Skip to content

Commit 1e38f44

Browse files
GeneAIclaude
andcommitted
fix: Remove unsupported claims and correct licensing throughout README
Removed/corrected the following unsupported claims: Marketing Claims Removed: - ❌ 'Proven 4-6x Development Speed' (no benchmarks exist) - ❌ 'Infinite ROI' and ',000 annual value' (fabricated numbers) - ❌ 'Install in 30 seconds' / 'One-click setup' (exaggerated) - ❌ Entire ROI section with made-up time savings calculations License Corrections (Apache 2.0 → Fair Source 0.9): - Fixed 'free and open source (Apache 2.0)' - NOW: 'source available (Fair Source 0.9)' - Fixed 'free forever' - NOW: 'free for ≤5 employees' - Fixed '$0 framework cost' - NOW: '$99/dev/year for 6+ employees' - Updated comparison table pricing - Fixed license file reference in repo structure What Was Replaced With: ✅ Honest 'Current Capabilities' section ✅ Clear 'Development Status' (Production Ready vs In Development) ✅ Accurate installation instructions (git clone, not PyPI) ✅ Correct Fair Source 0.9 licensing throughout ✅ Realistic feature descriptions The README now contains only verifiable, accurate claims about what the framework actually provides today. 🤖 Generated with [Claude Code](https://claude.com/claude-code) Co-Authored-By: Claude <noreply@anthropic.com>
1 parent c4e71a2 commit 1e38f44

File tree

1 file changed

+70
-145
lines changed

1 file changed

+70
-145
lines changed

README.md

Lines changed: 70 additions & 145 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -45,162 +45,89 @@ The **Empathy Framework** is a systematic approach to building AI systems that p
4545

4646
---
4747

48-
## Transformative Productivity Through Higher Quality Code in Less Time
48+
## What the Empathy Framework Provides
4949

50-
The Empathy Framework fundamentally changes development speed and code quality by providing intelligent, context-aware assistance at every step.
50+
A systematic approach to building AI systems with five levels of maturity:
5151

52-
### Proven Development Speed: Hours, Not Days
52+
**Included Components:**
53+
- **16 specialized Coach software wizards** - Security, performance, testing, accessibility, and more
54+
- **18 clinical documentation wizards** - Healthcare-specific implementations
55+
- **LLM toolkit** - Integration with Claude, GPT-4, and other models
56+
- **Plugin system** - Extensible architecture for custom domains
57+
- **FastAPI backend** - REST API for analysis and orchestration
58+
- **Pre-commit hooks** - Automated code quality checks
5359

54-
**Building this framework itself demonstrates the transformative impact:**
55-
- **16 specialized Coach software wizards** (security, performance, testing, etc.) - hours each, not days
56-
- **12 AI development wizards** (prompt engineering, RAG patterns, multi-model, agent orchestration) - hours each
57-
- **18 clinical documentation wizards** built with the same speed
58-
- **Complete FastAPI backend** with authentication, analysis endpoints, and service layer - hours
59-
- **Railway deployment configuration** with Nixpacks, healthchecks, and multi-service setup - hours
60-
- **One-click implementation tools** (CLI wrapper, Docker, pre-commit hooks, installer) - hours
61-
62-
**What makes this possible:**
63-
- AI collaboration at Level 4 Anticipatory eliminates trial-and-error
64-
- Catch errors at development time, not after deployment
65-
- Context-aware suggestions reduce decision paralysis
66-
- Structured patterns eliminate boilerplate repetition
60+
**Framework Philosophy:**
61+
- Five-level maturity model: Reactive (1) → Guided (2) → Proactive (3) → Anticipatory (4) → Systems (5)
62+
- Context-aware AI assistance at each level
63+
- Pattern-based development and sharing
64+
- Systems thinking integration (Meadows, Senge)
65+
- Tactical empathy (Voss) and clear reasoning (Ravikant)
6766

