs (1)
9-9: Version Update ConfirmationThe version has been updated to "0.0.7" to reflect the latest release. This metadata change is consistent with the overall versioning strategy and does not impact functionality.
components/slack/actions/send-message-to-channel/send-message-to-channel.mjs (1)
9-9: Module Version BumpThe version for this action is now "0.0.4", which aligns with the coordinated release updates. There are no changes to the logic or control flow.
components/slack/sources/new-direct-message/new-direct-message.mjs (1)
8-8: Direct Message Source Version UpdateThe version property has been updated to "1.0.22". This metadata change follows the consistent versioning pattern seen across similar modules, and no functional changes are introduced.
components/slack/sources/new-channel-created/new-channel-created.mjs (1)
8-8: New Channel Created Source Version IncrementThe version is now "0.0.9", reflecting a minor release update. The change is limited to the version metadata, with no modifications in the event handling or overall functionality.
components/slack/sources/new-user-added/new-user-added.mjs (1)
8-8: New User Added Version BumpThe version was updated from "0.0.2" to "0.0.3". This change ensures that the module’s release version is current while leaving its functionality intact.
components/slack/actions/send-message-to-user-or-group/send-message-to-user-or-group.mjs (1)
10-10: Version Update Verification
The version number has been updated to"0.0.4"as part of this release. This metadata change is consistent with other modules in the PR and does not affect functionality.components/slack/actions/send-message/send-message.mjs (1)
9-9: Version Bump Confirmation
The version field is now"0.0.19". This update is solely a metadata change for version tracking and aligns well with the coordinated version upgrades across the Slack actions.components/slack/sources/new-message-in-channels/new-message-in-channels.mjs (1)
9-9: Version Metadata Update
The version has been incremented to"1.0.24". This change is straightforward and helps maintain consistency with the release strategy. All other functionalities appear to be intact.components/slack/actions/send-message-advanced/send-message-advanced.mjs (1)
10-10: Version Bump Update
The version field is updated to"0.0.6". The change is limited to metadata and follows the same pattern as other Slack action modules in this PR.components/slack/sources/new-interaction-event-received/new-interaction-event-received.mjs (1)
6-6: Metadata Version Update
The version has been updated to"0.0.19", aligning with the overarching versioning strategy for Slack components. No functional changes are introduced by this metadata update.components/slack/actions/set-status/set-status.mjs (2)
7-7: Version bump correctly reflects changes.The version increment from 0.0.7 to 0.0.8 appropriately reflects the implementation changes in this action component.
33-40: Improved API interaction pattern.The refactoring from
this.slack.sdk().users.profile.settothis.slack.updateProfilesimplifies the code and creates a more consistent interface for Slack API interactions, while maintaining the same functionality.components/slack/sources/common/base.mjs (2)
88-93: Refactored API interactions are more maintainable.The code consistently replaces direct SDK method calls with wrapper methods (e.g.,
this.slack.sdk().users.info→this.slack.usersInfo), which improves readability and maintainability while preserving functionality.Also applies to: 97-102, 106-111, 115-123, 128-138
147-160:❓ Verification inconclusive
Inconsistent refactoring pattern.
Unlike other method calls in this file that were refactored to directly use methods on the
this.slackobject, this method still usesthis.slack.sdk().getConversationRepliesrather than something likethis.slack.getConversationReplies.Check if this inconsistency is intentional:
🏁 Script executed:
#!/bin/bash # Look for other instances of getConversationReplies in the codebase rg "getConversationReplies" --type js # Also check how other conversation-related methods are implemented rg "this\.slack\.(conversations|getConversation)" --type jsLength of output: 99
Refactoring Consistency Check for
getConversationRepliesThe implementation at lines 147–160 of
components/slack/sources/common/base.mjsuses:const response = await this.slack.sdk().getConversationReplies({ channel, ts, limit: 1, });This contrasts with other methods in the file that directly call methods on the
this.slackobject (e.g.,this.slack.getConversation...). Our initial searches for alternative patterns (such as a directthis.slack.getConversationReplies) returned no results. This leaves it unclear whether the current approach is intentional or if it represents an oversight during refactoring.Please verify manually that:
- There isn’t an intended direct method (e.g.
this.slack.getConversationReplies) that should be used instead.- If the use of
this.slack.sdk().getConversationRepliesis deliberate, consider adding an inline comment to clarify the design choice.components/slack/actions/reply-to-a-message/reply-to-a-message.mjs (1)
9-9: Version increment is appropriate.The version bump from 0.1.27 to 0.1.28 aligns with the broader refactoring effort across Slack components, even though this file doesn't contain functional changes.
components/slack/common/constants.mjs (1)
2-2:✅ Verification successful
Verify Slack API support for increased page size.
