Skip to content

Commit b7d6e5e

Browse files
saguiitaysaguiitay
committed
Added doc
1 parent dfcf1fd commit b7d6e5e

File tree

1 file changed

+280
-0
lines changed

1 file changed

+280
-0
lines changed

‎ROADMAP.md‎

Lines changed: 280 additions & 0 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,280 @@
1+
# CardinalityEstimation Library - Roadmap for Improvements
2+
3+
## Executive Summary
4+
The CardinalityEstimation library implements a sophisticated cardinality estimator using HyperLogLog with optimizations for small cardinalities (direct counting) and medium cardinalities (linear counting). While the core implementation is solid, there are several opportunities for improvement in terms of performance, usability, extensibility, and modern .NET capabilities.
5+
6+
## Current Strengths
7+
- ? Solid HyperLogLog implementation with bias correction
8+
- ? Efficient sparse/dense representation switching
9+
- ? Direct counting for exact results on small sets (?100 elements)
10+
- ? Binary serialization support
11+
- ? Multi-target framework support (.NET 8, .NET 9)
12+
- ? Comprehensive test coverage
13+
- ? Multiple hash function support (Murmur3, FNV-1a, XxHash128)
14+
15+
## High Priority Improvements
16+
17+
### 1. Thread Safety & Concurrency
18+
**Priority:** HIGH
19+
**Impact:** HIGH
20+
**Effort:** MEDIUM
21+
22+
**Issues:**
23+
- Current implementation is explicitly not thread-safe
24+
- No support for concurrent updates from multiple threads
25+
- Missing parallel merge operations
26+
27+
**Improvements:**
28+
- [ ] Add `ConcurrentCardinalityEstimator` class with thread-safe operations
29+
- [ ] Implement lock-free updates where possible using `Interlocked` operations
30+
- [ ] Add `ParallelMerge` method for merging multiple estimators in parallel
31+
- [ ] Consider using `ReaderWriterLockSlim` for read-heavy scenarios
32+
33+
### 2. Generic Type Support & Performance
34+
**Priority:** HIGH
35+
**Impact:** HIGH
36+
**Effort:** MEDIUM
37+
38+
**Issues:**
39+
- Repetitive Add methods for each primitive type
40+
- Boxing for value types in some scenarios
41+
- No support for custom types with IEquatable<T>
42+
43+
**Improvements:**
44+
- [ ] Add generic `Add<T>()` method with appropriate constraints
45+
- [ ] Implement `ICardinalityEstimator<T>` for any `T` where reasonable
46+
- [ ] Optimize byte conversion to avoid allocations
47+
- [ ] Add `Span<byte>` and `ReadOnlySpan<byte>` support for zero-allocation scenarios
48+
49+
### 3. Modern .NET Features Integration
50+
**Priority:** HIGH
51+
**Impact:** MEDIUM
52+
**Effort:** MEDIUM
53+
54+
**Issues:**
55+
- Missing async support for I/O operations
56+
- No support for `System.Text.Json` serialization
57+
- Not utilizing newer .NET performance features
58+
59+
**Improvements:**
60+
- [ ] Add `System.Text.Json` serialization support with custom converters
61+
- [ ] Implement `IAsyncEnumerable<T>` support for streaming additions
62+
- [ ] Add async serialization methods (`SerializeAsync`, `DeserializeAsync`)
63+
- [ ] Utilize `ArrayPool<T>` for temporary byte array allocations
64+
- [ ] Add `Memory<T>` and `ReadOnlyMemory<T>` support
65+
66+
## Medium Priority Improvements
67+
68+
### 4. Enhanced Error Handling & Validation
69+
**Priority:** MEDIUM
70+
**Impact:** MEDIUM
71+
**Effort:** LOW
72+
73+
**Issues:**
74+
- Limited input validation
75+
- Generic exceptions without context
76+
- Missing guard clauses
77+
78+
**Improvements:**
79+
- [ ] Add comprehensive input validation with descriptive error messages
80+
- [ ] Create custom exception types (`CardinalityEstimationException`)
81+