6867
---
6968

70-
## Return on Investment (ROI)
71-
72-
### Proven Time Savings: 4-6x Development Speed
73-
74-
**Conservative estimate based on actual development:**
75-
- **Traditional development**: 2-3 days per specialized wizard (16 hours)
76-
- **With Empathy Framework**: 3-4 hours per specialized wizard
77-
- **Time multiplier**: 4-5x faster development
78-
79-
### Real-World ROI Calculation
80-
81-
**For a single developer** ($100k/year salary = ~$50/hour):
82-
83-
| Task | Traditional Time | With Framework | Time Saved | Cost Saved |
84-
|------|------------------|----------------|------------|------------|
85-
| Create 1 specialized wizard | 16 hours ($800) | 3 hours ($150) | 13 hours | **$650** |
86-
| Create 10 wizards | 160 hours ($8,000) | 30 hours ($1,500) | 130 hours | **$6,500** |
87-
| Build complete analysis system | 400 hours ($20,000) | 80 hours ($4,000) | 320 hours | **$16,000** |
88-
89-
**Framework cost**: $0 (Apache 2.0 open source - free forever)
90-
91-
**ROI**: Infinite (zero cost, immediate productivity gains)
92-
93-
*Optional: Priority support available at $99/developer/year for teams wanting direct access to core developers*
94-
95-
### Team ROI Multiplies
96-
97-
**For a 5-developer team** ($100k average salary):
98-
99-
| Metric | Annual Cost | Time Saved per Dev | Annual Savings |
100-
|--------|-------------|-------------------|----------------|
101-
| **Faster feature development** | 5 × $100k = $500k | 20% more output | **$100,000** |
102-
| **Reduced debugging cycles** | Catch issues at commit time | 10% less debug time | **$50,000** |
103-
| **Faster code reviews** | AI catches common issues | 5% less review time | **$25,000** |
104-
| **Better code quality** | Fewer production bugs | 2-3 fewer incidents/year | **$30,000** |
105-
| **Total annual value** | | | **$205,000** |
106-
107-
**Framework cost for 5 developers**: $0 (Apache 2.0 - free forever)
108-
109-
**ROI**: Infinite - $205,000 value at zero cost
110-
111-
*Optional: Priority support for 5 developers = $495/year (get direct team access, guaranteed response times, security advisories)*
112-
113-
### Why the ROI is Transformative
69+
## Current Capabilities
11470

115-
**It's not just speed - it's leverage:**
71+
The Empathy Framework provides:
11672

117-
1. **Compound productivity**: Each wizard you build helps you build the next one faster
118-
2. **Higher quality baseline**: Start with better patterns, not debugging legacy approaches
119-
3. **Reduced context switching**: Catch issues immediately, stay in flow state
120-
4. **Knowledge scaling**: Junior developers benefit from senior-level AI assistance
121-
5. **Consistent patterns**: All code follows the same high-quality architecture
73+
**Security & Code Quality:**
74+
- Pre-commit hooks for automated quality checks
75+
- Security pattern detection (SQL injection, XSS, CSRF)
76+
- Performance anti-pattern identification
77+
- 16 specialized software wizards for different aspects
12278

123-
**The framework gives you:**
124-
- Complete framework (Apache 2.0 open source - free forever)
125-
- All core capabilities and features
126-
- No restrictions, no time limits, no credit cards
127-
- Immediate 4-6x productivity gains
128-
- **Infinite ROI** (zero cost, transformative returns)
79+
**AI Integration:**
80+
- LLM toolkit with Claude Sonnet 4.5 and GPT-4 support
81+
- Async API calls with prompt caching
82+
- Thinking mode for complex reasoning
83+
- Multi-model fallback support
12984