Increasing the
LIMITconstant from 200 to 250 will allow retrieving more items per request, potentially reducing the number of API calls needed for pagination. However, ensure this new limit is supported by Slack's API endpoints.
🌐 Web query:
What is the maximum page size (limit parameter) supported by Slack API methods?💡 Result:
The maximum page size (
limitparameter) supported by Slack API methods is 1,000 elements per request, though this varies by endpoint and is subject to change. Key details:General Guidelines:
- Most paginated methods allow a
limitof up to 1,000 items[10][13], but Slack strongly recommends using 100-200 items per page for reliability and performance[10][16].- Methods like
users.listandconversations.listsupport this maximum, though exceeding 200 items/pagination cycle risks triggering rate limits (Tier 2: 20+ req/min)[1][2].Key Considerations:
Rate Limits:
Pagination uses tiered rate limits:
- Tier 2 (common for list methods): 20+ requests/minute[1]
- Tier 3: 50+ requests/minute[1]
Fetching 1,000 items/page with Tier 2 would require ≤20 pages/minute (≤20k items/min).
Performance Tradeoffs:
Largerlimitvalues consume more memory and increase error risk during high-load periods[2][13]. Slack's cursor-based pagination optimizes efficiency when using smaller batches[10][17].Method-Specific Limits:
Method Max limitNotes files.info1,000 Max 200 recommended[13] users.list1,000 Rate-limited to 20 req/min (Tier 2)[1][16] conversations.history1,000 Performance degrades with large pages[10] Best Practices:
- Default to
limit=200unless handling exceptionally large datasets[10][16].- Use cursor pagination instead of offset pagination for stability[10][17].
- Implement retry logic with
Retry-Afterheaders on HTTP 429 errors[1][2].For example, cursor-paginated requests would follow this pattern:
GET /api/users.list?limit=200&cursor=dXNlcjpVMEc5V0ZYTlo%3D Authorization: Bearer xoxb-...The limit cap enables scalability while balancing API reliability and workspace performance[1][10]. Always verify per-method limits in the official documentation[10].
Citations:
- 1: https://api.slack.com/apis/rate-limits
- 2: https://community.n8n.io/t/api-limit-reached-when-user-information-is-obtained-from-slack/27453
- 3: https://developer.zendesk.com/api-reference/introduction/pagination/
- 4: https://api.slack.com/changelog/2018-04-truncating-really-long-messages
- 5: https://api.slack.com/methods/chat.postMessage
- 6: https://api.slack-gov.com/admins/scim
- 7: https://slack.engineering/evolving-api-pagination-at-slack/
- 8: https://api.slack.com/tutorials/tracks/getting-a-token
- 9: slackapi/node-slack-sdk#343
- 10: https://api.slack.com/apis/pagination
- 11: slackapi/bolt-js#1811
- 12: https://trailhead.salesforce.com/trailblazer-community/feed/0D5KX00000KhkGR0AZ
- 13: https://api.slack.com/methods/files.info
- 14: https://api.slack.com/reference/block-kit/blocks
- 15: https://api.slack.com/reference/messaging/attachments
- 16: slackapi/hubot-slack#557
- 17: https://api.slack.com/reference/messaging/block-elements
Verified: Slack API supports the increased page size, but recommended limits suggest caution.
Increasing the
LIMITconstant from 200 to 250 is technically supported since Slack API endpoints allow up to 1,000 items per request. However, Slack recommends using 100–200 items per page for optimal reliability and performance. While 250 is within the allowed range, please verify that this slight increase aligns with your application’s performance requirements and will not negatively impact rate limits or resource consumption.components/slack/sources/new-saved-message/new-saved-message.mjs (1)
8-8: Version increment looks goodThe version has been properly bumped from "0.0.4" to "0.0.5", which aligns with the versioning updates seen across other Slack components in this PR.
components/slack/sources/new-reaction-added/new-reaction-added.mjs (1)
8-8: Version increment looks goodThe version has been properly bumped from "1.1.24" to "1.1.25", which aligns with the versioning updates seen across other Slack components in this PR.
components/slack/actions/get-file/get-file.mjs (2)
7-7: Version increment looks goodThe version has been properly bumped from "0.0.22" to "0.0.23", which aligns with the versioning updates seen across other Slack components in this PR.
