WIP Categories spreadsheet and mapping to cloud providers offering

[vicenteherrera]

Hi friends,

I want to start this discussion thread sharing an updated version of the spreadsheet I started, with categories originally proposed by @simonzhangbmo here, and my first attempt to map them to what cloud providers use for categories.

This is an improved version where I've found a better source for official AWS categories, they map a lot better (almost perfeclty) than my previous attempt.
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/10TP21qAnjnn5TkW1y758oPpjzc4CcyF4UKNCmsnlzps/edit#gid=1772808763

I also attacht here an Excel file for it.
Finos CCC categories - 2023-09-13.xlsx

I know this has to be done under consensus, my intention with this is having something "shitty" to start with that we can iterate and see how it fits. We should stablish a good criteria about the conditions for separation of categories we are defining (why is containers not compute), and agree to a couples of paragraphs description for each one. We should also list in more detail each service inside each cloud provider category, and make sure not only names match but also the category definition.

But until we solve how to organize work, allow me to tinker with this and share it with you here. It's completely open to anybody's feedback and suggestions... let's discuss, friends!

[mcleo-d]

@vicenteherrera - I have added this discussion to the CCC project kanban - FINOS Common Cloud Controls - Project Kanban (view)

Thanks for raising 🙌🏻

cc @rhyddian and @mark-rushing

[mcleo-d]

Hi @smendis-scottlogic - The link above is asking for a Scott Logic login. Also, I've noticed there is an emoji rendered in the URL :)

[smendis-scottlogic]

Hi @mcleo-d sorry about that. will remove that link. Can you download the attachment?

[mcleo-d]

Hi @smendis-scottlogic

I have just raised the following pull request that converts @vicenteherrera's original work to markdown.

#39

Is there a big difference between your Excel and the original sheet as like to make sure we don't lose track of versions?

Many thanks,

James.

[mcleo-d]

Hi @smendis-scottlogic - I have taken your Excel sheet and have added to @vicenteherrera's Google Sheet below to ensure that your work doesn't get lost in Discussion comments...

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/10TP21qAnjnn5TkW1y758oPpjzc4CcyF4UKNCmsnlzps/edit?pli=1#gid=1458499499&range=A1

[mcleo-d]

Hi @smendis-scottlogic - I have added your CSP comparison to pull request #39 so it appears in the repo as markdown for people to extend and comment upon.

77ed1fb#r1337550928

[smendis-scottlogic]

Hi James, Thanks! Hopefully we will be able to see whether we are on the right track after tomorrow's meeting. Best Regards, Sonali Mendis

…

________________________________ From: James McLeod ***@***.***> Sent: Tuesday, September 26, 2023 6:19 PM To: finos/common-cloud-controls ***@***.***> Cc: Sonali Mendis (She/Her) ***@***.***>; Mention ***@***.***> Subject: Re: [finos/common-cloud-controls] WIP Categories spreadsheet and mapping to cloud providers offering (Discussion #29) Hi @smendis-scottlogic<https://github.com/smendis-scottlogic> - I have added your CSP comparison to pull request #39<#39> so it appears in the repo as markdown for people to extend and comment upon. 77ed1fb#r1337550928<77ed1fb#r1337550928> — Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub<#29 (reply in thread)>, or unsubscribe<https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/A5UIC5OQWTSDLGTLQD2R2ADX4MFB7ANCNFSM6AAAAAA4XEOIRM>. You are receiving this because you were mentioned.Message ID: ***@***.***>

[damienjburks]

@smendis-scottlogic are we good to close this out?