Flutter Android Email Not Publishing

[bbeckley]

If you are looking for help, please confirm the following...

• I confirm I have searched the Docs, Codemagic Sample Projects, and GitHub Discussions.
• I confirm the software versions on my local computer match the ones in CI environment (e.g. Xcode version, Gradle version). See here
• I confirm I am able to do a fresh clone of the repository and build the project on my local computer.

Which mobile framework are you using?

Flutter (Dart)

Steps to reproduce

When my android build is successful there is not email sent, but if the build fails we get an email. For my iOS workflow I get an email sent when successful. My yaml publishing section between both workflows are identical. I don't believe gmail is blocking or sending to spam and I have check and the failure and iOS build email sends correctly.

workflows:
  android-workflow:
    name: Android Workflow
    instance_type: mac_mini_m1
    max_build_duration: 120
    cache:
      cache_paths:
        - $FLUTTER_ROOT/.pub-cache
        - $HOME/.gradle/caches
        - $CM_BUILD_DIR/node_modules
    environment:
      groups:
        - browserstack_credentials
        - build_environment
      android_signing:
        - my_keystore_reference
    scripts:
      - name: Set up local.properties
        script: |
          echo "flutter.sdk=$HOME/programs/flutter" > "$CM_BUILD_DIR/android/local.properties"
      - name: Get Flutter packages
        script: |
          flutter packages pub get
            - name: Flutter analyze
              script: |
                flutter analyze
      - name: Flutter unit tests
        script: |
          flutter test
        ignore_failure: true
      - name: Build AAB with Flutter
        script: |
          BUILD_NUMBER=$(($(google-play get-latest-build-number --package-name "$PACKAGE_NAME" --tracks="$GOOGLE_PLAY_TRACK") + 1))
          echo "My build is $BUILD_ENV_JSON > Build for version > $BUILD_NUMBER"
          flutter build apk --release \
            --build-name=1.0.$BUILD_NUMBER \
            --build-number=$BUILD_NUMBER \
            --dart-define-from-file=.env/$BUILD_ENV_JSON
      - name: BrowserStack upload
        script: |
          curl -u "$BROWSERSTACK_USERNAME:$BROWSERSTACK_ACCESS_TOKEN" \
            -X POST "https://api-cloud.browserstack.com/app-live/upload" \
            -F "file=@build/app/outputs/flutter-apk/app-release.apk"
    artifacts:
      - build/**/outputs/**/*.aab
      - build/**/outputs/**/*.apk
      - build/**/outputs/**/mapping.txt
      - flutter_drive.log
    publishing:
      email:
        recipients:
          - [email protected]

iOS yaml that is working

 ios-workflow:
    name: iOS Workflow
    instance_type: mac_mini_m1
    max_build_duration: 120
    cache:
      cache_paths:
        - $FLUTTER_ROOT/.pub-cache
        - $HOME/Library/Caches/CocoaPods
        - $CM_BUILD_DIR/node_modules
    environment:
      ios_signing:
        distribution_type: ad_hoc
        bundle_identifier: com.my.org
      groups:
        - browserstack_credentials
        - build_environment
      vars:
        XCODE_WORKSPACE: "Runner.xcworkspace"
        XCODE_SCHEME: "Runner"
        APP_STORE_ID: 1234
      flutter: stable
      xcode: 15.3
      cocoapods: 1.15.2
    scripts:
      - name: Set up code signing settings on Xcode project
        script: |
          xcode-project use-profiles
      - name: Get Flutter packages
        script: |
          flutter packages pub get
        ignore_failure: true
      - name: Install pods
        script: |
          find . -name "Podfile" -execdir pod install \;
      - name: Flutter analyze
        script: |
          flutter analyze
      - name: Flutter unit tests
        script: |
          flutter test
        ignore_failure: true
      - name: Flutter build ipa and automatic versioning
        script: |
          flutter build ipa --release \
          --build-name=1.0.0 \
          --build-number=$(($(app-store-connect get-latest-testflight-build-number "$APP_STORE_ID") + 1)) \
          --dart-define-from-file=.env/$BUILD_ENV_JSON \
          --export-options-plist=/Users/builder/export_options.plist
      - name: Uploading to BrowserStack App Live environment
        script: |
          curl -u "$BROWSERSTACK_USERNAME:$BROWSERSTACK_ACCESS_TOKEN" \
            -X POST "https://api-cloud.browserstack.com/app-live/upload" \
            -F "file=@build/ios/ipa/myapp_v2.ipa"
    artifacts:
      - build/ios/ipa/*.ipa
      - /tmp/xcodebuild_logs/*.log
      - flutter_drive.log
      - $HOME/Library/Developer/Xcode/DerivedData/**/Build/**/*.app
    publishing:
      email:
        recipients:
          - [email protected]

Expected results

Email for Android build sent when successful or failure

Actual results

No email sent on successful Android build

Build id (optional)

665f0fe240e0c287c9b2f596

[himesh-cm]

Hey @bbeckley
Please modify the script as below

publishing:
  email:
    recipients:
      - [email protected]
    notify:
      success: false # To not receive a notification when a build succeeds
      failure: false # To not receive a notification when a build fails

[bbeckley]

I will give that a try, but I believe I did try that once before. But for iOS the emails are sending without any notify config. But since I want the emails to send all the time with a success or failure I'd want the values to be true, correct ?

publishing:
  email:
    recipients:
      - [email protected]
    notify:
      success: true # notification when a build succeeds
      failure: true #  notification when a build fails

[bbeckley]

That worked. Sorry I was pretty sure I had tried that and I think iOS is working without that notify attribute set. But all good now, I'll add it to iOS as well to be consistent. Thanks

[himesh-cm]

While I’m closing our discussion for now, if you have any other questions or suggestions, feel free to reply back or start a new discussion anytime. Have a nice day!