19-21: Improved API interaction patternGreat refactoring by replacing the direct SDK call
this.slack.sdk().files.infowiththis.slack.getFileInfo. This helps centralize API interactions, making the codebase more maintainable and consistent. If there are any rate limiting or error handling concerns, they can now be addressed in a single location.components/slack/actions/set-channel-topic/set-channel-topic.mjs (2)
7-7: Version increment looks goodThe version has been properly bumped from "0.0.22" to "0.0.23", which aligns with the versioning updates seen across other Slack components in this PR.
25-28: Improved API interaction patternGood refactoring by replacing the direct SDK call
this.slack.sdk().conversations.setTopicwiththis.slack.setChannelTopic. This helps centralize API interactions, making the codebase more maintainable and consistent. If there are any rate limiting or error handling concerns, they can now be addressed in a single location.components/slack/actions/create-channel/create-channel.mjs (2)
7-7: Version bump looks goodAppropriate version increment from "0.0.23" to "0.0.24" to reflect the changes in the implementation.
28-28: Simplified API method callGood refactoring from
this.slack.sdk().conversations.createtothis.slack.createConversations. This change is part of a larger effort to streamline the Slack API interactions and makes the code more maintainable.components/slack/actions/delete-file/delete-file.mjs (2)
7-7: Version bump is appropriateVersion incremented from "0.0.22" to "0.0.23" to reflect implementation changes.
19-19: Simplified API method callGood refactoring from
this.slack.sdk().files.deletetothis.slack.deleteFiles. This change is consistent with the broader effort to streamline Slack API interactions across the codebase.components/slack/actions/update-profile/update-profile.mjs (2)
8-8: Version bump is appropriateVersion incremented from "0.0.22" to "0.0.23" to reflect implementation changes.
73-73: Simplified API method callGood refactoring from
this.slack.sdk().users.profile.settothis.slack.updateProfile. This change improves code readability and is consistent with the broader effort to streamline Slack API interactions across the codebase.components/slack/actions/find-user-by-email/find-user-by-email.mjs (2)
7-7: Version bump is appropriateVersion incremented from "0.0.22" to "0.0.23" to reflect implementation changes.
19-19: Simplified API method callGood refactoring from
this.slack.sdk().users.lookupByEmailtothis.slack.lookupUserByEmail. This change is consistent with the broader effort to streamline Slack API interactions across the codebase.components/slack/actions/update-message/update-message.mjs (2)
7-7: Version increment looks goodThe version has been properly incremented from 0.1.22 to 0.1.23 as part of this update.
44-44: Well-refactored method callThe method call has been simplified from the nested
this.slack.sdk().chat.updateto the more directthis.slack.updateMessage. This is a good improvement that makes the code cleaner and easier to maintain.components/slack/actions/update-group-members/update-group-members.mjs (3)
7-7: Version increment looks goodThe version has been properly incremented from 0.0.7 to 0.0.8 as part of this update.
53-53: Well-refactored method call for listing group membersThe method call has been simplified from the nested
this.slack.sdk().usergroups.users.listto the more directthis.slack.listGroupMembers. This is a good improvement that makes the code cleaner and easier to maintain.
59-59: Well-refactored method call for updating group membersThe method call has been simplified from the nested
this.slack.sdk().usergroups.users.updateto the more directthis.slack.updateGroupMembers. This is a good improvement that makes the code cleaner and easier to maintain.components/slack/actions/approve-workflow/approve-workflow.mjs (2)
8-8: Version increment looks goodThe version has been properly incremented from 0.0.3 to 0.0.4 as part of this update.
47-47: Well-refactored method call for posting chat messagesThe method call has been simplified from the nested
this.slack.sdk().chat.postMessageto the more directthis.slack.postChatMessage. This is a good improvement that makes the code cleaner and easier to maintain.components/slack/actions/create-reminder/create-reminder.mjs (2)
7-7: Version increment looks goodThe version has been properly incremented from 0.0.23 to 0.0.24 as part of this update.
38-38: Well-refactored method call for adding remindersThe method call has been simplified from the nested
this.slack.sdk().reminders.addto the more directthis.slack.addReminders. This is a good improvement that makes the code cleaner and easier to maintain.components/slack/actions/kick-user/kick-user.mjs (2)
8-8: Version update looks good.Version increment from 0.0.22 to 0.0.23 appropriately tracks the changes made to this component.
