Skip to content

Commit cfe3869

Browse files
matthiaskmatthiask
committed
Add docs
1 parent fd947ce commit cfe3869

File tree

1 file changed

+221
-0
lines changed

1 file changed

+221
-0
lines changed

‎tests/TREE_ADMIN_IMPLEMENTATION.md‎

Lines changed: 221 additions & 0 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,221 @@
1+
# TreeAdmin Implementation Summary
2+
3+
This document captures the complete implementation of the TreeAdmin functionality for django-tree-queries, developed in collaboration with Claude Code.
4+
5+
## Overview
6+
7+
Added a comprehensive TreeAdmin class for Django admin that provides intuitive tree management with drag-and-drop style node moving capabilities, supporting both positioned and unpositioned trees.
8+
9+
## Key Features Implemented
10+
11+
### 1. TreeAdmin Class (`tree_queries/admin.py`)
12+
- **Base class**: Extends Django's `ModelAdmin`
13+
- **Configuration**: `position_field = None` (set to field name for controllable positioning)
14+
- **Automatic adaptation**: Interface changes based on whether positioning is controllable
15+
- **List display columns**: `collapse_column`, `indented_title`, `move_column`
16+
17+
### 2. Tree Visualization
18+
- **Hierarchical display**: Unicode box-drawing characters for tree structure
19+
- **Collapsible nodes**: Click to expand/collapse branches
20+
- **Depth indication**: Visual indentation and depth-based styling
21+
- **Row highlighting**: Different background colors by tree depth
22+
23+
### 3. Node Moving System
24+
- **Cut/paste workflow**: Click cut button, select destination from dropdown
25+
- **Position options** (when positioning is controllable):
26+
- `before`: Move before another sibling
27+
- `after`: Move after another sibling
28+
- `first-child`: Move as first child
29+
- `last-child`: Move as last child
30+
- **Root moves** (when positioning not controllable):
31+
- Direct "move to root" button with confirmation workflow
32+
- `child`: Move as child of another node
33+
- `root`: Move to root level
34+
35+
### 4. Smart Interface Adaptation
36+
- **With position field**: Shows full move options (before, after, first-child, last-child)
37+
- **Without position field**: Shows simplified options (child, root) + direct root button
38+
- **Visual state management**: Uses `data-move` attribute for CSS state control
39+
40+
## Technical Implementation
41+
42+
### JavaScript (`tree_queries/static/tree_queries/tree_admin.js`)
43+
- **Tree collapsing**: Recursive node visibility management
44+
- **Move state management**: Session storage persistence across page reloads
45+
- **Fetch API integration**: Consolidated `performMove()` function for all move operations
46+
- **Error handling**: Comprehensive error messages and state cleanup
47+
- **Button behavior**: Smart mode switching between regular and root moves
48+
49+
### CSS (`tree_queries/static/tree_queries/tree_admin.css`)
50+
- **Tree visualization**: Box-drawing characters and indentation
51+
- **State management**: Data attribute selectors (`body[data-move="root"]`)
52+
- **Button styling**: Inline SVG icons from Material Design
53+
- **Status bar**: Fixed position move status with action buttons
54+
- **Responsive design**: Works with Django admin's responsive layout
55+
56+
### Form Validation (`MoveNodeForm`)
57+
- **Dynamic field setup**: Adapts to admin's position_field configuration
58+
- **Position validation**: Ensures valid moves based on tree constraints
59+
- **Error handling**: Clear validation messages for invalid operations
60+
- **Backend processing**: Handles all move types with proper sibling ordering
61+
62+
## File Structure
63+
64+
```
65+
tree_queries/
66+
├── admin.py # Main TreeAdmin class and MoveNodeForm
67+
├── static/tree_queries/
68+
│ ├── tree_admin.css # Complete styling with inline SVG icons
69+
│ └── tree_admin.js # Tree interaction and move functionality
70+
└── templatetags/
71+
└── tree_queries.py # Template tags (tree_info, recursetree)
72+
73+
tests/testapp/
74+
├── admin.py # Example admin classes for testing
75+
├── models.py # Test models (Model, UnorderedModel, etc.)
76+
└── test_admin.py # Comprehensive test suite (12 test cases)
77+
```
78+
79+
## Dependencies and Installation
80+
81+
### Package Configuration (`pyproject.toml`)
82+
```toml
83+
dependencies = [] # Core package has no dependencies
84+
85+
optional-dependencies.admin = [
86+
"django-js-asset",
87+
]
88+
89+
optional-dependencies.tests = [
90+
"coverage",
91+
"pytest",
92+
"pytest-cov",
93+
"pytest-django",
94+
"django-js-asset",
95+
]
96+
```
97+
98+
### Installation
99+
```bash
100+
# Core functionality only
101+
pip install django-tree-queries
102+
103+
# With admin functionality
104+
pip install django-tree-queries[admin]
105+
106+
# For development/testing
107+
pip install django-tree-queries[tests]
108+
```
109+
110+
