About table sorting

[alexandru-dinu]

Hello Michael,

I just noticed that "table sorting" is listed under your roadmap.

I am developing obsidian-sortable, a simple plugin to achieve this, and I thought about the possibility of merging the plugin's functionality into dataview, in order to keep things consistent; especially with the latest release that brought auto refresh (see this issue).

A middle ground solution may be to make sortable a dependency of dataview, so that people that don't use dataview will not lose table sorting.

What do you think?

Thank you,
Alex

[blacksmithgu]

Does obsidian-sortable just operate on HTML tables? If so, would be happy to see about integrating it in a smart way (since dataview already has a pretty good internal sort algorithm).

[alexandru-dinu]

Does obsidian-sortable just operate on HTML tables?

Yes, it simply reorders table rows (tr elements) based on the column data of the clicked header.

[...] integrating it in a smart way (since dataview already has a pretty good internal sort algorithm).

What do you think it's the best way to do it? The plugin has no additional dependencies (other than the ones required by Obsidian), so it should be straightforward to integrate it.

Thanks!

[Moonbase59]

Hi there! Would love to see some collaboration here.

Related:

• https://forum.obsidian.md/t/dataviewjs-snippet-showcase/17847/16?u=moonbase59
• Check integration with obsidian-dataview alexandru-dinu/obsidian-sortable#6
• Feature Request (future): Add hook for individual sorting function (comparator function) alexandru-dinu/obsidian-sortable#12

[ghost]

Any updates on this? It's been a while.

[blacksmithgu]

It might be revisited in the near future since dynamic table column sorting is coming, though Dataview now has a relatively robust internal sorting mechanism so I'm not sure yet.

[alexandru-dinu]

Come to think of it, it's better to have Sortable and Dataview as separate plugins. One option is to let users sort Dataview tables using your own mechanism, and I can add a setting to ignore Dataview tables for this case (i.e. let Sortable operate only on "vanilla" tables).

[brandonzylstra]

@alexandru-dinu if/when Dataview adds dynamic sorting, could Sortable automatically disable its own sorting for tables generated by Dataview if the plugin version of Dataview is new enough to support dynamic sorting?

[AB1908]

May want to put this idea on hold since Michael is working on Datacore