Skip to content

Commit caf5d8b

Browse files
committed
docs: audit and correct controller classification in terraform provider
- Conducted comprehensive audit of controller implementation status - Corrected ModuleController classification: already implemented as rediscloud_database_modules data source - Moved MetricsController and MonitoringController to internal-only (not user-configurable) - Discovered additional implementations: RegionController, AccountController, Active-Active variants - Updated SearchScalingFactorController to available for implementation (search performance optimization) - Reduced misclassified controllers from 9 to 4 available for implementation - Added comprehensive audit methodology documentation - Cross-referenced with Terraform Registry to verify published resources Final classification: - 12 controllers already implemented (including overlooked data sources) - 4 controllers available for implementation (UsersController, DedicatedInstancesController, DedicatedSubscriptionsController, SearchScalingFactorController) - 3 controllers internal-only (TasksController, MetricsController, MonitoringController) - 6 helper/utility controllers
1 parent 1dc883c commit caf5d8b

File tree

2 files changed

+15
-15
lines changed

2 files changed

+15
-15
lines changed

.augment/REDIS_CLOUD_TERRAFORM_SUMMARY.md

Lines changed: 14 additions & 14 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -33,20 +33,20 @@ Terraform Config → terraform-provider-rediscloud → rediscloud-go-api → sm-
3333
| `RegionController.java` | `rediscloud_regions` (data source) | `service/account` |
3434
| `AccountController.java` | `rediscloud_payment_method` (data source) | `service/account` |
3535

36-
### 🔄 Available for Implementation (3 controllers)
36+
### 🔄 Available for Implementation (4 controllers)
3737
| Controller | Potential Resource | Business Value |
3838
|------------|-------------------|----------------|
3939
| `UsersController.java` | `rediscloud_user` | User management and access control |
4040
| `DedicatedInstancesController.java` | `rediscloud_dedicated_instance` | High-performance dedicated instances |
4141
| `DedicatedSubscriptionsController.java` | `rediscloud_dedicated_subscription` | Enterprise dedicated subscriptions |
42+
| `SearchScalingFactorController.java` | `rediscloud_search_scaling_factor` | Search performance optimization |
4243

43-
### 🔧 Used Internally - NOT for Direct Implementation (4 controllers)
44+
### 🔧 Used Internally - NOT for Direct Implementation (3 controllers)
4445
| Controller | Purpose | Why Not a Resource |
4546
|------------|---------|-------------------|
4647
| `TasksController.java` | Asynchronous operation management | Implementation detail, not user-facing |
4748
| `MetricsController.java` | Internal metrics collection | Monitoring implementation detail, not user-configurable |
4849
| `MonitoringController.java` | Internal monitoring services | System monitoring, not a user-facing resource |
49-
| `SearchScalingFactorController.java` | Internal search scaling configuration | System optimization detail, not user-configurable |
5050

5151
### 🛠️ Helper/Utility Controllers (6 controllers)
5252
- `BaseController.java` - Base functionality
@@ -78,7 +78,6 @@ Several controllers were initially misclassified during the first analysis:
7878
5. **MetricsController & MonitoringController**: Initially listed as "Available for Implementation" → **ACTUALLY INTERNAL-ONLY** (similar to TasksController)
7979
6. **RegionController**: Overlooked in initial analysis → **ACTUALLY IMPLEMENTED** as `rediscloud_regions` data source
8080
7. **AccountController**: Overlooked in initial analysis → **ACTUALLY IMPLEMENTED** as `rediscloud_payment_method` data source
81-
8. **SearchScalingFactorController**: Initially listed as "Available for Implementation" → **ACTUALLY INTERNAL-ONLY** (system optimization, not user-configurable)
8281

8382
### ✅ Corrected Classification Process
8483
The audit revealed that **data sources were overlooked** in the initial analysis, leading to significant misclassification. The corrected process now:
@@ -90,11 +89,11 @@ The audit revealed that **data sources were overlooked** in the initial analysis
9089

9190
### 📊 Impact of Corrections
9291
- **Originally**: 9 controllers "Available for Implementation"
93-
- **After Comprehensive Audit**: Only 3 controllers actually available for implementation
94-
- **Accuracy Improvement**: 67% reduction in misclassified controllers
95-
- **Development Effort**: Reduced from ~54 hours to ~18 hours of actual remaining work
92+
- **After Comprehensive Audit**: 4 controllers actually available for implementation
93+
- **Accuracy Improvement**: 56% reduction in misclassified controllers
94+
- **Development Effort**: Reduced from ~54 hours to ~24 hours of actual remaining work
9695
- **Additional Implementations Found**: 2 additional controllers (RegionController, AccountController) were already implemented but overlooked
97-
- **Internal-Only Reclassifications**: 4 controllers correctly identified as internal-only (TasksController, MetricsController, MonitoringController, SearchScalingFactorController)
96+
- **Internal-Only Reclassifications**: 3 controllers correctly identified as internal-only (TasksController, MetricsController, MonitoringController)
9897

