Skip to content

Commit d51274c

Browse files
stanleykcstanleykc
committed
Updated the spec status to reflect current implementation
Signed-off-by: Kevin Stanley <[email protected]>
1 parent 1b8c9f5 commit d51274c

File tree

3 files changed

+338
-15
lines changed

3 files changed

+338
-15
lines changed

‎specs/001-unityauth-cli/implementation-status.md‎

Lines changed: 314 additions & 0 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,314 @@
1+
# UnityAuth CLI Implementation Status
2+
3+
**Generated**: 2025-12-31
4+
**Spec Version**: 1.0.0
5+
**Implementation Progress**: ~78% Complete
6+
7+
---
8+
9+
## Executive Summary
10+
11+
The UnityAuth CLI is substantially implemented with all P1-P3 user stories complete. P4 (Permission Verification) is partially implemented, and P5 (Batch Operations) is not started. The implementation follows the spec closely with minor naming deviations.
12+
13+
---
14+
15+
## Functional Requirements Compliance Matrix
16+
17+
| Requirement | Description | Status | Notes |
18+
|-------------|-------------|--------|-------|
19+
| **FR-001** | Authenticate via email/password | ✅ Implemented | `login` command |
20+
| **FR-002** | Secure OS-native token storage | ✅ Implemented | keyring library |
21+
| **FR-003** | Auto-detect expired tokens | ⚠️ Partial | 401 caught but user must manually re-login |
22+
| **FR-004** | Create user with attributes | ✅ Implemented | `user create` command |
23+
| **FR-005** | Update user role assignments | ✅ Implemented | `user update` command (note: T039 backend issue) |
24+
| **FR-006** | Users update own profile | ✅ Implemented | `user update-profile` command (bonus feature) |
25+
| **FR-007** | List accessible tenants | ✅ Implemented | `tenant list` command |
26+
| **FR-008** | List users in tenant | ✅ Implemented | `tenant users` and `user list` commands |
27+
| **FR-009** | List all roles | ✅ Implemented | `role list` command |
28+
| **FR-010** | Query permissions for tenant/service | ✅ Implemented | `permissions list` command |
29+
| **FR-011** | Check specific permissions | ❌ Not Implemented | Missing `permission check` command |
30+
| **FR-012** | Permission-based access control | ✅ Implemented | Via API enforcement |
31+
| **FR-013** | Clear error messages | ✅ Implemented | Rich-styled errors with guidance |
32+
| **FR-014** | Batch user creation from CSV | ❌ Not Implemented | Entire batch module missing |
33+
| **FR-015** | Configurable output formats | ✅ Implemented | table/JSON/CSV via `-o` flag |
34+
| **FR-016** | API endpoint configuration | ✅ Implemented | `config set api_url` and `init` wizard |
35+
| **FR-017** | Input validation | ✅ Implemented | `utils/validation.py` |
36+
| **FR-018** | Interactive/non-interactive modes | ✅ Implemented | TTY detection with prompts |
37+
| **FR-019** | Dry-run mode for batch | ❌ Not Implemented | No batch module exists |
38+
| **FR-020** | Verbose output mode | ✅ Implemented | `-v/--verbose` flag |
39+
| **FR-021** | View token info | ✅ Implemented | `token-info` command |
40+
| **FR-022** | Logout operation | ✅ Implemented | `logout` command |
41+
| **FR-023** | Rate limit error with retry-after | ✅ Implemented | `RateLimitError` in client.py:245-251 |
42+
| **FR-024** | API version compatibility check | ✅ Implemented | `_check_version_compatibility` in client.py:257-281 |
43+
44+
**Summary**: 20/24 requirements implemented (83%)
45+
46+
---
47+
48+
## User Story Implementation Status
49+
50+
### User Story 1: System Administrator Authentication (P1) - ✅ COMPLETE
51+
52+
| Acceptance Scenario | Status | Implementation |
53+
|---------------------|--------|----------------|
54+
| Login with valid credentials stores token | ✅ Pass | `login` command + keyring |
55+
