Updating approach bob

Author: jagdish-15

exercises/practice/bob/.approaches/config.json

@@ -4,27 +4,29 @@
       "bobahop"
     ],
     "contributors": [
-      "jagdish-15"
+      "jagdish-15",
+      "kahgoh"
     ]
   },
   "approaches": [
     {
       "uuid": "6ca5c7c0-f8f1-49b2-b137-951fa39f89eb",
-      "slug": "method-based",
-      "title": "Method based",
-      "blurb": "Uses boolean functions to check conditions",
+      "slug": "if-statements",
+      "title": "if statements",
+      "blurb": "Use if statements to return the answer.",
       "authors": [
         "jagdish-15"
       ],
       "contributors": [
-        "BenjaminGale"
+        "BenjaminGale",
+        "kahgoh"
       ]
     },
     {
       "uuid": "323eb230-7f27-4301-88ea-19c39d3eb5b6",
-      "slug": "if-statements",
-      "title": "if statements",
-      "blurb": "Use if statements to return the answer.",
+      "slug": "nested-if-statements",
+      "title": "nested if statements",
+      "blurb": "Use nested if statements to return the answer.",
       "authors": [
         "bobahop"
       ]

exercises/practice/bob/.approaches/if-statements/content.md

@@ -1,88 +1,86 @@
 # `if` statements
 
 ```java
-import java.util.function.Predicate;
-import java.util.regex.Pattern;
-
 class Bob {
-
-    final private static Pattern isAlpha = Pattern.compile("[a-zA-Z]");
-    final private static Predicate < String > isShout = msg -> isAlpha.matcher(msg).find() && msg == msg.toUpperCase();
-
-    public String hey(String message) {
-        var speech = message.trim();
-        if (speech.isEmpty()) {
-            return "Fine. Be that way!";
-        }
-        var questioning = speech.endsWith("?");
-        var shouting = isShout.test(speech);
-        if (questioning) {
-            if (shouting) {
-                return "Calm down, I know what I'm doing!";
-            }
-            return "Sure.";
-        }
-        if (shouting) {
+    String hey(String input) {
+        var inputTrimmed = input.trim();
+        
+        if (isSilent(inputTrimmed))
+           return "Fine. Be that way!";
+        if (isShouting(inputTrimmed) && isQuestioning(inputTrimmed))
+            return "Calm down, I know what I'm doing!";
+        if (isShouting(inputTrimmed))
             return "Whoa, chill out!";
-        }
+        if (isQuestioning(inputTrimmed))
+            return "Sure.";
+            
         return "Whatever.";
     }
+
+    private boolean isShouting(String input) {
+        return input.chars()
+                    .anyMatch(Character::isLetter) &&
+                input.chars()
+                    .filter(Character::isLetter)
+                    .allMatch(Character::isUpperCase);
+    }
+
+    private boolean isQuestioning(String input) {
+        return input.endsWith("?");
+    }
+
+    private boolean isSilent(String input) {
+        return input.length() == 0;
+    }
 }
 ```
 
-In this approach you have a series of `if` statements using the private methods to evaluate the conditions.
-As soon as the right condition is found, the correct response is returned.
+In this approach, the different conditions for Bob’s responses are separated into dedicated private methods within the `Bob` class. This method-based approach improves readability and modularity by organizing each condition check into its own method, making the main response method easier to understand and maintain.
 
-Note that there are no `else if` or `else` statements.
-If an `if` statement can return, then an `else if` or `else` is not needed.
-Execution will either return or will continue to the next statement anyway.
+## Explanation
 
-The `String` [`trim()`][trim] method is applied to the input to eliminate any whitespace at either end of the input.
-If the string has no characters left, it returns the response for saying nothing.
+This approach simplifies the main method `hey` by breaking down each response condition into helper methods:
 
-~~~~exercism/caution
-Note that a `null` `string` would be different from a `String` of all whitespace.
-A `null` `String` would throw a `NullPointerException` if `trim()` were applied to it.
-~~~~
+### Trimming the Input
 
-A [Pattern][pattern] is defined to look for at least one English alphabetic character.
+   The `input` is trimmed using the `String` [`trim()`][trim] method to remove any leading or trailing whitespace. This helps to accurately detect if the input is empty and should prompt a `"Fine. Be that way!"` response.
 
-The first half of the `isShout` [Predicate][predicate]
+### **Delegating to Helper Methods**:
+   
+   Each condition is evaluated using the following helper methods:
 
-```java
-isAlpha.matcher(msg).find() && msg == msg.toUpperCase();
-```
+   - **`isSilent`**: Checks if the trimmed input has no characters.
+   - **`isShouting`**: Checks if the input is all uppercase and contains at least one alphabetic character, indicating shouting.
+   - **`isQuestioning`**: Verifies if the trimmed input ends with a question mark.
+
+   This modular approach keeps each condition encapsulated, enhancing code clarity.
 
-is constructed from the `Pattern` [`matcher()`][matcher-method] method and the [`Matcher`][matcher]  [`find()`][find] method
-to ensure there is at least one letter character in the `String`.
-This is because the second half of the condition tests that the uppercased input is the same as the input.
-If the input were only `"123"` it would equal itself uppercased, but without letters it would not be a shout.
+### **Order of Checks**:
+   
+   The order of checks within `hey` is important:
+   - Silence is evaluated first, as it requires an immediate response.
+   - Shouted questions take precedence over individual checks for yelling and asking.
+   - Yelling comes next, requiring its response if not combined with a question.
+   - Asking (a non-shouted question) is checked afterward.
 
-A question is determined by use of the [`endsWith()`][endswith] method to see if the input ends with a question mark.
+   This ordering ensures that Bob’s response matches the expected behavior without redundancy.
 
 ## Shortening
 
-When the body of an `if` statement is a single line, both the test expression and the body _could_ be put on the same line, like so
+When the body of an `if` statement is a single line, both the test expression and the body _could_ be put on the same line, like so:
 
 ```java
-if (speech.isEmpty()) return "Fine. Be that way!";
+if (isSilent(inputTrimmed)) return "Fine. Be that way!";
 ```
 
-or the body _could_ be put on a separate line without curly braces
+or the body _could_ be put on a separate line without curly braces:
 
 ```java
-if (speech.isEmpty())
+if (isSilent(inputTrimmed))
     return "Fine. Be that way!";
 ```
 
-However, the [Java Coding Conventions][coding-conventions] advise to always use curly braces for `if` statements, which helps to avoid errors.
-Your team may choose to overrule them at its own risk.
+However, the [Java Coding Conventions][coding-conventions] advise always using curly braces for `if` statements, which helps to avoid errors. Your team may choose to overrule them at its own risk.
 
-[trim]: https://docs.oracle.com/javase/7/docs/api/java/lang/String.html#trim()
-[pattern]: https://docs.oracle.com/javase/8/docs/api/java/util/regex/Pattern.html
-[predicate]: https://docs.oracle.com/javase/8/docs/api/java/util/function/Predicate.html
-[matcher]: https://docs.oracle.com/javase/8/docs/api/java/util/regex/Matcher.html
-[matcher-method]: https://docs.oracle.com/javase/8/docs/api/java/util/regex/Pattern.html#matcher-java.lang.CharSequence-
-[find]: https://docs.oracle.com/javase/8/docs/api/java/util/regex/Matcher.html#find--
-[endswith]: https://docs.oracle.com/javase/7/docs/api/java/lang/String.html#endsWith(java.lang.String)
+[trim]: https://docs.oracle.com/javase/7/docs/api/java/lang/String.html#trim()  
 [coding-conventions]: https://www.oracle.com/java/technologies/javase/codeconventions-statements.html#449

exercises/practice/bob/.approaches/if-statements/snippet.txt

@@ -1,8 +1,8 @@
-if (questioning) {
-    if (shouting)
-        return "Calm down, I know what I'm doing!";
-    return "Sure.";
-}
-if (shouting)
+if (isSilent(inputTrimmed))
+    return "Fine. Be that way!";
+if (isShouting(inputTrimmed) && isQuestioning(inputTrimmed))
+    return "Calm down, I know what I'm doing!";
+if (isShouting(inputTrimmed))
     return "Whoa, chill out!";
-return "Whatever.";
+if (isQuestioning(inputTrimmed))
+    return "Sure.";

exercises/practice/bob/.approaches/introduction.md

@@ -2,7 +2,7 @@
 
 In this exercise, we’re working on a program to determine Bob’s responses based on the tone and style of given messages. Bob responds differently depending on whether a message is a question, a shout, both, or silence. Various approaches can be used to implement this logic efficiently and cleanly, ensuring the code remains readable and easy to maintain.
 