### CI/CD Configuration
111+
- **tox.ini**: Added `django-js-asset` to test dependencies
112+
- **GitHub Actions**: Uses tox for cross-platform testing
113+
114+
### Running Tests
115+
```bash
116+
# Run tests for specific Python/Django combination
117+
tox -e py313-dj52-sqlite
118+
119+
# Run all supported combinations
120+
tox
121+
122+
# Run with specific database backends
123+
tox -e py313-dj52-postgresql
124+
tox -e py313-dj52-mysql
125+
126+
# Run specific test files or add pytest arguments
127+
tox -e py313-dj52-sqlite -- tests/testapp/test_admin.py -v
128+
tox -e py313-dj52-sqlite -- tests/testapp/test_admin.py::TreeAdminTestCase::test_position_field_configuration -v
129+
```
130+
131+
## Usage Examples
132+
133+
### Basic TreeAdmin
134+
```python
135+
from django.contrib import admin
136+
from tree_queries.admin import TreeAdmin
137+
from .models import Category
138+
139+
@admin.register(Category)
140+
class CategoryAdmin(TreeAdmin):
141+
list_display = [*TreeAdmin.list_display, "name", "is_active"]
142+
position_field = "order" # For controllable sibling positioning
143+
```
144+
145+
### Unpositioned Trees
146+
```python
147+
@admin.register(Department)
148+
class DepartmentAdmin(TreeAdmin):
149+
list_display = [*TreeAdmin.list_display, "name"]
150+
# position_field = None (default) - uses direct root moves
151+
```
152+
153+
## Test Coverage
154+
155+
### Test Suite (`tests/testapp/test_admin.py`)
156+
- **12 comprehensive test cases**
157+
- **Coverage**: Form validation, move operations, UI adaptation
158+
- **Test classes**: `TreeAdminTestCase`, `MoveOperationTestCase`
159+
- **Scenarios**: Both positioned and unpositioned tree models
160+
161+
### Key Test Cases
162+
1. Position field configuration validation
163+
2. Move position options based on positioning capability
164+
3. Form validation for all move types
165+
4. Actual move operations (before, after, first-child, last-child, root, child)
166+
5. UI context and button visibility
167+
168+
## Design Decisions
169+
170+
### 1. Terminology
171+
- **"Position" over "Ordering"**: Avoided Django's overloaded "ordering" terminology
172+
- **position_field**: More specific than generic "ordering_field"
173+
- **Positioning vs Ordering**: Clearer semantic distinction
174+
175+
### 2. Architecture
176+
- **Direct field access**: Removed getter methods, use `self.position_field` directly
177+
- **Truthiness checks**: Use `if self.position_field:` instead of `!= None`
178+
- **Consolidated constants**: Single source of truth for move positions
179+
180+
### 3. Dependencies
181+
- **Minimal core**: No dependencies for basic tree functionality
182+
- **Optional admin**: Admin functionality via `[admin]` extra
183+
- **Self-contained icons**: Inline SVG to avoid external dependencies
184+
- **Proper attribution**: Clear credit to Material Design icons
185+
186+
### 4. UX/UI
187+
- **Consistent buttons**: Status bar uses buttons for both confirm and cancel
188+
- **Visual feedback**: Row highlighting during moves
189+
- **State persistence**: Move state survives page navigation
190+
- **Accessibility**: Proper button semantics and ARIA-friendly
191+
192+
## Performance Considerations
193+
194+
- **Efficient queries**: Uses existing `with_tree_fields()` infrastructure
195+
- **Minimal JavaScript**: No heavy libraries, vanilla JS only
196+
- **CSS optimization**: Inline SVG data URLs, no external requests
197+
- **State management**: Lightweight session storage usage
198+
199+
## Future Enhancement Possibilities
200+
201+
Based on the implementation, potential future enhancements could include:
202+
203+
1. **Bulk operations**: Multiple node selection and moving
204+
2. **Drag-and-drop**: Direct mouse-based moving (though cut/paste is often more reliable)
205+
3. **Keyboard shortcuts**: Arrow keys for navigation, shortcuts for common operations
206+
4. **Custom position field types**: Support for different ordering strategies
207+
5. **Tree filtering**: Admin filters based on tree structure
208+
6. **Export/import**: Tree structure serialization
209+
210+
## Documentation
211+
212+
- **README.rst**: Complete usage documentation with examples
213+
- **CHANGELOG.rst**: Added entry for TreeAdmin functionality
214+
- **Inline comments**: Code documentation and icon attribution
215+
- **Type hints**: Could be added for better IDE support
216+
217+
## Conclusion
218+
219+
The TreeAdmin implementation provides a production-ready, intuitive interface for managing tree structures in Django admin. The code is well-tested, properly documented, and designed for maintainability and extensibility.
220+
221+
The implementation successfully balances functionality with simplicity, providing powerful tree management capabilities while maintaining Django admin's familiar patterns and conventions.

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)