| Authenticated commands use stored token | ✅ Pass | `@require_auth` decorator |
56+
| Logout removes credentials | ✅ Pass | `logout` command |
57+
| Invalid credentials shows clear error | ✅ Pass | `AuthenticationError` class |
58+
| Expired token prompts re-auth | ⚠️ Partial | 401 detected, manual re-login required |
59+
60+
**Files**: `commands/login.py`, `auth.py`, `cli.py` (`@require_auth`)
61+
62+
---
63+
64+
### User Story 2: User Account Management (P2) - ✅ COMPLETE (with known issue)
65+
66+
| Acceptance Scenario | Status | Implementation |
67+
|---------------------|--------|----------------|
68+
| Create user with attributes | ✅ Pass | `user create` command |
69+
| Update user roles for tenant | ⚠️ Backend Issue | `user update` - T039: 403 from backend |
70+
| List users for tenant | ✅ Pass | `user list` command |
71+
| Permission denied shows clear error | ✅ Pass | `AuthorizationError` handling |
72+
| Validation errors with details | ✅ Pass | `ValidationError` with guidance |
73+
74+
**Files**: `commands/users.py`
75+
76+
**Known Issue (T039)**: `user update` command sends correct payload to `PATCH /api/users/{id}/roles` but backend returns 403. Requires backend investigation.
77+
78+
---
79+
80+
### User Story 3: Tenant and Role Discovery (P3) - ✅ COMPLETE
81+
82+
| Acceptance Scenario | Status | Implementation |
83+
|---------------------|--------|----------------|
84+
| List accessible tenants | ✅ Pass | `tenant list` command |
85+
| List all roles with descriptions | ✅ Pass | `role list` command |
86+
| View tenant users | ✅ Pass | `tenant users` command |
87+
| Unity admin sees all tenants | ✅ Pass | Via API permission filtering |
88+
| Tenant admin sees only their tenants | ✅ Pass | Via API permission filtering |
89+
90+
**Files**: `commands/tenants.py`, `commands/roles.py`
91+
92+
---
93+
94+
### User Story 4: Permission Verification (P4) - ⚠️ PARTIALLY IMPLEMENTED
95+
96+
| Acceptance Scenario | Status | Implementation |
97+
|---------------------|--------|----------------|
98+
| Get permissions for user/tenant/service | ✅ Pass | `permissions list` command |
99+
| Check specific named permissions | ❌ Not Implemented | Missing `permission check` |
100+
| Inactive user/tenant error | ❓ Untested | Depends on API response |
101+
| Service unavailable error | ❓ Untested | Depends on API response |
102+
103+
**Files**: `commands/permissions.py`
104+
105+
**Missing**: The `permission check` command per contracts/commands.yml that calls `POST /api/hasPermission` is not implemented. Only `permissions list` (equivalent to `permission get` in spec) exists.
106+
107+
---
108+
109+
### User Story 5: Batch Operations (P5) - ❌ NOT IMPLEMENTED
110+
111+
| Feature | Status | Notes |
112+
|---------|--------|-------|
113+
| Batch create users from CSV | ❌ Missing | No `commands/batch.py` exists |
114+
| Dry-run mode for preview | ❌ Missing | Included in batch requirements |
115+
| Continue-on-error behavior | ❌ Missing | Included in batch requirements |
116+
| Rich progress bars | ❌ Missing | Included in batch requirements |
117+
| CSV validation with errors | ❌ Missing | Included in batch requirements |
118+
119+
**Missing Files**: `commands/batch.py`, `utils/batch.py`
120+
121+
---
122+
123+
## Command Structure Comparison
124+
125+
### Spec vs Implementation
126+
127+
| Spec Command (contracts/commands.yml) | Implementation | Status |
128+
|---------------------------------------|----------------|--------|
129+
| `unityauth login` | `login` | ✅ Match |
130+
| `unityauth logout` | `logout` | ✅ Match |
131+
| `unityauth token-info` | `token-info` | ✅ Match |
132+
| `unityauth config show` | `config show` | ✅ Match |
133+
| `unityauth config set` | `config set` | ✅ Match |
134+
| `unityauth config edit` | `config edit` | ✅ Match |
135+