36-39: Clean SDK abstraction implementation.Replacing the direct SDK call
this.slack.sdk().conversations.kickwith the wrapper methodthis.slack.kickUserFromConversationimproves code maintainability while preserving the same functionality. This abstraction helps decouple the component from direct SDK dependencies and provides a more consistent API surface.components/slack/actions/set-channel-description/set-channel-description.mjs (2)
7-7: Version update looks good.Version increment from 0.0.7 to 0.0.8 appropriately tracks the changes made to this component.
25-28: Improved method naming and abstraction.Replacing the direct SDK call
this.slack.sdk().conversations.setPurposewith the more intuitively named wrapper methodthis.slack.setChannelDescriptionenhances code readability and maintainability. This change maintains the same functionality while providing a clearer API.components/slack/actions/upload-file/upload-file.mjs (2)
9-9: Version update looks good.Version increment from 0.0.26 to 0.0.27 appropriately tracks the changes made to this component.
38-43: Simplified file upload method.Replacing the direct SDK call
this.slack.sdk().filesUploadV2with the wrapper methodthis.slack.uploadFileimproves code maintainability while preserving all parameters and functionality. The error handling for file existence check (lines 35-37) is properly maintained, ensuring consistent behavior.components/slack/actions/delete-message/delete-message.mjs (2)
7-7: Version update looks good.Version increment from 0.0.22 to 0.0.23 appropriately tracks the changes made to this component.
32-36: Improved method naming and abstraction.Replacing the direct SDK call
this.slack.sdk().chat.deletewith the more descriptive wrapper methodthis.slack.deleteMessageenhances code readability while maintaining the same parameters and functionality. This abstraction provides a more consistent and intuitive API across the Slack components.components/slack/actions/archive-channel/archive-channel.mjs (2)
8-8: Version update for tracking changesVersion increment from "0.0.22" to "0.0.23" properly reflects the changes made to this component.
27-27: SDK method refactoring improves code clarityThe change from nested SDK calls (
this.slack.sdk().conversations.archive) to a direct method (this.slack.archiveConversations) simplifies the code and improves maintainability, while preserving the same functionality.components/slack/actions/add-emoji-reaction/add-emoji-reaction.mjs (2)
7-7: Version update for tracking changesVersion increment from "0.0.14" to "0.0.15" properly reflects the changes made to this component.
35-35: SDK method refactoring improves code clarityThe change from nested SDK calls (
this.slack.sdk().reactions.add) to a direct method (this.slack.addReactions) simplifies the code and improves maintainability, while preserving the same functionality.components/slack/actions/invite-user-to-channel/invite-user-to-channel.mjs (2)
7-7: Version update for tracking changesVersion increment from "0.0.22" to "0.0.23" properly reflects the changes made to this component.
25-25: SDK method refactoring improves code clarityThe change from nested SDK calls (
this.slack.sdk().conversations.invite) to a direct method (this.slack.inviteToConversation) simplifies the code and improves maintainability, while preserving the same functionality.components/slack/actions/common/send-message.mjs (3)
238-238: SDK method refactoring improves code clarityThe change from nested SDK calls (
this.slack.sdk().chat.scheduleMessage) to a direct method (this.slack.scheduleMessage) simplifies the code and improves maintainability, while preserving the same functionality.
240-240: SDK method refactoring improves code clarityThe change from nested SDK calls (
this.slack.sdk().chat.postMessage) to a direct method (this.slack.postChatMessage) simplifies the code and improves maintainability, while preserving the same functionality.
246-250: Improved user profile retrievalThe implementation now uses
this.slack.getUserProfile()instead ofthis.slack.userNames()and accesses the user'sreal_nameproperty from the profile. This approach is more direct and potentially provides more accurate user display names.components/slack/actions/send-large-message/send-large-message.mjs (2)
8-8: Incremented version from 0.0.22 to 0.0.23.This version bump is consistent with the rest of the Slack actions and follows semantic versioning guidelines.
82-85: Validate the user profile retrieval logic.Switching to
this.slack.getUserProfile()is fine, but ifprofile.real_nameis missing or undefined, this could cause errors or unexpected channel naming.Do you want to confirm that
profile.real_nameis always present? If needed, adding fallback handling for missing real_name will help avoid runtime errors.components/slack/actions/list-files/list-files.mjs (4)
7-7: Version bump to 0.0.51 looks appropriate.This minor update aligns with the incremental changes introduced in pagination and reflects a consistent release cycle.
