Skip to content

Handling of not implemented services in when called within fragment  #12

@strecph1SICKAG

Description

@strecph1SICKAG

I have an arrangement which makes services available via expose().

code3

To access this service from the arrangement within my fragments, I have to implement this function in expose() again.
code4

I struggled with getting this communication to work in the beginning, as it was unclear to me why and how I have to (re-)implement functions within a fragment to call them from the "external" arrangement.
I have two recommendations for clarifying this design choice and making it more beginner friendly:

No. 1: Clearly stating the options and reasons to choose them could make it easier to understand conceptually

The re-implementation of external functionalities within the fragments expose() was decided upon to create a clear fallback strategy, when the external service is not available.
This re-implementation can

  • be empty, if the fragment does not have to be usable outside the context enabling the external functionality
  • resemble the full external functionality, to make the fragment independent and fully featured without any context
  • contain any other fallback functionality to be called of external service not available

No. 2: I think it would be very helpful for situations like this to get meaningful errors from collage as to why I can't access a function.
Errors like the following could lower the barrier to entry:

  • "Uncaught (in promise) collageError: api.services.ArrangementName.getHelloWorld is not a defined in the Collage API expose() initialization, see here: LINK TO DOKU"

Thanks :)

Metadata

Metadata

Labels

No labels
No labels

Type

No type

Projects

No projects

Relationships

None yet

Development

No branches or pull requests

Issue actions