| `unityauth user create` | `user create` | ✅ Match |
136+
| `unityauth user update` | `user update` | ✅ Match |
137+
| `unityauth user list` | `user list` | ✅ Match |
138+
| `unityauth tenant list` | `tenant list` | ✅ Match |
139+
| `unityauth tenant users` | `tenant users` | ✅ Match |
140+
| `unityauth role list` | `role list` | ✅ Match |
141+
| `unityauth permission get` | `permissions list` | ⚠️ Renamed |
142+
| `unityauth permission check` | N/A | ❌ Missing |
143+
| `unityauth batch create-users` | N/A | ❌ Missing |
144+
145+
### Extra Commands (Not in Spec)
146+
147+
| Command | Description | Status |
148+
|---------|-------------|--------|
149+
| `unityauth init` | First-time setup wizard | ✅ Bonus (from usability-recommendations.md) |
150+
| `unityauth user update-profile` | Self-service profile update | ✅ Bonus (implements FR-006) |
151+
152+
---
153+
154+
## Naming Deviations
155+
156+
| Spec Name | Implementation Name | Rationale |
157+
|-----------|---------------------|-----------|
158+
| `permission get` | `permissions list` | More intuitive (lists permissions) |
159+
| `permission check` | N/A | Not implemented |
160+
| Command group: `permission` | Command group: `permissions` | Plural for consistency |
161+
162+
---
163+
164+
## Output Format Compliance
165+
166+
All implemented commands support the three output formats specified:
167+
168+
| Format | Spec | Implementation | Status |
169+
|--------|------|----------------|--------|
170+
| table | Default human-readable | tabulate library with grid style | ✅ |
171+
| json | Machine-readable JSON | stdlib json | ✅ |
172+
| csv | Spreadsheet-compatible | stdlib csv | ✅ |
173+
174+
The `-o/--format` option is available both globally and per-command as specified.
175+
176+
---
177+
178+
## Exit Code Compliance
179+
180+
| Code | Spec Meaning | Implementation | Status |
181+
|------|--------------|----------------|--------|
182+
| 0 | SUCCESS | All commands | ✅ |
183+
| 1 | GENERAL_ERROR | `ValidationError`, `NetworkError` | ✅ |
184+
| 2 | AUTHENTICATION_ERROR | `AuthenticationError` | ✅ |
185+
| 3 | PERMISSION_ERROR | `AuthorizationError` | ✅ |
186+
| 4 | CONFIGURATION_ERROR | `ConfigurationError` | ✅ |
187+
188+
**Files**: `utils/errors.py` defines all error classes with exit codes.
189+
190+
---
191+
192+
## Short Flag Implementation (usability-recommendations.md)
193+
194+
| Flag | Spec | Status | Notes |
195+
|------|------|--------|-------|
196+
| `-t` for `--tenant-id` | P1 | ✅ Implemented | users, permissions commands |
197+
| `-o` for `--format` | P1 | ✅ Implemented | Global option |
198+
| `-v` for `--verbose` | P1 | ✅ Implemented | Global option |
199+
| `-r` for `--role-ids` | P1 | ✅ Implemented | user create/update |
200+
| `-s` for `--service-id` | P1 | ✅ Implemented | permissions list |
201+
| `-n` for `--dry-run` | P2 | ✅ Implemented | Mutating commands |
202+
| `-e` for `--email` | P1 | Deferred | Low frequency use |
203+
| `-f` for `--first-name` | P1 | Deferred | Low frequency use |
204+
| `-l` for `--last-name` | P1 | Deferred | Low frequency use |
205+
| `-p` for `--password` | P1 | Deferred | Security (prefer prompts) |
206+
207+
---
208+
209+
## Remaining Work Summary
210+
211+
### Phase 6: Permission Verification (T048-T052)
212+
213+
- [ ] T048: Implement `permission get` command (rename existing `permissions list`)
214+
- [ ] T049: Implement `permission check` command (`POST /api/hasPermission`)
215+
- [ ] T050: Add permission command group to CLI
216+
- [ ] T051: Add formatted output for permission lists
217+
- [ ] T052: Add error handling for inactive users/tenants/services
218+
219+
### Phase 7: Batch Operations (T053-T061)
220+
221+
- [ ] T053: Create `BatchUserRecord` dataclass with validation
222+
- [ ] T054: Implement CSV parser with UTF-8 and header validation