51-51: Usingcount: this.pageSizeis correct for Slack'sfiles.list.Slack’s API expects a
countparam to set the page size. This usage is on track.
56-56: Refactored method call tothis.slack.listFiles(params).This is in line with the broader refactoring away from nested SDK calls.
60-60: Limiting pages helps manage large data.Short-circuiting the loop with
params.page <= this.numPagesprevents excessive queries and is aligned with the newly added props.components/slack/actions/list-users/list-users.mjs (4)
7-7: Version updated to 0.0.23.This minor version increment is consistent with similar Slack actions.
18-29: IntroducedpageSizeandnumPagesfor user-list pagination.These properties offer enhanced control over retrieving users in batches.
32-46: New do-while loop implements paginated retrieval of users.Storing
membersin an array and trackingnextCursoreach iteration is a clean approach to pagination. EnsurenextCursoris validated if Slack changes its response format.
48-53: Exporting a descriptive summary and returning the users array.Providing both a user-friendly summary and the accumulated users object is helpful for downstream steps.
components/slack/actions/list-replies/list-replies.mjs (4)
7-7: Version bump looks correct.
No issues found. The minor version change nicely reflects new functionality.
23-28: Confirm default handling forpageSize.
You might want to ensure a safe default or an upper limit if the user skips passing this prop.
37-43: Initialization for replies and parameters appears correct.
The approach for pagination setup is straightforward and well-structured.
54-59: Returning messages array with a clear summary.
This is a well-structured output that improves clarity for end-users.components/slack/actions/list-members-in-channel/list-members-in-channel.mjs (4)
7-7: Version update aligns with added pagination.
No further concerns.
23-28: Confirm default or boundary forpageSize.
Similar to other pagination props, ensure sensible fallback behavior when not provided.
37-43: Pagination setup is consistent.
The initialization ofchannelMembersandparamsis correct and easy to follow.
54-54: Check for potential lookup errors.
userNameLookupcan fail if any ID is invalid. Consider adding basic error handling or fallback.components/slack/actions/list-channels/list-channels.mjs (3)
7-7: Minor version increase is appropriate.
The change reflects the new pagination feature.
11-16: EnsurepageSizehas reasonable defaults.
If the user omits this input, a fallback is recommended to avoid overly large or small page sizes.
40-45: Returning summarized channel data is clear.
Exposing the total count and the final array is user-friendly.components/slack/actions/list-group-members/list-group-members.mjs (4)
7-7: Minor version bump looks fine
25-36: New pagination props
The addition ofpageSizeandnumPagesprops is consistent with the enhanced pagination approach. Ensure default values or validations are in place (the Slack app props appear to set defaults to 250 and 1).
39-45: Initialization of members array and request params
Storing the user group inparams.usergroupand applying thethis.pageSizelimit is appropriate for batch retrieval.
56-61: Summarizing and returning all members
Reporting the total number of retrieved users is a nice touch for user feedback.components/slack/slack.app.mjs (62)
3-4: New utility imports
Usinglodash/getandasync-retrycan improve code clarity and resilience against transient errors.
20-21: Explicitly callingavailableConversationswith rate-limit throwing
PassingtrueforthrowRateLimitErrorhelps fail fast during severe rate limits.
23-26: Retrieving channel members
Invokingthis.listChannelMembersis consistent with the new method-based approach. ThethrowRateLimitError: trueparameter ensures stronger error control.
29-29: Filtering logic
.filter((c) => members.includes(c.user || c.id))is correct if Slack’sc.userorc.idalways lines up with those inmembers.Please confirm that
c.uservs.c.idis consistently set. In some Slack data,c.usercan be undefined if the conversation object doesn't include a direct user reference.
30-31: Looking up user names
CollectinguserIdsand callingthis.userNameLookupis an elegant approach to map display labels.
52-52: Paginated group retrieval
Similarly callsavailableConversations(..., true), ensuring robust handling of rate-limit scenarios.
71-73:usergroupsListwiththrowRateLimitError
Makes user group listing more reliable under heavy usage.
85-87:remindersListwiththrowRateLimitError
Parallels the same improved pattern for rate-limit resilience.
101-101: DestructuringprevContext.cursor
Ensures you use the existing pagination cursor for channel lookups. No concerns here.
106-108: InjectingthrowRateLimitErrorintoauthTest
Aligns error-handling logic with the rest of the Slack methods.
122-122: Another call toavailableConversationswith robust rate-limit handling
This ensures consistent usage across the app.
