Skip to content

Unexpected behavior when adding external targets to srcs #88

@juanzolotoochin

Description

@juanzolotoochin

The external/<name> part of the source files is removed by tar.bzl when creating a tar archive. For example for the following target:

load("@tar.bzl//:tar.bzl", "mutate", "tar")

tar(
    name = "tar",
    srcs = ["@multitool//tools/gh:gh"]
)

To repro:

$ git clone git@github.com:juanique/bazel-examples.git

$ cd bazel-examples

$ git checkout tar-external-repro

$ cd bazel8/tar_repro

$ bazel build :tar

$ tar -tf bazel-bin/tar.tar

expected output is something along the lines of:

external/rules_multitool++multitool+multitool/tools/
external/rules_multitool++multitool+multitool/tools/gh
external/rules_multitool++multitool+multitool/tools/gh/gh

Actual output is:

tools/
tools/gh/
tools/gh/gh
tar: Removing leading `../' from member names
../rules_multitool++multitool+multitool/tools/gh/gh.runfiles/
../rules_multitool++multitool+multitool/tools/gh/gh.runfiles/rules_multitool++multitool+multitool/
../rules_multitool++multitool+multitool/tools/gh/gh.runfiles/rules_multitool++multitool+multitool/tools/
../rules_multitool++multitool+multitool/tools/gh/gh.runfiles/rules_multitool++multitool+multitool/tools/gh/
../rules_multitool++multitool+multitool/tools/gh/gh.runfiles/rules_multitool++multitool+multitool/tools/gh/gh
../rules_multitool++multitool+multitool/tools/gh/gh.runfiles/_repo_mapping

Untaring the archive:

$ mkdir /tmp/tar_repro

$ tar -xf bazel-bin/tar.tar -C /tmp/tar_repro

tar: Removing leading `../' from member names
tar: ../rules_multitool++multitool+multitool/tools/gh/gh.runfiles/: Member name contains '..'
tar: ../rules_multitool++multitool+multitool/tools/gh/gh.runfiles/rules_multitool++multitool+multitool/: Member name contains '..'
tar: ../rules_multitool++multitool+multitool/tools/gh/gh.runfiles/rules_multitool++multitool+multitool/tools/: Member name contains '..'
tar: ../rules_multitool++multitool+multitool/tools/gh/gh.runfiles/rules_multitool++multitool+multitool/tools/gh/: Member name contains '..'
tar: ../rules_multitool++multitool+multitool/tools/gh/gh.runfiles/rules_multitool++multitool+multitool/tools/gh/gh: Member name contains '..'
tar: ../rules_multitool++multitool+multitool/tools/gh/gh.runfiles/_repo_mapping: Member name contains '..'
tar: Exiting with failure status due to previous errors

$ find /tmp/tar_repro

/tmp/tar_repro
/tmp/tar_repro/tools
/tmp/tar_repro/tools/gh
/tmp/tar_repro/tools/gh/gh

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions