Skip to content

Commit c0e15ec

Browse files
committed
docs(phase-14): close TA-P14-006 and pass gate
1 parent 77af789 commit c0e15ec

20 files changed

+304
-19
lines changed

docs/implementation/gates/README.md

Lines changed: 2 additions & 1 deletion
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -1,6 +1,6 @@
11
# TelAgent v1 Phase Gate 目录
22

3-
- 文档版本:v1.0
3+
- 文档版本:v1.1
44
- 目的:统一记录每个 Phase 的 Gate 评审结论,作为下一阶段启动依据
55

66
## 1. 使用规则
@@ -30,6 +30,7 @@
3030
- `phase-11-gate.md`:Phase 11 评审记录
3131
- `phase-12-gate.md`:Phase 12 评审记录
3232
- `phase-13-gate.md`:Phase 13 评审记录
33+
- `phase-14-gate.md`:Phase 14 评审记录
3334

3435
## 3. 推荐流程
3536

Lines changed: 59 additions & 0 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,59 @@
1+
# TelAgent v1 Phase 14 Gate
2+
3+
- Phase:`Phase 14(产品聚焦与缺陷收敛)`
4+
- Gate 编号:`TA-GATE-P14`
5+
- 实际评审日期:`2026-03-03`
6+
- 最近更新:`2026-03-03`
7+
- 主持人(TL):`Agent-TL`
8+
- 参与人:`BE/FE/QA/DX/Security/TL`
9+
- 结论:`PASS`
10+
11+
## 1) 输入物检查
12+
13+
- [x] WBS 中 `TA-P14-001` ~ `TA-P14-006` 已更新状态
14+
- [x] Phase 14 全量任务文档与日志已归档
15+
- [x] `manifests/` 全量机读清单结论为 `PASS`
16+
- [x] Web/Node/SDK 构建与回归证据已归档
17+
18+
## 2) Exit Criteria 核对
19+
20+
| 条目 | 结果 | 证据路径 | 备注 |
21+
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
22+
| 默认 Web 运维面板下线(保留核心链路) | PASS | `docs/implementation/phase-14/manifests/2026-03-03-p14-web-ops-removal-check.json` | `decision=PASS` |
23+
| 消息拉取稳定游标改造通过(TA-P14-003) | PASS | `docs/implementation/phase-14/manifests/2026-03-03-p14-stable-pull-cursor-check.json` | `global/conversation cursor stable` |
24+
| direct 会话参与方访问控制通过(TA-P14-004) | PASS | `docs/implementation/phase-14/manifests/2026-03-03-p14-direct-session-acl-check.json` | `403 + RFC7807 + code=FORBIDDEN` |
25+
| TS/Python SDK 行为收敛通过(TA-P14-005) | PASS | `docs/implementation/phase-14/manifests/2026-03-03-p14-sdk-parity-check.json` | identity encoding + direct ACL error semantics parity |
26+
| manifests 汇总校验通过 | PASS | `docs/implementation/phase-14/logs/2026-03-03-p14-gate-manifest-summary.txt` | `failed=0` |
27+
| 回归测试通过 | PASS | `docs/implementation/phase-14/logs/2026-03-03-p14-gate-node-test.txt` | `89/89` |
28+
| SDK 测试通过(TS + Python) | PASS | `docs/implementation/phase-14/logs/2026-03-03-p14-gate-sdk-ts-test.txt`, `docs/implementation/phase-14/logs/2026-03-03-p14-gate-sdk-python-test.txt` | `4/4` + `4/4` |
29+
30+
## 3) 风险与阻塞
31+
32+
| 风险/阻塞 | 影响 | Owner | 截止日期 | 状态 |
33+
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
34+
| direct 会话参与方约束当前基于“首两位发送者”建模,未引入显式协商层 | 对复杂 direct 会话迁移场景可扩展性有限 | BE + Security | Phase 15 | ACCEPTED |
35+
| 当前无硬阻塞项 | - | - | - | N/A |
36+
37+
## 4) 条件放行补丁项(仅 CONDITIONAL PASS 填写)
38+
39+
| 补丁项 | Owner | 截止日期 | 验收标准 | 状态 |
40+
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
41+
|| - | - | - | N/A |
42+
43+
## 5) 结论说明
44+
45+
- 决策摘要:Phase 14 `TA-P14-001` ~ `TA-P14-005` 已完成并具备机读化证据,Gate 收口检查通过。
46+
- 是否允许关闭 Phase 14:`YES`
47+
- 是否允许进入 Phase 15:`YES`
48+
49+
## 6) 签字
50+
51+
- TL:`Agent-TL`
52+
- Phase Owner(BE/FE/Security/DX):`Agent-BE`
53+
- QA:`Agent-QA`
54+
55+
## 7) 阶段进展快照(2026-03-03)
56+
57+
- 已完成任务:`TA-P14-001``TA-P14-002``TA-P14-003``TA-P14-004``TA-P14-005``TA-P14-006`
58+
- 证据目录:`docs/implementation/phase-14/README.md`
59+
- 当前结论:`PASS`,Phase 14 正式关闭。