223+
- [ ] T055: Implement `batch create-users` command
224+
- [ ] T056: Add `--dry-run` mode for batch operations
225+
- [ ] T057: Add `--continue-on-error` flag
226+
- [ ] T058: Add batch command group to CLI
227+
- [ ] T059: Implement Rich progress bars
228+
- [ ] T060: Add batch operation summary report
229+
- [ ] T061: Add CSV validation with specific error messages
230+
231+
### Phase 8: Polish (T070-T073)
232+
233+
- [ ] T070: Update root CLAUDE.md with CLI documentation
234+
- [ ] T071: Update root README.md with CLI reference
235+
- [ ] T072: Create sample CSV files in tests/fixtures/
236+
- [ ] T073: Validate quickstart.md examples
237+
238+
### Usability Recommendations (Pending)
239+
240+
From `usability-recommendations.md`:
241+
242+
- [ ] Add `whoami` command (alias for token-info)
243+
- [ ] Interactive wizard for `user create`
244+
- [ ] Allow empty `--role-ids` to remove all roles
245+
- [ ] Add typo suggestions (`click-didyoumean`)
246+
- [ ] Improve empty state messages
247+
- [ ] Name-based lookups (tenant/role names instead of IDs)
248+
- [ ] Command aliases (`users`, `tenants`, `roles`, `perms`)
249+
- [ ] `--quiet` flag for scripting
250+
- [ ] Grouped help output by category
251+
- [ ] Confirmation prompts for destructive actions
252+
253+
---
254+
255+
## Implementation Quality Notes
256+
257+
### Strengths
258+
259+
1. **Decorator pattern**: `@require_auth` and `@require_config` eliminate boilerplate
260+
2. **Error hierarchy**: Comprehensive error classes with exit codes and guidance
261+
3. **Output flexibility**: All commands support table/JSON/CSV formats
262+
4. **Rich integration**: Styled output for better UX
263+
5. **Short flags**: Common options have short versions for faster typing
264+
6. **Dry-run support**: Mutating commands preview changes before execution
265+
7. **Setup wizard**: `init` command simplifies first-time configuration
266+
267+
### Areas for Improvement
268+
269+
1. **Auto re-authentication**: Expired tokens require manual re-login
270+
2. **Batch operations**: Critical for automation workflows - not implemented
271+
3. **Permission checking**: Only list, no check for specific permissions
272+
4. **Empty state messages**: Could be more helpful with next steps
273+
274+
---
275+
276+
## Files Reference
277+
278+
### Core Implementation
279+
280+
| File | Purpose | Lines |
281+
|------|---------|-------|
282+
| `cli.py` | Main CLI group, decorators, output helpers | 340 |
283+
| `client.py` | API client with error mapping | 282 |
284+
| `config.py` | Configuration management | ~150 |
285+
| `auth.py` | Token storage via keyring | ~80 |
286+
287+
### Commands
288+
289+
| File | Commands | Status |
290+
|------|----------|--------|
291+
| `commands/login.py` | login, logout, token-info | ✅ Complete |
292+
| `commands/users.py` | create, update, update-profile, list | ✅ Complete |
293+
| `commands/tenants.py` | list, users | ✅ Complete |
294+
| `commands/roles.py` | list | ✅ Complete |
295+
| `commands/permissions.py` | list | ⚠️ Missing `check` |
296+
| `commands/config.py` | show, set, edit | ✅ Complete |
297+
| `commands/init.py` | init | ✅ Complete |
298+
| `commands/batch.py` | N/A | ❌ Not created |
299+
300+
### Utilities
301+
302+
| File | Purpose | Status |
303+
|------|---------|--------|
304+
| `utils/errors.py` | Custom exceptions | ✅ Complete |
305+
| `utils/validation.py` | Input validators | ✅ Complete |
306+
| `utils/batch.py` | CSV parsing | ❌ Not created |
307+
308+
### Formatters
309+
310+
| File | Format | Status |
311+
|------|--------|--------|
312+
| `formatters/table.py` | table output | ✅ Complete |
313+
| `formatters/json_fmt.py` | JSON output | ✅ Complete |
314+
| `formatters/csv_fmt.py` | CSV output | ✅ Complete |