-## General Guidance
+## General guidance
 
 When implementing your solution, consider the following tips to keep your code optimized and idiomatic:
 
@@ -13,7 +13,7 @@ When implementing your solution, consider the following tips to keep your code o
 - **Return Statements**: An early return in an `if` statement eliminates the need for additional `else` blocks, making the code more readable.
 - **Curly Braces**: While optional for single-line statements, some teams may require them for readability and consistency.
 
-## Approach: Method-Based
+## Approach: `if` statements
 
 ```java
 class Bob {
@@ -22,25 +22,25 @@ class Bob {
 
         if (isSilent(inputTrimmed))
            return "Fine. Be that way!";
-        if (isYelling(inputTrimmed) && isAsking(inputTrimmed))
+        if (isShouting(inputTrimmed) && isQuestioning(inputTrimmed))
             return "Calm down, I know what I'm doing!";
-        if (isYelling(inputTrimmed))
+        if (isShouting(inputTrimmed))
             return "Whoa, chill out!";
-        if (isAsking(inputTrimmed))
+        if (isQuestioning(inputTrimmed))
             return "Sure.";
 
         return "Whatever.";
     }
 
-    private boolean isYelling(String input) {
+    private boolean isShouting(String input) {
         return input.chars()
                     .anyMatch(Character::isLetter) &&
                 input.chars()
                     .filter(Character::isLetter)
                     .allMatch(Character::isUpperCase);
     }
 
-    private boolean isAsking(String input) {
+    private boolean isQuestioning(String input) {
         return input.endsWith("?");
     }
 
@@ -50,9 +50,9 @@ class Bob {
 }
 ```
 
-This approach defines helper methods for each type of message—silent, yelling, and asking—to keep each condition clean and easily testable. For more details, refer to the [Method-Based Approach][approach-method-based].
+This approach defines helper methods for each type of message—silent, shouting, and questioning—to keep each condition clean and easily testable. For more details, refer to the [`if` Statements Approach][approach-if].
 
-## Approach: `if` Statements
+## Approach: nested `if` statements
 
 ```java
 import java.util.function.Predicate;
@@ -84,9 +84,9 @@ class Bob {
 }
 ```
 
-This approach utilizes nested `if` statements and a predicate for determining if a message is a shout. For more details, refer to the [`if` Statements Approach][approach-if].
+This approach utilizes nested `if` statements and a predicate for determining if a message is a shout. For more details, refer to the [nested `if` Statements Approach][approach-nested-if].
 
-## Approach: Answer Array
+## Approach: answer array
 
 ```java
 import java.util.function.Predicate;
@@ -118,17 +118,17 @@ This approach uses an array of answers and calculates the appropriate index base
 
 ## Which Approach to Use?
 
-Choosing between the method-based approach, `if` statements, and answer array approach can come down to readability and maintainability. Each has its advantages:
+The choice between the **`if` Statements Approach**, **Nested `if` Statements Approach**, and the **Answer Array Approach** depends on readability, maintainability, and efficiency:
 
-- **Method-Based**: Clear and modular, great for readability.
-- **`if` Statements**: Compact and straightforward.
-- **Answer Array**: Minimizes condition checks by using indices, efficient for a variety of responses.
+- **`if` Statements Approach**: This is clear and easy to follow but checks conditions multiple times, potentially affecting performance. Storing results in variables like `questioning` and `shouting` can improve efficiency but may reduce clarity slightly.
+- **Nested `if` Statements Approach**: This approach can be more efficient by avoiding redundant checks, but its nested structure can reduce readability and maintainability.
+- **Answer Array Approach**: Efficient and compact, this method uses an array of responses based on flags for questioning and shouting. However, it may be less intuitive and harder to modify if more responses are needed.
 
-Experiment with these approaches to find the balance between readability and performance that best suits your needs.
+Each approach offers a balance between readability and performance, with trade-offs in flexibility and clarity.
 
 [trim]: https://docs.oracle.com/javase/7/docs/api/java/lang/String.html#trim()
 [endswith]: https://docs.oracle.com/javase/7/docs/api/java/lang/String.html#endsWith(java.lang.String)
 [dry]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Don%27t_repeat_yourself
-[approach-method-based]: https://exercism.org/tracks/java/exercises/bob/approaches/method-based
+[approach-nested-if]: https://exercism.org/tracks/java/exercises/bob/approaches/nested-if-statements
 [approach-if]: https://exercism.org/tracks/java/exercises/bob/approaches/if-statements
 [approach-answer-array]: https://exercism.org/tracks/java/exercises/bob/approaches/answer-array