docs/implementation/phase-14/README.md

Lines changed: 14 additions & 3 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -1,7 +1,7 @@
11
# TelAgent v1 Phase 14 执行产出(产品聚焦与缺陷收敛)
22

3-
- 文档版本:v1.3
4-
- 状态:Phase 14 执行中
3+
- 文档版本:v1.4
4+
- 状态:Phase 14 已关闭(Gate=PASS)
55
- 最后更新:2026-03-03
66

77
## 1. 阶段定位
@@ -20,7 +20,7 @@ Phase 14 回归 P2P 应用核心体验,聚焦“可用性、正确性、收敛
2020
| TA-P14-003 | DONE | 消息拉取稳定游标改造(替代 offset 风险) |
2121
| TA-P14-004 | DONE | direct 会话参与方与访问约束强化 |
2222
| TA-P14-005 | DONE | TS/Python SDK 核心行为收敛与错误语义统一 |
23-
| TA-P14-006 | TODO | 回归验证与 Gate 收口 |
23+
| TA-P14-006 | DONE | 回归验证与 Gate 收口 |
2424

2525
## 3. 当前证据
2626

@@ -29,6 +29,7 @@ Phase 14 回归 P2P 应用核心体验,聚焦“可用性、正确性、收敛
2929
- `ta-p14-003-stable-pull-cursor-2026-03-03.md`
3030
- `ta-p14-004-direct-session-acl-2026-03-03.md`
3131
- `ta-p14-005-sdk-parity-and-error-semantics-2026-03-03.md`
32+
- `ta-p14-006-phase14-gate-review-2026-03-03.md`
3233
- `logs/2026-03-03-p14-web-build.txt`
3334
- `logs/2026-03-03-p14-web-ops-removal-check.txt`
3435
- `logs/2026-03-03-p14-node-build.txt`
@@ -40,7 +41,17 @@ Phase 14 回归 P2P 应用核心体验,聚焦“可用性、正确性、收敛
4041
- `logs/2026-03-03-p14-sdk-ts-test.txt`
4142
- `logs/2026-03-03-p14-sdk-python-test.txt`
4243
- `logs/2026-03-03-p14-sdk-parity-check-run.txt`
44+
- `logs/2026-03-03-p14-gate-web-build.txt`
45+
- `logs/2026-03-03-p14-gate-node-build.txt`
46+
- `logs/2026-03-03-p14-gate-node-test.txt`
47+
- `logs/2026-03-03-p14-gate-sdk-ts-test.txt`
48+
- `logs/2026-03-03-p14-gate-sdk-python-test.txt`
49+
- `logs/2026-03-03-p14-gate-stable-pull-cursor-check-run.txt`
50+
- `logs/2026-03-03-p14-gate-direct-session-acl-check-run.txt`
51+
- `logs/2026-03-03-p14-gate-sdk-parity-check-run.txt`
52+
- `logs/2026-03-03-p14-gate-manifest-summary.txt`
4353
- `manifests/2026-03-03-p14-web-ops-removal-check.json`
4454
- `manifests/2026-03-03-p14-stable-pull-cursor-check.json`
4555
- `manifests/2026-03-03-p14-direct-session-acl-check.json`
4656
- `manifests/2026-03-03-p14-sdk-parity-check.json`
57+
- `docs/implementation/gates/phase-14-gate.md`
Lines changed: 6 additions & 0 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,6 @@
1+
[TA-P14-004] firstTwoParticipantsAccepted=true
2+
[TA-P14-004] nonParticipantRejectedRfc7807=true
3+
[TA-P14-004] existingParticipantAcceptedAfterRejection=true
4+
[TA-P14-004] rejectedErrorCode=FORBIDDEN
5+
[TA-P14-004] decision=PASS
6+
[TA-P14-004] output=/Users/xiasenhai/Workspace/OpenClaw/telagent/docs/implementation/phase-14/manifests/2026-03-03-p14-direct-session-acl-check.json
Lines changed: 5 additions & 0 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,5 @@
1+
2026-03-03-p14-direct-session-acl-check.json decision=PASS
2+
2026-03-03-p14-sdk-parity-check.json decision=PASS
3+
2026-03-03-p14-stable-pull-cursor-check.json decision=PASS
4+
2026-03-03-p14-web-ops-removal-check.json decision=PASS
5+
summary total=4 failed=0
Lines changed: 4 additions & 0 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,4 @@
1+
2+
> @telagent/node@0.1.0 build /Users/xiasenhai/Workspace/OpenClaw/telagent/packages/node
3+
> tsc -p tsconfig.json
4+
Lines changed: 109 additions & 0 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,109 @@
1+
2+
