About the Security groups

[leo79901]

I have installed an ACS with 'Core - Basic' zone. When I want to change the VM's name, display or other information, ACS tells me that I cannot change the security groups.
Is this correct?
Meanwhile, can't I change the security groups while the VMs are running? If this is true, I have to create a new security group for every VM.

[rajujith]

@leo79901 You should be allowed to change or display the name on a running instance. This error seems to be a bug with the basic zone only or any instance with a security group. Do you mind creating an issue ticket?

You have to stop the instance to change the security group.
You can use one security group for many instances.

[weizhouapache]

it looks like the restriction was added 8 years ago and it is still there

5877293

[leo79901]

Thanks a lot. In order to provide more flexible security protection, before it possible to adjust the security groups when the machine is powered on, I will create a separate security group for each host.

[NuxRo]

@leo79901 if you do it from cmk/cloudmonkey does it work?

[leo79901]

Yes, i have do it again using CloudMonkey. The name was changed successfully.

[weizhouapache]

in my opinion,

• the first issue is a bug. since security groups cannot be changed when vm is running, we should hide the field in the dialog.
• the second can be a improvement request: Update security group lists of a running vm

[leo79901]

Thanks a lot, i will do it.

[weizhouapache]

please keep eye on #10714 which aim to fix the first issue

[weizhouapache]

new feature request: #10729