- [ ] Add parameter validation attributes
82+
- [ ] Implement proper null checks with meaningful messages
83+
84+
### 5. Extended Hash Function Support
85+
**Priority:** MEDIUM
86+
**Impact:** MEDIUM
87+
**Effort:** MEDIUM
88+
89+
**Issues:**
90+
- Limited hash function choices
91+
- Hash function selection is constructor-time only
92+
- No pluggable hash function interface
93+
94+
**Improvements:**
95+
- [ ] Create `IHashFunction` interface for pluggable hash functions
96+
- [ ] Add more hash functions (CityHash, SpookyHash, etc.)
97+
- [ ] Support for cryptographic hash functions when needed
98+
- [ ] Allow hash function switching for existing estimators (with warnings)
99+
- [ ] Add hash function benchmarking utilities
100+
101+
### 6. Advanced Estimation Algorithms
102+
**Priority:** MEDIUM
103+
**Impact:** HIGH
104+
**Effort:** HIGH
105+
106+
**Issues:**
107+
- Only supports HyperLogLog algorithm
108+
- No support for other cardinality estimation methods
109+
- Limited to single algorithm approach
110+
111+
**Improvements:**
112+
- [ ] Implement HyperLogLog++ algorithm for improved accuracy
113+
- [ ] Add LogLog and SuperLogLog implementations
114+
- [ ] Implement MinHash for Jaccard similarity estimation
115+
- [ ] Add HeavyHitters/Count-Min Sketch integration
116+
- [ ] Create algorithm selection based on use case
117+
118+
### 7. Enhanced Serialization Options
119+
**Priority:** MEDIUM
120+
**Impact:** MEDIUM
121+
**Effort:** MEDIUM
122+
123+
**Issues:**
124+
- Only binary serialization supported
125+
- No compression options
126+
- No format versioning strategy
127+
128+
**Improvements:**
129+
- [ ] Add JSON serialization with schema versioning
130+
- [ ] Implement compression support (gzip, brotli)
131+
- [ ] Add Protocol Buffers serialization
132+
- [ ] Create migration utilities for format upgrades
133+
- [ ] Support streaming serialization for large datasets
134+
135+
## Low Priority Improvements
136+
137+
### 8. Observability & Diagnostics
138+
**Priority:** LOW
139+
**Impact:** MEDIUM
140+
**Effort:** LOW
141+
142+
**Issues:**
143+
- Limited observability into estimator performance
144+
- No built-in metrics or monitoring
145+
- Difficult to debug accuracy issues
146+
147+
**Improvements:**
148+
- [ ] Add performance counters and metrics
149+
- [ ] Implement detailed logging with different levels
150+
- [ ] Create diagnostic methods for accuracy analysis
151+
- [ ] Add health check capabilities
152+
- [ ] Implement custom `EventSource` for ETW logging
153+
154+
### 9. Memory Optimization
155+
**Priority:** LOW
156+
**Impact:** MEDIUM
157+
**Effort:** MEDIUM
158+
159+
**Issues:**
160+
- Memory usage could be optimized further
161+
- No memory pressure handling
162+
- Large object heap usage for big estimators
163+
164+
**Improvements:**
165+
- [ ] Implement memory-mapped file support for very large estimators
166+
- [ ] Add memory pressure response mechanisms
167+
- [ ] Optimize sparse representation memory layout
168+
- [ ] Implement lazy loading for serialized estimators
169+
- [ ] Add memory usage reporting methods
170+
171+
### 10. Developer Experience
172+
**Priority:** LOW
173+
**Impact:** LOW
174+
**Effort:** LOW
175+
176+
**Issues:**
177+
- Limited documentation and examples
178+
- No fluent API support
179+
- Missing extension methods
180+
181+
**Improvements:**
182+
- [ ] Create fluent API builder pattern
183+
- [ ] Add extension methods for common scenarios
184+
- [ ] Implement better ToString() representations
185+
- [ ] Add debugging visualizers
186+
- [ ] Create comprehensive documentation with examples
187+
188+
## Breaking Changes (Major Version)
189+