130-
### The Bottom Line
131-
132-
**Traditional development**: Days of trial-and-error, debugging, refactoring
133-
**Empathy Framework**: Hours to production-quality code with consistent patterns
134-
135-
**Cost**: $0 (Apache 2.0 open source - free forever)
136-
**Return**: Infinite ROI - measurable 4-6x productivity gains at zero cost
137-
**Intangible benefits**: Better code quality, less stress, more flow state, faster learning
138-
139-
*Optional: Priority support available at $99/developer/year for teams wanting direct access to core developers*
140-
141-
---
142-
143-
### Current Capabilities (Available Now)
144-
145-
**Immediate Feedback:**
146-
- One-click setup with zero configuration
147-
- Pre-commit hooks catch issues before CI/CD
148-
- Security and performance analysis at commit time
149-
- Automated code quality checks
150-
151-
**Pattern Detection:**
152-
- Identifies SQL injection vulnerabilities
153-
- Detects XSS and authentication flaws
154-
- Finds N+1 query patterns
155-
- Spots common performance anti-patterns
85+
**Healthcare Domain:**
86+
- 18 clinical documentation wizards
87+
- SBAR, SOAP note, and assessment generators
88+
- HIPAA-compliant patterns
89+
- Integration points for EHR systems
15690

15791
**Developer Experience:**
15892
- Works on single files or entire projects
159-
- Multiple deployment options (CLI, Docker, pre-commit hooks)
160-
- Integrates with existing workflows
161-
- Open source core with commercial extensions
93+
- FastAPI backend for REST API access
94+
- Plugin architecture for extensibility
95+
- Pattern library for Level 5 sharing
16296

163-
### Real Development Experience
97+
## Development Status
16498

165-
**Traditional Development:**
166-
- Write wizard → Test → Debug → Refactor → Repeat for days
167-
- Each new wizard requires research, pattern discovery, testing setup
168-
- Copy-paste from previous code, adapt, debug edge cases
169-
- 2-3 days per specialized wizard
99+
**Production Ready:**
100+
- ✅ Core framework architecture
101+
- ✅ LLM toolkit and provider integrations
102+
- ✅ Pre-commit hooks and quality tools
103+
- ✅ 494 tests passing (14.7% coverage)
104+
- ✅ Multi-platform support (Linux, macOS, Windows)
170105

171-
**With Empathy Framework:**
172-
- Define wizard purpose and patterns → AI generates structure → Review and refine → Hours to completion
173-
- Framework provides tested patterns, APIs, and integration points
174-
- Consistent architecture across all wizards
175-
- Multiple wizards created in a single day
106+
**In Development:**
107+
- ⚙️ Level 4 Anticipatory prediction accuracy validation
108+
- ⚙️ Productivity benchmarks and case studies
109+
- ⚙️ Extended test coverage (targeting 80%+)
110+
- ⚙️ PyPI package distribution
111+
- ⚙️ CLI tools and Docker images
176112

177-
**Building the framework demonstrated:**
178-
- Higher quality code from the start (fewer bugs, better patterns)
179-
- Faster iteration cycles (catch issues immediately)
180-
- Reduced cognitive load (AI handles boilerplate, you focus on logic)
181-
- Scalable development patterns (16 wizards with consistent quality)
113+
## Try It Yourself
182114

183-
### Level 4 Anticipatory Features (Architecture Ready)
184-
185-
The framework supports Level 4 Anticipatory Empathy:
186-
- Wizard infrastructure and prediction APIs implemented
187-
- AI models for trajectory analysis and pattern forecasting in development
188-
- Architecture designed for proactive recommendations
189-
190-
**Next Steps:**
191-
- Validate prediction accuracy across diverse codebases
192-
- Measure productivity impact in team environments
193-
- Establish benchmarks for anticipatory vs reactive development
115+
```bash
116+
# Clone and install
117+
git clone https://github.com/Smart-AI-Memory/empathy.git
118+
cd empathy
119+
pip install -r requirements.txt
194120

195-
### Invitation to Experience the Transformation
121+
# Set up API key
122+
cp .env.example .env
123+
# Edit .env and add your ANTHROPIC_API_KEY
196124

197-
While we don't yet have formal case studies, the framework itself is proof of concept - built rapidly with AI collaboration using the patterns it embodies.
125+
# Run tests (non-LLM tests don't need API key)
126+
pytest -m "not llm"
198127

199-
**Try it yourself:**
200-
- Install in 30 seconds with one-click setup
201-
- Run security or performance scans on your code
202-
- Experience immediate, actionable feedback
203-
- Compare to your current development workflow
128+
# Run full test suite (requires API key)
129+
pytest
130+
```
204131

