Skip to content

Commit 11332fb

Browse files
committed
Expand protocol comparison report with Phase 2 summary and TOC
Major enhancements to ProtocolAttributes-Spec-vs-AutobahnPython.md: 1. Added comprehensive Table of Contents: - Summary sections with links - Phase 1 (Pub/Sub) message links - Phase 2 (RPC) message links with TODO markers - Appendix links 2. Enhanced Summary Matrix: - Split into Phase 1 (Complete) and Phase 2 (In Progress) - Added CALL.Options and RESULT.Details rows - Added placeholders for remaining RPC messages - Added Phase 1+2 Summary with compliance/extension analysis 3. Expanded Version Information: - Analysis Status: Visual progress tracking with checkmarks/emojis - Test Coverage: Detailed test count breakdown - Source Information: Complete file paths - Related Issues: Links to wamp-proto#556 and autobahn-python#1764 Current status: - Phase 1 (Pub/Sub): 7 message types ✅ COMPLETE - Phase 2 (RPC): 2/8 message types complete (CALL, RESULT) - Total tests: 254 passed, 35 skipped Related to autobahn-python issue #1764.
1 parent e2a7494 commit 11332fb

File tree

1 file changed

+107
-1
lines changed

1 file changed

+107
-1
lines changed

examples/serdes/ProtocolAttributes-Spec-vs-AutobahnPython.md

Lines changed: 107 additions & 1 deletion
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -3,8 +3,44 @@
33
This document compares WAMP protocol message attributes as defined in the WAMP specification
44
against their implementation in Autobahn-Python.
55

6+
## Table of Contents
7+
8+
### Summary
9+
- [Summary Matrix](#summary-matrix)
10+
- [Phase 1: Pub/Sub Messages (Complete)](#phase-1-pubsub-messages-complete)
11+
- [Phase 2: RPC Messages (In Progress)](#phase-2-rpc-messages-in-progress)
12+
- [Phase 1+2 Summary](#phase-12-summary)
13+
14+
### Phase 1: Pub/Sub Messages
15+
- [PUBLISH.Options](#publishoptions)
16+
- [EVENT.Details](#eventdetails)
17+
- [SUBSCRIBE.Options](#subscribeoptions)
18+
- [SUBSCRIBED](#subscribed)
19+
- [PUBLISHED](#published)
20+
- [UNSUBSCRIBE.Options](#unsubscribeoptions)
21+
- [UNSUBSCRIBED](#unsubscribed)
22+
23+
### Phase 2: RPC Messages
24+
- [CALL.Options](#calloptions)
25+
- [RESULT.Details](#resultdetails)
26+
- [REGISTER.Options](#registeroptions) (TODO)
27+
- [REGISTERED](#registered) (TODO)
28+
- [UNREGISTER.Options](#unregisteroptions) (TODO)
29+
- [UNREGISTERED](#unregistered) (TODO)
30+
- [INVOCATION.Details](#invocationdetails) (TODO)
31+
- [YIELD.Options](#yieldoptions) (TODO)
32+
- [ERROR.Details](#errordetails) (TODO)
33+
34+
### Appendix
35+
- [Recommendations](#recommendations)
36+
- [Version Information](#version-information)
37+
38+
---
39+
640
## Summary Matrix
741

42+
### Phase 1: Pub/Sub Messages (Complete)
43+
844
| Message Type | Matched | Spec-Only | Implementation-Only | Naming Differences |
945
|--------------|---------|-----------|---------------------|-------------------|
1046
| PUBLISH.Options | 9 | 1 (+4 ppt_*) | 2 (+3 enc_*) | E2EE: ppt_* vs enc_* |
@@ -15,6 +51,35 @@ against their implementation in Autobahn-Python.
1551
| UNSUBSCRIBE.Options | 0 | 0 | 1 | None |
1652
| UNSUBSCRIBED | N/A | N/A | N/A | No Details (basic) |
1753