‎specs/001-unityauth-cli/tasks.md‎

Lines changed: 19 additions & 12 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -134,13 +134,17 @@
134134

135135
### Implementation for User Story 4
136136

137-
- [ ] T048 [P] [US4] Implement permission get command in unityauth-cli/src/unityauth_cli/commands/permissions.py calling POST /api/principal/permissions (uses @require_auth decorator)
137+
**Status Note**: `permissions list` command is already implemented (equivalent to spec's `permission get`), using `POST /api/principal/permissions`. Only `permission check` is missing.
138+
139+
- [x] T048 [P] [US4] Implement permission get command (IMPLEMENTED as `permissions list` in unityauth-cli/src/unityauth_cli/commands/permissions.py) calling POST /api/principal/permissions (uses @require_auth decorator)
138140
- [ ] T049 [P] [US4] Implement permission check command in unityauth-cli/src/unityauth_cli/commands/permissions.py calling POST /api/hasPermission (uses @require_auth decorator)
139-
- [ ] T050 [US4] Add permission command group to CLI in unityauth-cli/src/unityauth_cli/cli.py with subcommands (get, check)
140-
- [ ] T051 [US4] Add formatted output for permission lists (readable list format with scope indicators)
141+
- [x] T050 [US4] Add permission command group to CLI (IMPLEMENTED as `permissions` group in unityauth-cli/src/unityauth_cli/cli.py)
142+
- [x] T051 [US4] Add formatted output for permission lists (IMPLEMENTED with table/JSON/CSV support)
141143
- [ ] T052 [US4] Add error handling for inactive users/tenants/services with clear status messages
142144

143-
**Checkpoint**: Permission verification fully functional - useful for debugging and validation scenarios
145+
**Deviation from Spec**: Command is named `permissions list` instead of `permission get` for more intuitive naming. The `permission check` command (FR-011) is NOT implemented.
146+
147+
**Checkpoint**: Permission listing functional - `permission check` command needed for full story completion
144148

145149
---
146150

@@ -234,32 +238,35 @@ All commands MUST use:
234238
- ✅ Phase 3: User Story 1 - COMPLETE with unit tests
235239
- ✅ Phase 4: User Story 2 - COMPLETE (except T039 research for update 403 issue)
236240
- ✅ Phase 5: User Story 3 - COMPLETE (tenant list, tenant users, role list with formatting)
237-
- ⏳ Phase 6: User Story 4 - NOT STARTED
238-
- ⏳ Phase 7: User Story 5 - NOT STARTED
241+
- 🔄 Phase 6: User Story 4 - PARTIALLY COMPLETE (`permissions list` works, `permission check` missing)
242+
- ⏳ Phase 7: User Story 5 - NOT STARTED (batch operations)
239243
- 🔄 Phase 8: Polish - PARTIALLY COMPLETE (config commands done, docs pending)
240244

241245
---
242246

243247
## Summary Statistics
244248

245249
- **Total Tasks**: 73 tasks
246-
- **Completed**: 57 tasks ✅
247-
- **Remaining**: 16 tasks
250+
- **Completed**: 60 tasks ✅
251+
- **Remaining**: 13 tasks
248252
- **Setup Phase**: 6 tasks (COMPLETE)
249253
- **Foundational Phase**: 12 tasks (COMPLETE - includes architectural improvements)
250254
- **User Story 1 (P1)**: 13 tasks - Authentication 🎯 MVP (COMPLETE with tests)
251255
- **User Story 2 (P2)**: 9 tasks - User Management (8 complete, 1 research pending)
252256
- **User Story 3 (P3)**: 7 tasks - Discovery (COMPLETE)
253-
- **User Story 4 (P4)**: 5 tasks - Permission Verification (NOT STARTED)
257+
- **User Story 4 (P4)**: 5 tasks - Permission Verification (3 complete, 2 remaining - `permission check` not implemented)
254258
- **User Story 5 (P5)**: 9 tasks - Batch Operations (NOT STARTED)
255259
- **Polish Phase**: 12 tasks - Cross-cutting concerns (8 complete, 4 pending)
256260

257261
**Parallel Opportunities**: 35 tasks marked [P] can run in parallel within their phases
258262

263+
**Implementation Status**: See [implementation-status.md](implementation-status.md) for detailed comparison against spec.
264+
259265
**Next Steps**:
260-
1. Complete T039 (research update 403 issue)
261-
2. Implement Phase 6: User Story 4 (Permission Verification)
262-
3. Update documentation (T070, T071)
266+
1. Complete T039 (research update 403 issue for `user update` command)
267+
2. Implement T049 (`permission check` command calling POST /api/hasPermission)
268+
3. Implement Phase 7: Batch Operations (T053-T061)
269+
4. Update documentation (T070, T071)
263270

264271
**Format Validation**: ✅ ALL tasks follow the checklist format: `- [ ] [TaskID] [P?] [Story?] Description with file path`
265272

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)