123-130: Filtering IM vs. non-IM and retrieving user display names
Recognizingc.is_imearly is an elegant solution. The fallback for channels is also correct.
178-178:throwRateLimitErrorwhen listing channel IDs
Reinforces the standardized approach to rate-limit exceptions.
180-184: Conditional IM evaluation
Maps user IDs for direct messaging channels and usesuserNameLookupfor clarity.
275-275:listFilescall
Ensures channel-based file listing.
276-276: New argument usage
Extractingchannelandpagefrom props for clarity.
278-279: Large count and rate-limit check
count: constants.LIMITplusthrowRateLimitErroris consistent with the rest of the design.
436-449: IntroducingpageSizeandnumPages
These new Slack app-level props unify pagination defaults (250 results, 1 page). It's a good pattern for reusability.
475-477:rejectRateLimitedCalls: trueinWebClient
This is a solid approach for capturing Slack rate-limit responses early.
480-480: Extended signature
IncludingthrowRateLimitErrorin the method arguments ensures granular control for the caller.
486-486: Retain_withRetries
Calling_withRetriescentralizes retry logic, promoting maintainability.
494-494: Helper_withRetries
Provides the main anchor for consistent backoff and retry.
495-516: Asynchronous exponential retry
The approach is effective. On rate-limit errors (code === 429), either bail ifthrowRateLimitErroristrue, or automatically retry after the designated backoff.
529-529: EnhancedavailableConversations
ExplicitthrowRateLimitErrorparameter keeps logic consistent.
530-539: ApplyingthrowRateLimitError
The consistent pattern across Slack calls ensures uniform behavior under load.
545-545: RefactoreduserNameLookup
OptionalthrowRateLimitErrorfosters a flexible usage pattern.
553-556: PassingthrowRateLimitErrorand arguments
Spreads props intousersList, ensuring it respects pagination and rate-limit policies.
560-562: Filtering user IDs
Storing matched user names in an object is a memory-friendly approach.
566-566: Cursor-based loop
Stops when no more pages or all relevant IDs are mapped. Efficient usage of Slack pagination.
630-631:usersConversationslimit fallback
args.limit ||= constants.LIMITensures consistent page size.
650-650:usersListlimit fallback
Same pattern as above, good for predictable paging.
663-663: Comment changes
Makes the doc block reflect the updated usage oflimitdefaults.
672-672:conversationsListlimit
Keeps the code consistent across all Slack listing methods.
692-692:conversationsHistorylimit
Analogous approach ensures uniform pagination.
748-748:searchMessagescount fallback
Matches the same||= constants.LIMITpattern.
775-776:reactionsListlimit
Maintains consistency for Slack reactions retrieval.
781-781:getCustomEmojis
Async method to retrieve a large set of emojis.
783-785: Handling rate limit inemoji.list
Adheres to the same pattern as other endpoints.
794-800: IntroducinglistChannelMembers
Wraps Slack’sconversations.memberswith a standard approach.
801-814: NewlistFilesmethod
Retrieves file listings, likewise adopting consistent pagination.
815-820:listGroupMembers
Used in the new Slack actions for user group management.
821-826:getFileInfo
Enables retrieval of Slack file metadata.
827-832:getUserProfile
Fetches user profile details for post-processing.
833-838:getBotInfo
Complements the rest of the user-based calls, ensuring coverage of bot details.
839-844:getTeamInfo
Allows workspace-level data to be retrieved.
845-850:getConversationReplies
Handles Slack conversation threaded replies.
851-856:addReactions
Wrapsreactions.addwith standardized usage.
857-862:postChatMessage
Encapsulates Slack’schat.postMessageparameters.
863-868:archiveConversations
Provides a neat method for archival tasks.
869-874:scheduleMessage
Adds scheduling features, with the standard throwRateLimitError logic.
875-880:createConversations
Wraps Slack’s channel creation.
881-886:inviteToConversation
Method for user invitation to private/public channels.
887-892:kickUserFromConversation
Method for removing users from channels or group DMs.
893-898:addReminders
Implements Slack reminders creation.
899-904:deleteFiles
For bulk or individual file deletion.
905-910:deleteMessage
Versatile DM or channel message-deletion method.
911-916:lookupUserByEmail
Facilitates user resolution by email.
917-922:setChannelDescription
Sets conversation purpose text.
923-928:setChannelTopic
Updates conversation topic text.
929-934:updateProfile
Let users or bots adjust Slack profile data.
935-940:updateGroupMembers
Modifies user group membership.
