fix: proper server type registration

[cristipufu]

No description provided.

[cristipufu]

/help review

[cristipufu]

/ai generated [2849346244]

Code Review for PR #91: "fix: proper server type registration"

Changed Files Overview

1. pyproject.toml

   • Version bump from 0.0.77 to 0.0.78.

2. src/uipath_mcp/_cli/_runtime/_context.py

   • Added a new UiPathServerType enum with documentation and utility methods.
   • No breaking changes to existing classes.

3. src/uipath_mcp/_cli/_runtime/_runtime.py

   • Refactored server type registration logic.
   • Introduced new properties (packaged, server_type) to determine server type.
   • Updated registration payload to use the new server type logic.
   • Improved code formatting and error handling in some places.

---

Detailed Review

1. pyproject.toml

• Good: Proper version bump to reflect a new feature/fix.
• No Issues.

2. src/uipath_mcp/_cli/_runtime/_context.py

• Good:
  • The introduction of UiPathServerType as an Enum is a good practice for type safety and clarity.
  • The enum is well-documented, with clear descriptions for each type.
  • Utility methods (from_string, get_description) are helpful for future extensibility and code clarity.
• Suggestions:
  • Consider adding unit tests for the new enum and its methods.
  • The from_string method could be case-insensitive for robustness, unless strict matching is required.

3. src/uipath_mcp/_cli/_runtime/_runtime.py

• Good:
  • The logic for determining the server type is now encapsulated in the server_type property, improving maintainability.
  • The packaged property is a clear and concise way to check for packaged runtimes.
  • The registration payload now uses the correct server type value, which should fix any misregistration issues.
  • Minor formatting and error handling improvements increase code readability.
• Issues/Concerns:
  • The logic for determining server type is based on the presence of process_key and job_id. Ensure that these fields are always set as expected in all runtime scenarios.
  • The fallback in server_type returns Hosted if neither packaged nor sandboxed is true. Is this always the correct default? If not, consider logging a warning or raising an exception for unexpected states.
  • The Type field for tools in the registration payload is now omitted (was previously hardcoded as 1). If this is intentional and the backend does not require it, that's fine; otherwise, double-check for regressions.
• Suggestions:
  • Add or update tests to cover the new server type logic, especially edge cases.
  • Consider logging the determined server type during registration for easier debugging.
  • If possible, document the expected values for process_key and job_id in the class or method docstrings.

---

General Observations

• Backward Compatibility: No breaking changes detected.
• Code Quality: The refactor improves clarity and maintainability.
• Testing: No test changes are included in this PR. Tests should be added or updated to cover the new logic.
• Documentation: Enum and methods are well-documented.

---

Summary

• ✅ Good use of enums for server type.
• ✅ Improved registration logic and code clarity.
• ⚠️ Ensure tests cover new logic and edge cases.
• ⚠️ Double-check the omission of the Type field for tools in the registration payload.
• 💡 Consider minor improvements for robustness and logging.

Overall, this is a solid and maintainable improvement. Address the above suggestions for best results.