Skip to content

Commit b233482

Browse files
committed
docs(zerobucket): add refactor notes and test summary
1 parent 847663e commit b233482

File tree

1 file changed

+54
-0
lines changed

1 file changed

+54
-0
lines changed

docs/refactor-zero-bucket-notes.md

Lines changed: 54 additions & 0 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,54 @@
1+
# Refactor Notes: ZeroBucket (Task 1)
2+
3+
## Summary
4+
5+
Converted implicit lazy loading (sentinel values Long.MAX_VALUE / Double.NaN) into explicit state flags (indexComputed, thresholdComputed). Added static factories (fromThreshold, fromIndexAndScale) while retaining the original public constructor (deprecated) and the original APIs (minimalEmpty, minimalWithCount, merge, collapseOverlappingBuckets\*, compareZeroThreshold). Added equals/hashCode/toString for value semantics and stronger testability.
6+
7+
## Key Changes
8+
9+
| Aspect | Before | After |
10+
| ----------------- | --------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
11+
| Lazy tracking | Sentinels (Long.MAX_VALUE / Double.NaN) | Booleans (indexComputed / thresholdComputed) |
12+
| Constructors | Public constructor only | + fromThreshold / fromIndexAndScale (constructor kept, deprecated) |
13+
| API compatibility | merge, collapse\*, minimalWithCount | Preserved (restored where removed) |
14+
| Value semantics | None | equals, hashCode, toString |
15+
| Tests | None for ZeroBucket | Added ZeroBucketTests (lazy, merge, minimal, invalid input, collapse, equality) |
16+
17+
## Rationale
18+
19+
Explicit flags improve readability and reduce mental overhead. Factories clarify intent (threshold-driven vs index-driven). Value semantics simplify reasoning in future merging logic and aid debugging (toString includes internal state).
20+
21+
## Risks & Mitigation
22+
23+
| Risk | Mitigation |
24+
| ---------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
25+
| Off-by-one index computation regression | Preserved original +1 logic in index() lazy path |
26+
| Breaking callers using removed methods | Restored original methods (merge, minimalWithCount, collapseOverlappingBuckets\*, compareZeroThreshold) |
27+
| Hidden performance cost from forcing both computations in equals | Acceptable; equality rarely on hot path; keeps simplicity |
28+
29+
## Tests Added
30+
31+
- testFromThresholdLazyIndex
32+
- testFromIndexLazyThreshold
33+
- testMinimalEmptySingleton
34+
- testMinimalWithCount
35+
- testMergeKeepsLargerThreshold
36+
- testInvalidNegativeThreshold
37+
- testEqualityAndHashStable
38+
- testCollapseNoOverlapReturnsSame
39+
- testToStringContainsKeyFields
40+
41+
All passed with:
42+
`./gradlew :libs:exponential-histogram:test --tests "*ZeroBucketTests"`
43+
44+
## Evidence Pointers
45+
46+
- Commit(s): refactor(zerobucket)... (and fix if needed)
47+
- PR: refactor: ZeroBucket explicit lazy state & value semantics (Task 1)
48+
- Build screenshot: ZeroBucketTests BUILD SUCCESSFUL
49+
- Diff: removal of sentinel logic / introduction of flags & factories
50+
51+
## Future Follow-up (Not in Task 1)
52+
53+
- Remove deprecated constructor after downstream code migrates to factories.
54+
- Consider benchmarking overhead of toString in large diagnostics.

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)