941-946:updateMessageanduploadFile
Rounding out the Slack methods for message editing and file uploads.
components/slack/actions/send-large-message/send-large-message.mjs
Outdated
Show resolved
Hide resolved
| const statusCode = get(error, "code"); | ||
| if (statusCode === 429) { | ||
| if (throwRateLimitError) { | ||
| bail(`Rate limit exceeded. ${error}`); |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Do you know if this message will be shown in the async options UI?
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Hi @GTFalcao. I did some testing, made some minor adjustments, and yes the message is displayed in the async options!
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Actionable comments posted: 0
🧹 Nitpick comments (3)
components/slack/actions/upload-file/upload-file.mjs (3)
42-43: Consider using path.basename for more robust filename extractionThe current method of extracting the filename assumes UNIX-style paths and might not work with Windows-style paths (which use backslashes).
+import path from "path"; -const filename = this.content.split("/").pop(); +const filename = path.basename(this.content);
58-71: Add explicit error handling for file upload stepUnlike the other steps, the axios request doesn't have explicit error handling. If the upload fails, it would throw an axios error that might not be very descriptive or user-friendly.
-await axios($, { - url: uploadUrl, - data: formData, - method: "POST", - headers: { - ...formData.getHeaders(), - Authorization: `Bearer ${this.slack.getToken()}`, - }, -}); +try { + await axios($, { + url: uploadUrl, + data: formData, + method: "POST", + headers: { + ...formData.getHeaders(), + Authorization: `Bearer ${this.slack.getToken()}`, + }, + }); +} catch (error) { + throw new Error(`Error uploading file: ${error.message}`); +}
37-90: Consider adding resource cleanup for file streamsThe file stream created with
fs.createReadStream()isn't explicitly closed after the upload. While Node.js's garbage collection will usually handle this, in high-load scenarios, it might be good to explicitly close streams.const formData = new FormData(); -formData.append("file", fs.createReadStream(this.content)); +const fileStream = fs.createReadStream(this.content); +formData.append("file", fileStream); formData.append("filename", filename); try { await axios($, { url: uploadUrl, data: formData, method: "POST", headers: { ...formData.getHeaders(), Authorization: `Bearer ${this.slack.getToken()}`, }, }); } catch (error) { throw new Error(`Error uploading file: ${error.message}`); } finally { + // Ensure the file stream is closed + fileStream.destroy(); }
📜 Review details
Configuration used: CodeRabbit UI
Review profile: CHILL
Plan: Pro
⛔ Files ignored due to path filters (1)
pnpm-lock.yamlis excluded by!**/pnpm-lock.yaml
📒 Files selected for processing (7)
components/slack/actions/delete-file/delete-file.mjs(1 hunks)components/slack/actions/get-file/get-file.mjs(1 hunks)components/slack/actions/invite-user-to-channel/invite-user-to-channel.mjs(2 hunks)components/slack/actions/kick-user/kick-user.mjs(2 hunks)components/slack/actions/upload-file/upload-file.mjs(2 hunks)components/slack/package.json(2 hunks)components/slack/slack.app.mjs(26 hunks)
🚧 Files skipped from review as they are similar to previous changes (2)
- components/slack/package.json
- components/slack/actions/invite-user-to-channel/invite-user-to-channel.mjs
⏰ Context from checks skipped due to timeout of 90000ms (3)
- GitHub Check: pnpm publish
- GitHub Check: Verify TypeScript components
- GitHub Check: Publish TypeScript components
🔇 Additional comments (28)
components/slack/actions/upload-file/upload-file.mjs (6)
1-5: Appropriate imports added for the new implementationThe addition of
ConfigurationError,axios, andFormDataimports are necessary for the updated file upload implementation, which now uses a multi-step process.
11-12: Improved documentation and version bumpThe description now includes a link to the relevant Slack API documentation, which is helpful for users trying to understand this component. The version bump from 0.0.26 to 0.0.27 correctly reflects these implementation changes.
44-56: Good error handling for the getUploadUrl stepThe implementation properly checks if the response is successful and throws a descriptive
ConfigurationErrorif it fails, including the response details for debugging purposes.
73-86: Good implementation of the completeUpload stepThe code properly completes the upload process by calling
this.slack.completeUploadwith the required parameters and includes appropriate error handling.
88-89: Improved response handlingThe code now returns the complete upload response from Slack, which provides more information to the caller than the previous implementation.