> @telagent/node@0.1.0 pretest /Users/xiasenhai/Workspace/OpenClaw/telagent/packages/node
3+
> pnpm build
4+
5+
6+
> @telagent/node@0.1.0 build /Users/xiasenhai/Workspace/OpenClaw/telagent/packages/node
7+
> tsc -p tsconfig.json
8+
9+
10+
> @telagent/node@0.1.0 test /Users/xiasenhai/Workspace/OpenClaw/telagent/packages/node
11+
> node --test dist/*.test.js dist/**/*.test.js
12+
13+
✔ created response returns data envelope and Location header (161.50085ms)
14+
✔ list response returns paginated envelope shape (11.942374ms)
15+
✔ validation errors use RFC7807 shape and problem+json content type (130.679224ms)
16+
✔ node audit snapshot exports de-sensitized envelope and links.self (24.92499ms)
17+
✔ node audit snapshot rejects invalid query with RFC7807 response (5.157949ms)
18+
✔ TA-P12-003 revoked DID event isolates session and rejects message send with RFC7807 (92.823102ms)
19+
✔ TA-P12-004 node metrics exposes federation DLQ replay burn-rate section (3.881643ms)
20+
✔ not found uses RFC7807 shape (2.970381ms)
21+
✔ identities and groups endpoints are accessible with expected status codes (54.472131ms)
22+
✔ messages, attachments and federation endpoints are accessible (133.149516ms)
23+
✔ routes only serve /api/v1/* prefix (210.070355ms)
24+
✔ identity endpoint responds with data envelope (74.657903ms)
25+
✔ mailbox store defaults to sqlite backend (5.248956ms)
26+
✔ mailbox store parses postgres backend config (0.567987ms)
27+
✔ postgres backend requires connection url (0.685423ms)
28+
✔ mailbox backend rejects unsupported value (0.333396ms)
29+
✔ federation protocol defaults to v1 and supports self version (0.970538ms)
30+
✔ federation supported protocols auto-include self version (0.411163ms)
31+
✔ federation replay protection defaults are applied (0.378238ms)
32+
✔ federation replay protection accepts custom values (0.353366ms)
33+
✔ federation replay protection requires positive integer values (0.421965ms)
34+
✔ domain proof config defaults to enforced mode (0.614512ms)
35+
✔ domain proof config accepts report-only mode and custom values (0.380265ms)
36+
✔ domain proof mode rejects unsupported value (0.340855ms)
37+
✔ domain proof numeric settings require positive integers (0.349485ms)
38+
✔ federation pinning defaults to disabled mode (0.380957ms)
39+
✔ federation pinning parses current/next keys and cutover timestamp (0.528972ms)
40+
✔ federation pinning rejects invalid mode (0.324286ms)
41+
✔ federation pinning enabled requires key mappings (0.291012ms)
42+
✔ federation pinning map requires domain=keys format (0.275401ms)
43+
✔ federation SLO automation config defaults are applied (0.305818ms)
44+
✔ federation SLO automation config accepts custom values (0.301441ms)
45+
✔ federation SLO burn-rate thresholds require positive values (0.309591ms)
46+
✔ finalityDepth only materializes finalized blocks (145.062016ms)
47+
✔ reorg rollback replays canonical events and restores deterministic view (19.53323ms)
48+
✔ TA-P4-009 E2E main path: create -> invite -> accept -> group chat (text/image/file) (320.5064ms)
49+
✔ TA-P4-010 E2E offline 24h pull keeps dedupe and per-conversation order (112.368815ms)
50+
✔ TA-P14-003 E2E pull cursor stays stable when cleanup happens between pages (15.934795ms)
