@@ -6,20 +6,18 @@ As published in [DuD](https://rdcu.be/cWdBJ) (German, English version in
66[ the cloud report] ( https://the-report.cloud/why-digital-sovereignty-is-more-than-mere-legal-compliance/ ) )
77and being summarized nicely in a [ cloudahead article] ( https://www.cloudahead.de/der-freiheitskampf-des-sovereign-cloud-stacks ) ,
88we differentiate between several levels of digital sovereignty.
9- We'll skip stage 0, introduced by Gregor Schuhmacher in his description, which
10- specifies using a cloud at all as the pre-step to be taken. This has relevance,
11- as some companies continue to call solutions that are not on-demand, not
12- self-service API driven, not metered
13- (see [ NIST definition of cloud] ( https://nvlpubs.nist.gov/nistpubs/legacy/sp/nistspecialpublication800-145.pdf ) )
14- to be (private) clouds. We talk about real clouds, where deployment of infrastructure
15- is API-driven, unlocking DevOps teams productivity.
9+ Level 0 (introduced by Gregor Schuhmacher in the cloudahead article)
10+ which describes having real clouds (see
11+ [ NIST definition of cloud] ( https://nvlpubs.nist.gov/nistpubs/legacy/sp/nistspecialpublication800-145.pdf ) )
12+ with self-service on-demand API driven service shall be taken for granted.
1613
17- The levels as seen by the SCS movement are:
14+ The levels as seen by the SCS project are:
1815
19- 1 . Control over data and data sharing and ability to fulfill regulatory requirements (GDPR)
16+ 1 . Control over data and data sharing and ability to fulfill regulatory requirements
17+ (e.g. GDPR) around data control.
20182 . Capability to chose between * highly compatible* operators, this way enabling a provider
2119 switch or using several providers in a federated fashion. This also includes the
22- possibility to run your infrastructure in a * highly compatible* manner.
20+ possibility to run your own infrastructure in a * highly compatible* manner.
23213 . Capability to influence and shape the infrastructure, enabling innovation at the
2422 infrastructure layer.
25234 . Transparency over operational aspects of running infrastructure, this way supporting
@@ -30,8 +28,8 @@ These aspects of sovereignty drive the work from the SCS team.
3028
3129Level number 1 is sometimes referred to as "data sovereignty". Achieving it does require
3230cloud infrastructure and cloud operations that can not be interfered with by actors that
33- are outside of the respective jurisdiction. For Europeans that need to observe GDPR, this
34- excludes using US clouds for personally identifiable information, expecting that the
31+ in ways incompatible with the respective jurisdiction. For Europeans that need to observe GDPR,
32+ this excludes using US clouds for personally identifiable information, expecting that the
3533adequacy decisions for the US do not fully address the risks. The SCS project does not
3634have deep legal expertise and refers to the work from [ noyb] ( https://noyb.eu/ )
3735and [ ENISA] ( https://www.enisa.europa.eu/ ) here.
@@ -56,22 +54,23 @@ for others (public cloud) or just for your own community (community cloud) or
5654internal (private cloud) needs.
5755
5856Level 4 addresses the skills and transparency aspects. Operating highly dynamic distributed
59- systems in a reliable manner requires knowledge and experience -- engineers with these skills
57+ systems in a reliable manner requires knowledge and experience — engineers with these skills
6058are scarce. To address this, the SCS team networks operations staff from providers and helps
6159to share and distill common knowledge that help everyone to be more successful. SCS has
6260thus been driving the [ Open Operations] ( https://openoperations.org ) initiative.
6361
64- Levels 2 and 3 are sometimes related to the term "technological sovereignty", indicating the ability to control and shape the technology.
62+ Levels 2 and 3 are sometimes related to the term "technological sovereignty",
63+ indicating the ability to control and shape the technology.
6564
6665## The SCS certification levels
6766
68- Corresponding to the levels of digital sovereignty in the SCS taxonomy, SCS defines
67+ Corresponding to the levels of digital sovereignty in the SCS taxonomy, SCS defines
6968SCS certification levels
7069
71701 . (Defined outside of the SCS scope)
72- 2 . SCS-compatible
73- 3 . SCS-open
74- 4 . SCS-sovereign
71+ 2 . * SCS-compatible*
72+ 3 . * SCS-open*
73+ 4 . * SCS-sovereign*
7574
7675### Why no SCS certification for GDPR?
7776
@@ -82,22 +81,24 @@ that fulfill the European GDPR regulation; it is also possible to operate clouds
8281special regulation, e.g. in the banking or insurance sector.
8382
8483SCS is not in a position to judge this and thus defines no own label / certificate to
85- vouch for regulatory compliance. We typically refer to the ENISA for GDPR considerations
86- and also recommend to take the Gaia-X labels into account here.
84+ vouch for regulatory compliance. We typically refer to the
85+ [ ENISA] ( https://www.enisa.europa.eu/ ) for GDPR considerations
86+ and also recommend to take the [ Gaia-X] ( https://gaia-x.eu/ ) labels into account here.
8787
8888## Status of SCS certification for cloud operators
8989
90- As of September 2024, we have not yet formalized the requirements for SCS-open and SCS-sovereign
91- certification.
90+ As of September 2024, the requirements for * SCS-open* and * SCS-sovereign*
91+ certification have not been formalized yet .
9292
93- The technical compatibility validation corresponding to the SCS-compatible certification does
93+ The technical compatibility validation corresponding to the * SCS-compatible* certification does
9494exist since more than a year. There are certificates for two layers of the SCS architecture
9595stack:
96- * The virtualization layer: SCS-compatible IaaS
97- * The container layer: SCS-compatible KaaS
96+
97+ * The virtualization layer: * SCS-compatible IaaS*
98+ * The container layer: * SCS-compatible KaaS*
9899
99100For each of these, technical tests are being run to test service offerings for compliance.
100- The standards and the corresponding tests are versioned. The SCS-compatible certification
101+ The standards and the corresponding tests are versioned. The * SCS-compatible* certification
101102for a specific layer (currently IaaS or KaaS) and version is called a * certification scope* .
102103Please see [ Scopes and Versions] ( scopes-versions.md ) for detailed definitions.
103104
@@ -117,4 +118,3 @@ that such software can also be certified.
117118Implementation partners from the SCS ecosystem may support operators (CSPs) to build
118119and operate SCS-compatible infrastructure. A certification program that certifies the
119120skills and experience of such partners is planned as well.
120-
0 commit comments