37-90: Overall implementation is significantly improvedThe refactoring from using a direct SDK call to a multi-step process (get upload URL, upload file, complete upload) is a notable improvement. This approach likely provides better control over the upload process and potentially better error handling capabilities.
components/slack/actions/get-file/get-file.mjs (4)
7-7: Version increment looks good.The version bump from "0.0.22" to "0.0.23" appropriately reflects the changes made to this component.
11-16: Good addition of the conversation property.Adding the conversation property as a prerequisite for file selection makes sense, as files in Slack are associated with specific conversations/channels.
21-23: Appropriate dependency configuration.The file property now correctly depends on the conversation property, ensuring that files are filtered by the selected conversation/channel.
28-28: Improved API call pattern.Replacing the nested SDK call
this.slack.sdk().files.infowith the direct methodthis.slack.getFileInfois a good refactoring choice that improves code readability and maintainability.components/slack/actions/kick-user/kick-user.mjs (2)
8-8: Version increment looks good.The version bump from "0.0.22" to "0.0.23" appropriately reflects the changes made to this component.
36-49: Good error handling improvement.The implementation now gracefully handles the case where a user is not in the channel by catching the "not_in_channel" error and providing a user-friendly message. This prevents workflow failures for this non-critical error case.
The refactoring from nested SDK call
this.slack.sdk().conversations.kickto direct method callthis.slack.kickUserFromConversationimproves code readability and maintainability.components/slack/actions/delete-file/delete-file.mjs (4)
7-7: Version increment looks good.The version bump from "0.0.22" to "0.0.23" appropriately reflects the changes made to this component.
11-16: Good addition of the conversation property.Adding the conversation property as a prerequisite for file selection makes sense, as files in Slack are associated with specific conversations/channels.
21-23: Appropriate dependency configuration.The file property now correctly depends on the conversation property, ensuring that files are filtered by the selected conversation/channel.
28-28: Improved API call pattern.Replacing the nested SDK call
this.slack.sdk().files.deletewith the direct methodthis.slack.deleteFilesis a good refactoring choice that improves code readability and maintainability.components/slack/slack.app.mjs (12)
3-4: Good addition of utility libraries.Adding
lodash/getprovides a safe way to access nested properties, andasync-retryis an excellent choice for implementing reliable retry logic for API calls.
21-32: Improved user options generation.The code now fetches channel members first and filters conversations by membership before looking up user names, which is more efficient than the previous approach. This ensures that only users in the selected channel are displayed as options.
52-52: Consistent error handling for asynchronous options.Good addition of the
throwRateLimitErrorparameter across all options methods. This ensures consistent handling of rate limit errors during option loading.Also applies to: 72-73, 86-87, 106-108
124-130: Improved separation of concerns.The code now handles IM and non-IM channels separately, which improves readability and makes the intent clearer. This is a good refactoring practice.
180-184: Optimized user lookup.Only fetching user names for IM channels is a good optimization, as it reduces unnecessary API calls for other channel types.
436-449: Good pagination controls.Adding
pageSizeandnumPagesproperties provides users with better control over pagination, which is important for handling large data sets efficiently.
475-477: Improved rate limit handling.Configuring the WebClient to reject rate-limited calls allows for explicit handling of rate limits, which is a good practice for API reliability.
494-515: Excellent retry implementation.The
_withRetriesmethod provides a robust retry mechanism for handling transient failures, with specific handling for rate limit errors. The exponential backoff approach is appropriate for API calls.
506-506: Consider clarifying error message for end users.When a rate limit is encountered in the async options UI, the error message will be shown to the user. Consider making it more user-friendly if this is customer-facing.
- bail(`Rate limit exceeded. ${error}`); + bail(`Rate limit exceeded. Please try again in a few moments.`);
528-528: Improved method signatures with default parameters.Adding default parameters for
throwRateLimitErrorand other arguments improves the API's usability while maintaining backward compatibility.Also applies to: 544-544
605-609: Consistent default limits.Using
||=to set default limits ensures that all API calls have consistent pagination behavior. This is a good practice for maintaining consistent API behavior.Also applies to: 649-654, 671-676
793-952: Excellent modular approach to API methods.Creating dedicated wrapper methods for each Slack API endpoint is a significant improvement that:
- Makes the code more readable and maintainable
- Provides a consistent interface for API calls
- Simplifies error handling
- Improves testability
This refactoring follows good software engineering practices by reducing direct dependencies on the Slack SDK throughout the codebase.
michelle0927
changed the title
|
/approve |
Resolves #15953
Summary by CodeRabbit
New Features
Refactor
Chore