51+
✔ TA-P14-004 E2E direct conversation blocks non-participant sender with RFC7807 (36.117665ms)
52+
✔ TA-P4-006 init-upload sanitizes filename and emits attachment objectKey (1.470236ms)
53+
✔ TA-P4-006 complete-upload enforces manifest and checksum integrity (0.753002ms)
54+
✔ TA-P4-006 complete-upload is idempotent and rejects checksum divergence (0.28007ms)
55+
✔ TA-P4-006 expired upload sessions are cleaned and cannot be completed (0.240272ms)
56+
✔ TA-P11-003 accepts valid domain proof challenge and canonical hash (22.877707ms)
57+
✔ TA-P11-003 rejects illegal domain challenge on malformed domain (0.795935ms)
58+
✔ TA-P11-003 rejects when canonical domainProofHash mismatches payload (0.65495ms)
59+
✔ TA-P11-003 rotates challenge nonce near expiry and accepts renewed domain proof (3.71913ms)
60+
✔ TA-P11-003 report-only mode returns warning without blocking create flow (0.460473ms)
61+
✔ TA-P4-007 federation envelopes support idempotent retries (2.087047ms)
62+
✔ TA-P4-007 federation auth token is enforced when configured (0.955306ms)
63+
✔ TA-P4-007 federation rate limit rejects burst traffic (0.322013ms)
64+
✔ TA-P4-008 group-state sync enforces domain consistency (1.326029ms)
65+
✔ TA-P8-002 group-state sync rejects stale stateVersion and records resilience counters (2.786288ms)
66+
✔ TA-P8-002 group-state sync detects split-brain on same stateVersion with different state (0.423622ms)
67+
✔ TA-P9-002 federation accepts compatible protocol versions and tracks usage stats (17.309509ms)
68+
✔ TA-P9-002 federation rejects unsupported protocol versions (0.278664ms)
69+
✔ TA-P11-004 federation pinning enforces sourceKeyId with current/next rotation (0.859859ms)
70+
✔ TA-P11-004 federation pinning report-only mode allows traffic but records warnings (0.447871ms)
71+
✔ TA-P11-005 federation DLQ captures failures and replays in sequence order (0.982506ms)
72+
✔ TA-P4-008 node-info publishes domain and federation security policy (0.205303ms)
73+
✔ TA-P13-005 federation replay applies backoff and opens circuit on repeated failures (0.701694ms)
74+
✔ TA-P13-005 federation replay protection validates backoff range (0.185465ms)
75+
✔ TA-P12-004 federation SLO runOnce auto-replays DLQ and records burn-rate metrics (11.672052ms)
76+
✔ TA-P12-004 federation SLO scheduler periodically replays DLQ (1102.148254ms)
77+
✔ assertSufficient throws INSUFFICIENT_GAS_TOKEN_BALANCE when native balance is not enough (1.802037ms)
78+
✔ TA-P11-006 rotate key keeps old key usable in grace window then expires (2.774869ms)
79+
✔ TA-P11-006 revoke and recover lifecycle is verifiable (0.525125ms)
80+
✔ TA-P11-006 rejects invalid did and malformed key id (0.255674ms)
81+
✔ TA-P12-007 orchestrator supports staged key rotation with rollback recovery (2.332172ms)
82+
✔ TA-P4-002 sequence allocator keeps per-conversation monotonic order (4.266036ms)
83+
✔ TA-P4-003 dedupe keeps idempotent writes for same envelopeId (0.640277ms)
84+
✔ TA-P4-003 duplicate envelopeId with different payload is rejected (0.837883ms)
85+
✔ TA-P14-004 direct conversation rejects non-participant writer after two participants are established (0.932564ms)
86+