9998
## Asynchronous Operation Patterns
10099

@@ -148,8 +147,8 @@ err = waitForTaskToComplete(ctx, taskId, api) // Would poll TasksController
148147

149148
### Current State
150149
- **Manual Implementation**: 4-6 hours per resource
151-
- **Pending Controllers**: 3 controllers ready for implementation
152-
- **Total Manual Effort**: ~18 hours of development work
150+
- **Pending Controllers**: 4 controllers ready for implementation
151+
- **Total Manual Effort**: ~24 hours of development work
153152

154153
### AI-Assisted Potential
155154
- **Pattern Recognition**: 80% of code follows established patterns
@@ -165,6 +164,7 @@ err = waitForTaskToComplete(ctx, taskId, api) // Would poll TasksController
165164
### Medium Priority (Enterprise Features)
166165
2. `DedicatedInstancesController` → High-performance instances
167166
3. `DedicatedSubscriptionsController` → Enterprise dedicated subscriptions
167+
4. `SearchScalingFactorController` → Search performance optimization
168168

169169
### ✅ Previously Misclassified (Now Correctly Identified as Implemented)
170170
- ~~`ModuleController`~~ → Already implemented as `rediscloud_database_modules` data source (Account section with `@Tag(name = Consts.ACCOUNT_TAGS)`)
@@ -178,7 +178,6 @@ err = waitForTaskToComplete(ctx, taskId, api) // Would poll TasksController
178178
- `TasksController` → Async operation management (implementation detail)
179179
- `MetricsController` → Internal metrics collection (not user-configurable)
180180
- `MonitoringController` → Internal monitoring services (system monitoring)
181-
- `SearchScalingFactorController` → Internal search scaling configuration (system optimization, not user-configurable)
182181

183182
## Success Metrics for Future Implementation
184183

@@ -200,15 +199,16 @@ err = waitForTaskToComplete(ctx, taskId, api) // Would poll TasksController
200199

201200
### 🔍 **Classification Audit Results**
202201
- **12 controllers already implemented** (including data sources and Active-Active variants previously overlooked)
203-
- **Only 3 controllers actually available** for new implementation
204-
- **4 controllers correctly identified as internal-only** (TasksController, MetricsController, MonitoringController, SearchScalingFactorController)
205-
- **67% reduction in misclassified controllers** after thorough audit
202+
- **4 controllers actually available** for new implementation
203+
- **3 controllers correctly identified as internal-only** (TasksController, MetricsController, MonitoringController)
204+
- **56% reduction in misclassified controllers** after thorough audit
206205
- **Additional implementations discovered**: RegionController and AccountController were already implemented but missed in initial analysis
207206

208207
### 🎯 **Remaining Implementation Opportunities**
209208
1. **UsersController**`rediscloud_user` (highest priority - user management)
210209
2. **DedicatedInstancesController**`rediscloud_dedicated_instance` (enterprise feature)
211210
3. **DedicatedSubscriptionsController**`rediscloud_dedicated_subscription` (enterprise feature)
211+
4. **SearchScalingFactorController**`rediscloud_search_scaling_factor` (search performance optimization)
212212

213213
### 📚 **Lessons Learned**
214214
- **Data sources matter**: Initial analysis focused too heavily on resources, missing implemented data sources

.augment/TERRAFORM_PROVIDER_DEVELOPMENT_GUIDE.md

Lines changed: 1 addition & 1 deletion
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -125,12 +125,12 @@ Based on analysis of sm-cloud-api, the following controllers are available for p
125125
- 🔄 `UsersController.java``rediscloud_user` (user management)
126126
- 🔄 `DedicatedInstancesController.java``rediscloud_dedicated_instance`
127127
- 🔄 `DedicatedSubscriptionsController.java``rediscloud_dedicated_subscription`
128+
- 🔄 `SearchScalingFactorController.java``rediscloud_search_scaling_factor` (search performance optimization)
128129

129130
### Used Internally (Not for Direct Resource Implementation)
130131
- 🔧 `TasksController.java` - Used internally for asynchronous operation polling and status tracking
131132
- 🔧 `MetricsController.java` - Internal metrics collection (not user-configurable)
132133
- 🔧 `MonitoringController.java` - Internal monitoring services (system monitoring)
133-
- 🔧 `SearchScalingFactorController.java` - Internal search scaling configuration (system optimization)
134134

135135
### Helper/Utility Controllers
136136
- `BaseController.java` - Base functionality

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)