54+
### Phase 2: RPC Messages (In Progress)
55+
56+
| Message Type | Matched | Spec-Only | Implementation-Only | Naming Differences |
57+
|--------------|---------|-----------|---------------------|-------------------|
58+
| CALL.Options | 2 | 1 (+4 ppt_*) | 5 (+3 enc_*) | E2EE: ppt_* vs enc_* |
59+
| RESULT.Details | 1 | 0 (+4 ppt_*) | 4 (+3 enc_*) | E2EE: ppt_* vs enc_* |
60+
| REGISTER.Options | - | - | - | TODO |
61+
| REGISTERED | - | - | - | TODO |
62+
| UNREGISTER.Options | - | - | - | TODO |
63+
| UNREGISTERED | - | - | - | TODO |
64+
| INVOCATION.Details | - | - | - | TODO |
65+
| YIELD.Options | - | - | - | TODO |
66+
| ERROR.Details | - | - | - | TODO (shared PubSub+RPC) |
67+
68+
### Phase 1+2 Summary
69+
70+
**Spec Compliance:**
71+
- ✅ Core functionality: All basic profile features implemented
72+
- ⚠️ Missing disclosure initiation: `disclose_me` not implemented (PUBLISH, CALL)
73+
- ⚠️ E2EE naming: Uses `enc_*` prefix instead of spec's `ppt_*` prefix
74+
- ⚠️ Missing E2EE: `ppt_scheme` not implemented (required in spec)
75+
- ⚠️ Missing trustlevel: `EVENT.Details.trustlevel` not implemented
76+
77+
**Implementation Extensions:**
78+
- ✅ Router-to-router forwarding: `forward_for` (all messages with Options/Details)
79+
- ✅ Transaction deduplication: `transaction_hash` (PUBLISH, CALL)
80+
- ✅ Disclosure metadata: Router-added `publisher*`, `caller*`, `callee*` attributes
81+
- ✅ Event acknowledgement: `x_acknowledged_delivery` (EVENT - needs naming review)
82+
1883
## PUBLISH.Options
1984

2085
### Matched Attributes (9)
@@ -507,6 +572,47 @@ RESULT.Details has similar patterns as CALL.Options:
507572

508573
## Version Information
509574

575+
### Analysis Status
576+
577+
**Phase 1: Pub/Sub Messages****COMPLETE**
578+
- PUBLISH.Options ✅
579+
- EVENT.Details ✅
580+
- SUBSCRIBE.Options ✅
581+
- SUBSCRIBED ✅
582+
- PUBLISHED ✅
583+
- UNSUBSCRIBE.Options ✅
584+
- UNSUBSCRIBED ✅
585+
586+
**Phase 2: RPC Messages** 🚧 **IN PROGRESS**
587+
- CALL.Options ✅
588+
- RESULT.Details ✅
589+
- REGISTER.Options ⏳ TODO
590+
- REGISTERED ⏳ TODO
591+
- UNREGISTER.Options ⏳ TODO
592+
- UNREGISTERED ⏳ TODO
593+
- INVOCATION.Details ⏳ TODO
594+
- YIELD.Options ⏳ TODO
595+
596+
**Phase 3: Shared Messages****TODO**
597+
- ERROR.Details (used in both Pub/Sub and RPC)
598+
599+
### Test Coverage
600+
601+
**SerDes Conformance Tests:**
602+
- Total: 254 passed, 35 skipped
603+
- Phase 1 (Pub/Sub): 218 tests (8 message types × ~27 tests/type avg)
604+
- Phase 2 (RPC so far): 24 tests (2 message types × 12 tests/type)
605+
- Serializers tested: JSON, MsgPack, CBOR, UBJSON (FlatBuffers skipped)
606+
607+
### Source Information
608+
510609
- **WAMP Spec**: /home/oberstet/work/wamp/wamp-proto/rfc/text/
511610
- **Autobahn-Python**: /home/oberstet/work/wamp/autobahn-python/autobahn/wamp/message.py
512-
- **Analysis Date**: 2025-11-17 (Phase 1 complete: all Pub/Sub messages analyzed; Phase 2 in progress: RPC messages)
611+
- **Test Vectors**: /home/oberstet/work/wamp/wamp-proto/testsuite/singlemessage/basic/
612+
- **Analysis Date**: 2025-11-17
613+
- **Last Updated**: Phase 2 - CALL/RESULT complete
614+
615+
### Related Issues
616+
617+
- **wamp-proto#556**: Add comprehensive test vectors for all WAMP message types
618+
- **autobahn-python#1764**: Add SerDes conformance tests using wamp-proto test vectors

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)