Skip to content

Commit 6d9ec7c

Browse files
CopilotDamianReeves
Copilot
and
DamianReeves
authored
Add comprehensive Issue #240 enhancement specification with guru framework principles (#278)
* Initial plan * Add enhanced Issue #240 specification with guru creation principles Co-authored-by: DamianReeves <957246+DamianReeves@users.noreply.github.com> * Add Issue #240 enhancement summary and update design index Co-authored-by: DamianReeves <957246+DamianReeves@users.noreply.github.com> * Add navigation guide for Issue #240 enhancement documents Co-authored-by: DamianReeves <957246+DamianReeves@users.noreply.github.com> * Merge main branch with vulnerability fixes and documentation restructure Co-authored-by: DamianReeves <957246+DamianReeves@users.noreply.github.com> --------- Co-authored-by: copilot-swe-agent[bot] <198982749+Copilot@users.noreply.github.com> Co-authored-by: DamianReeves <957246+DamianReeves@users.noreply.github.com>
1 parent a90a674 commit 6d9ec7c

File tree

4 files changed

+1659
-0
lines changed

4 files changed

+1659
-0
lines changed

‎docs/content/docs/contributing/design/ISSUE-240-README.md‎

Lines changed: 171 additions & 0 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,171 @@
1+
# Issue #240 Enhancement - Navigation Guide
2+
3+
This directory contains the enhanced specification for **Issue #240: Create Elm to F# Guru Skill**, incorporating guru framework principles from Issue #253.
4+
5+
## Quick Start
6+
7+
**New to Issue #240 enhancement?** Start here:
8+
9+
1. **[Quick Summary](./issue-240-summary.md)** - 10-minute read
10+
- Overview of all 7 enhancement sections
11+
- Key features and benefits
12+
- Before vs After comparison
13+
14+
2. **[Full Specification](./issue-240-enhanced.md)** - 30-minute read
15+
- Complete detailed specification
16+
- All 7 sections with examples and workflows
17+
- Implementation checklists
18+
19+
## Document Structure
20+
21+
### [issue-240-summary.md](./issue-240-summary.md)
22+
**Purpose:** Quick reference and overview
23+
**Audience:** Maintainers, reviewers, developers
24+
**Length:** 312 lines (~10 pages)
25+
26+
**Contains:**
27+
- Summary of all 7 enhancements
28+
- Key metrics and benefits
29+
- Before vs After comparison table
30+
- Implementation checklist
31+
- How to use the enhancement
32+
33+
**Use this if:**
34+
- You need a quick overview
35+
- You're reviewing the enhancement
36+
- You want to understand what changed
37+
38+
---
39+
40+
### [issue-240-enhanced.md](./issue-240-enhanced.md)
41+
**Purpose:** Complete specification for implementation
42+
**Audience:** Developers implementing the guru
43+
**Length:** 1,167 lines (~45 pages)
44+
45+
**Contains:**
46+
- **Section 1:** Proactive Review Capability ⭐
47+
- What the guru reviews (anti-patterns, Myriad opportunities, idiom violations)
48+
- Review triggers (session, weekly, quarterly)
49+
- Review output format with examples
50+
51+
- **Section 2:** Automated Feedback & Continuous Improvement
52+
- Session capture with "Patterns Discovered" section
53+
- Quarterly reviews and playbook evolution
54+
- Automation loop (patterns → scripts → prevention)
55+
56+
- **Section 3:** Token Efficiency Analysis
57+
- 4 F# scripts with detailed workflows
58+
- Token savings per script and annually (152,720 tokens)
59+
- JSON output examples
60+
61+
- **Section 4:** Cross-Project Portability
62+
- Portable components (pattern detection, analysis, review philosophy)
63+
- Non-portable components (F# idioms, Myriad plugins)
64+
- Adaptation guides (Elm-to-Haskell, Elm-to-OCaml, Python-to-F#)
65+
66+
- **Section 5:** Guru Coordination
67+
- With AOT Guru (generated code review)
68+
- With QA Tester (test coverage verification)
69+
- With Release Manager (milestone tracking)
70+
- Common retrospectives
71+
72+
- **Section 6:** Review Integration with Retrospectives
73+
- How proactive reviews and reactive retrospectives work together
74+
- Q1-Q3 improvement cycle example
75+
- ValueType boxing pattern case study
76+
77+
- **Section 7:** Enhanced Success Criteria
78+
- Functional, Learning, Automation, Maturity criteria
79+
- 3 maturity phases: Alpha (Q1), Beta (Q2-Q3), Stable (Q4+)
80+
- Measurable metrics and timelines
