Skip to content

Taking stochastic control flow a bit more seriously #25

@mohamed82008

Description

@mohamed82008

Currently, we support a variable number of random variables but only when the random variables are elements of an array that's always at least partially sampled. That is each "symbol" in the model is assumed to be visited every time you run the model. This is enough most of the time and indeed one can group together all optional parameters in a vector and use this method, however it fails to address models of the form:

@model demo(x) = begin
    a ~ Uniform()
    if a > 0.5
        b ~ Normal(a)
        x ~ Normal(b)
    else
        c ~ Uniform()
        x ~ Normal(c)
    end
end

Note that b and c will not always be "visited". The current VarInfo setup will therefore fail in those cases. One way to address this is to have an UntypedVarInfo stored inside the TypedVarInfo for previously unseen variable symbols. Then during the sampling, we can check at every iteration if there are new symbols sampled. If so, we create a new spl::Sampler whose spl.state.vi is an instance of the expanded TypedVarInfo. If we do this right, I think we will not be paying any penalty in the case where all the symbols are always visited, and we may need to pay only a small dynamic dispatch price per new symbol seen, keeping the remaining of the code type stable.

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions