App Commands - Modifying allowed channels makes all commands public

[Galarzaa90]

When you go into Server Settings > Integrations > Bot, and you modify the channels section:

This will make all slash commands available for all users, regardless of their synced permissions. Forcing users to have to go command by command to restrict them to certain roles, instead of being able to still use "default member permissions".

This is very inuntiuitive, as users would not expect their management commands to become public just because they limited the channels, and there is no warning in ths dialog about this side effect. Not to mention that if the users are still not familiar with the bot, they will have no idea which commands should have special restrictions (there is no indicator on the list of this either, only going command by command)

There is a "warning" when you check the settings of a specific command:

In any case, my opinion is that modifying channel settings should not alter permissions.

[ErwanGit]

I agree with this discussion.

The current operation of Slash commands permissions is very dangerous for server administrators and moderators. Changing the default allowed/forbidden channels of all commands can make a server very vulnerable to malicious actions.

In my opinion, I see two solutions to this problem:

• Add a warning message, like when changing a single command by stating that the default permissions will be ignored when changing the default permissions for all commands

- Or that the default permissions are always taken into account when only the channels permissions are modified as proposed above.