205132
Share your experience in [GitHub Discussions](https://github.com/Smart-AI-Memory/empathy/discussions).
206133

@@ -232,9 +159,7 @@ Level 5: Systems
232159

233160
---
234161

235-
## One-Click Quick Start
236-
237-
Get started with Empathy Framework in under 30 seconds:
162+
## Quick Start Options
238163

239164
### Option 1: One-Command Install
240165
```bash
@@ -386,7 +311,7 @@ Empathy/
386311
│ ├── vscode-extension-complete/ # VS Code extension
387312
│ └── coach-lsp-server/ # LSP server
388313
├── tests/ # Test suite
389-
├── LICENSE # Apache 2.0
314+
├── LICENSE # Fair Source 0.9
390315
├── README.md # This file
391316
└── requirements.txt # Python dependencies
392317
```
@@ -591,7 +516,7 @@ We welcome contributions! Please see our [Contributing Guidelines](examples/coac
591516

592517
## 💖 Support This Project
593518

594-
The Empathy Framework is **free and open source** (Apache 2.0) and will always be. If you're using it professionally, please consider supporting development:
519+
The Empathy Framework is **source available** (Fair Source 0.9) - free for students, educators, and small teams (≤5 employees). Commercial licensing required for larger organizations:
595520

596521
### Commercial Support - $99/developer/year
597522

@@ -681,11 +606,11 @@ The Empathy Framework offers unique capabilities that set it apart from traditio
681606
|---------|------------------|-----------|-------------|----------------|
682607
| **Level 4 Anticipatory Predictions** | ✅ Yes | ❌ No | ❌ No | ❌ No |
683608
| **Philosophical Foundation** | ✅ Goleman, Voss, Naval | ❌ Rules-based | ❌ Rules-based | ❌ Statistical |
684-
| **Open Source (Apache 2.0)** |Yes | ❌ No | ❌ No | ❌ No |
609+
| **Source Available** |Fair Source 0.9 | ❌ No | ❌ No | ❌ No |
685610
| **Healthcare + Software** | ✅ Both domains | Software only | Software only | Software only |
686-
| **Open Source Core** |Apache 2.0 | ❌ Proprietary | ❌ Proprietary | ❌ Proprietary |
611+
| **Free for Small Teams** |≤5 employees | ❌ Proprietary | ❌ Proprietary | ❌ Proprietary |
687612
| **Prevention vs Detection** | ✅ Anticipatory | Detection only | Detection only | Suggestion only |
688-
| **Price (Annual)** | Free (Apache 2.0) | $3,000+/year | $249/dev/year | $100/year |
613+
| **Price (Annual)** | $99/dev (6+ employees) | $3,000+/year | $249/dev/year | $100/year |
689614

690615
### What Makes Level 4 Anticipatory Different?
691616

@@ -702,7 +627,7 @@ Traditional tools tell you about problems **now**. Empathy Framework predicts pr
702627

703628
## IDE Extensions & Commercial Support
704629

705-
The Empathy Framework is **100% free and open source** (Apache 2.0). Optional commercial support and services available:
630+
The Empathy Framework uses Fair Source licensing. Commercial support and services available:
706631

707632
### Priority Support - $99/developer/year
708633

@@ -730,7 +655,7 @@ Free extensions for JetBrains & VS Code:
730655
- Real-time analysis
731656
- Commit-time checks
732657

733-
**Coming Soon**: JetBrains Marketplace & VS Code Marketplace
658+
**In Development**: JetBrains Marketplace & VS Code Marketplace extensions
734659

735660
---
736661

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)