✔ TA-P14-004 direct conversation ACL remains effective after repository-backed restart (21.098108ms)
87+
✔ TA-P4-004 cleanupExpired removes expired envelopes and releases dedupe key (0.862138ms)
88+
✔ TA-P14-003 conversation pull cursor stays stable after cleanup between pages (1.588247ms)
89+
✔ TA-P14-003 global pull cursor is keyset token and survives cleanup drift (0.914445ms)
90+
✔ TA-P4-005 provisional envelopes are retracted when group is reorged back (1.026793ms)
91+
✔ TA-P4-005 send is rejected when group chain state is REORGED_BACK (0.659667ms)
92+
✔ TA-P12-002 buildAuditSnapshot exports hashed retraction samples (1.358252ms)
93+
✔ TA-P12-002 buildAuditSnapshot normalizes sample and scan bounds (0.189877ms)
94+
✔ TA-P12-003 revoked DID event isolates related sessions and evicts active sessions (1.600015ms)
95+
✔ TA-P12-003 buildAuditSnapshot includes revocation isolation evidence (0.560175ms)
96+
✔ TA-P6-001 mailbox persists messages and seq after service restart (14.148375ms)
97+
✔ TA-P11-006 message send validates signal/mls key lifecycle status (1.554907ms)
98+
✔ TA-P11-007 revoked DID cannot continue sending new messages (0.423646ms)
99+
✔ TA-P5-002 monitoring snapshot normalizes dynamic route segments and records counters (2.63566ms)
100+
✔ TA-P5-002 monitoring emits warning/critical alerts when thresholds are exceeded (0.493418ms)
101+
✔ TA-P12-004 federation DLQ burn-rate alert is emitted and tracked (1.004406ms)
102+
ℹ tests 89
103+
ℹ suites 0
104+
ℹ pass 89
105+
ℹ fail 0
106+
ℹ cancelled 0
107+
ℹ skipped 0
108+
ℹ todo 0
109+
ℹ duration_ms 2488.709025
Lines changed: 7 additions & 0 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,7 @@
1+
[TA-P14-005] coreMethodParityPass=true
2+
[TA-P14-005] apiPrefixParityPass=true
3+
[TA-P14-005] errorModelParityPass=true
4+
[TA-P14-005] identityEncodingParityPass=true
5+
[TA-P14-005] directAclErrorSemanticsParityPass=true
6+
[TA-P14-005] decision=PASS
7+
[TA-P14-005] output=/Users/xiasenhai/Workspace/OpenClaw/telagent/docs/implementation/phase-14/manifests/2026-03-03-p14-sdk-parity-check.json
Lines changed: 5 additions & 0 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,5 @@
1+
....
2+
----------------------------------------------------------------------
3+
Ran 4 tests in 2.023s
4+
5+
OK
Lines changed: 24 additions & 0 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,24 @@
1+
2+
> @telagent/sdk@0.1.0 pretest /Users/xiasenhai/Workspace/OpenClaw/telagent/packages/sdk
3+
> pnpm build
4+
5+
6+
> @telagent/sdk@0.1.0 build /Users/xiasenhai/Workspace/OpenClaw/telagent/packages/sdk
7+
> tsc -p tsconfig.json
8+
9+
10+
> @telagent/sdk@0.1.0 test /Users/xiasenhai/Workspace/OpenClaw/telagent/packages/sdk
11+
> node --test dist/**/*.test.js
12+
13+
✔ TA-P11-008 SDK quickstart covers create-group and send/pull message flow (44.895268ms)
14+
✔ TA-P11-008 SDK maps RFC7807 errors to TelagentSdkError (9.984976ms)
15+
✔ TA-P14-005 SDK getIdentity encodes DID path segment (3.809805ms)
16+
✔ TA-P14-005 SDK maps direct ACL FORBIDDEN RFC7807 to TelagentSdkError (5.535366ms)
17+
ℹ tests 4
18+
ℹ suites 0
19+
ℹ pass 4
20+
ℹ fail 0
21+
ℹ cancelled 0
22+
ℹ skipped 0
23+
ℹ todo 0
24+
ℹ duration_ms 201.03469

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)