190+
### 11. API Modernization
191+
**Priority:** FUTURE
192+
**Impact:** HIGH
193+
**Effort:** HIGH
194+
195+
**Potential Breaking Changes:**
196+
- [ ] Make interfaces more generic and flexible
197+
- [ ] Rename methods to follow modern .NET conventions
198+
- [ ] Separate concerns (estimation vs. serialization)
199+
- [ ] Implement proper disposal pattern for resources
200+
- [ ] Add configuration options pattern
201+
202+
### 12. Architecture Refactoring
203+
**Priority:** FUTURE
204+
**Impact:** HIGH
205+
**Effort:** HIGH
206+
207+
**Potential Changes:**
208+
- [ ] Extract algorithms into separate strategy classes
209+
- [ ] Create plugin architecture for extensibility
210+
- [ ] Separate core logic from platform-specific implementations
211+
- [ ] Implement proper dependency injection support
212+
- [ ] Add factory pattern for estimator creation
213+
214+
## New Features
215+
216+
### 13. Distributed Estimation Support
217+
**Priority:** FUTURE
218+
**Impact:** HIGH
219+
**Effort:** HIGH
220+
221+
**New Capabilities:**
222+
- [ ] Network-based merging capabilities
223+
- [ ] Distributed cardinality estimation across services
224+
- [ ] Real-time streaming support with Apache Kafka integration
225+
- [ ] Cloud storage backend support (Azure Blob, AWS S3)
226+
227+
### 14. Machine Learning Integration
228+
**Priority:** FUTURE
229+
**Impact:** MEDIUM
230+
**Effort:** HIGH
231+
232+
**New Capabilities:**
233+
- [ ] Adaptive algorithm selection based on data patterns
234+
- [ ] ML-based accuracy prediction
235+
- [ ] Anomaly detection in cardinality patterns
236+
- [ ] Integration with ML.NET for predictive analytics
237+
238+
## Implementation Phases
239+
240+
### Phase 1: Foundation (3-6 months)
241+
- Thread safety improvements
242+
- Generic type support
243+
- Modern .NET features integration
244+
- Enhanced error handling
245+
246+
### Phase 2: Core Enhancements (6-9 months)
247+
- Extended hash function support
248+
- Advanced estimation algorithms
249+
- Enhanced serialization options
250+
- Memory optimization
251+
252+
### Phase 3: Advanced Features (9-12 months)
253+
- Observability & diagnostics
254+
- Developer experience improvements
255+
- Distributed estimation support
256+
257+
### Phase 4: Next Generation (12+ months)
258+
- API modernization (breaking changes)
259+
- Architecture refactoring
260+
- Machine learning integration
261+
262+
## Success Metrics
263+
264+
- **Performance:** 20% improvement in throughput for common operations
265+
- **Memory:** 15% reduction in memory usage for typical scenarios
266+
- **Accuracy:** Support for algorithms with 10% better accuracy than current HLL
267+
- **Usability:** Reduce lines of code needed for common scenarios by 50%
268+
- **Reliability:** Achieve 99.9% uptime in concurrent scenarios
269+
- **Compatibility:** Support for all LTS .NET versions with no breaking changes
270+
271+
## Recommendations
272+
273+
1. **Start with Phase 1** focusing on thread safety and generic support
274+
2. **Prioritize** modern .NET features to improve developer adoption
275+
3. **Maintain backward compatibility** through the entire roadmap (until major version)
276+
4. **Create comprehensive benchmarks** before and after each improvement
277+
5. **Engage with the community** for feedback on priorities and use cases
278+
6. **Document migration paths** for any future breaking changes
279+
280+
This roadmap provides a structured approach to evolving the CardinalityEstimation library while maintaining its core strengths and addressing current limitations.

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)