81+
82+
**Use this if:**
83+
- You're implementing the Elm-to-F# Guru
84+
- You need detailed workflows and examples
85+
- You want to understand the full design
86+
87+
---
88+
89+
## How to Use These Documents
90+
91+
### For Maintainers
92+
1. Review [issue-240-summary.md](./issue-240-summary.md) for overview
93+
2. Read [issue-240-enhanced.md](./issue-240-enhanced.md) for details
94+
3. Use content to update GitHub Issue #240
95+
4. Assign to developer for implementation
96+
97+
### For Developers
98+
1. Start with [issue-240-summary.md](./issue-240-summary.md) to understand scope
99+
2. Use [issue-240-enhanced.md](./issue-240-enhanced.md) as implementation spec
100+
3. Follow Implementation Checklist in Section 7
101+
4. Reference [Guru Creation Guide](../../../.agents/guru-creation-guide.md)
102+
5. Use [Skill Template](../../../../.claude/skills/template/)
103+
104+
### For Reviewers
105+
1. Check [issue-240-summary.md](./issue-240-summary.md) for acceptance criteria
106+
2. Verify all 7 sections are implemented
107+
3. Validate automation scripts exist and work
108+
4. Confirm review capability is functional
109+
5. Ensure maturity phase criteria are met
110+
111+
## Related Resources
112+
113+
### Guru Framework Documentation
114+
- [Issue #253](https://github.com/finos/morphir-dotnet/issues/253) - Unified Cross-Agent AI Skill Framework Architecture
115+
- [Issue #254](https://github.com/finos/morphir-dotnet/issues/254) - Cross-Agent Skill Accessibility
116+
- [Issue #255](https://github.com/finos/morphir-dotnet/issues/255) - Guru Creation Guide & Template
117+
- [Guru Philosophy](../../../.agents/guru-philosophy.md)
118+
- [Guru Creation Guide](../../../.agents/guru-creation-guide.md)
119+
- [Skills Reference](../../../.agents/skills-reference.md)
120+
121+
### Code Generation Issues
122+
- [Issue #241](https://github.com/finos/morphir-dotnet/issues/241) - Create CodeGeneration Project
123+
- [Issue #242](https://github.com/finos/morphir-dotnet/issues/242) - Integrate Fabulous.AST for F# Code Generation
124+
125+
### Implementation Resources
126+
- [Skill Template](../../../../.claude/skills/template/) - Template for new gurus
127+
- [QA Tester Guru](../../../../.claude/skills/qa-tester/) - Example mature guru
128+
- [AOT Guru](../../../../.claude/skills/aot-guru/) - Example mature guru
129+
- [Release Manager](../../../../.claude/skills/release-manager/) - Example mature guru
130+
131+
## Key Innovations
132+
133+
This enhancement is notable for several innovations:
134+
135+
1. **First Guru with Review Built-In from Day One**
136+
- Earlier gurus (QA Tester, AOT Guru, Release Manager) added review later
137+
- Elm-to-F# Guru has review as core competency from the start
138+
- Establishes pattern for all future gurus
139+
140+
2. **Comprehensive Token Efficiency Analysis**
141+
- 4 automation scripts with detailed token savings
142+
- Per-script and annual projections (152,720 tokens)
143+
- Reusability across projects documented
144+
145+
3. **Cross-Project Portability Analysis**
146+
- Clear separation: portable vs non-portable components
147+
- Adaptation guides for Elm-to-Haskell, Elm-to-OCaml, Python-to-F#
148+
- Effort estimates for adaptation (12-40 hours)
149+
150+
4. **Review + Retrospective Integration**
151+
- Detailed Q1-Q3 improvement cycle example
152+
- ValueType boxing pattern case study
153+
- Shows how proactive + reactive approaches work together
154+
155+
5. **Maturity Model with Clear Metrics**
156+
- 3 phases: Alpha (Q1), Beta (Q2-Q3), Stable (Q4+)
157+
- Measurable success criteria per phase
158+
- Transition criteria between phases
159+
160+
## Questions?
161+
162+
- **About the enhancement:** See [issue-240-summary.md](./issue-240-summary.md) "How to Use This Enhancement" section
163+
- **About implementation:** See [issue-240-enhanced.md](./issue-240-enhanced.md) "Implementation Checklist" section
164+
- **About guru framework:** See [Guru Creation Guide](../../../.agents/guru-creation-guide.md)
165+
- **About specific gurus:** See [Skills Reference](../../../.agents/skills-reference.md)
166+
167+
---
168+
169+
**Last Updated:** 2025-12-19
170+
**Status:** ✅ Complete and ready for use
171+
**Next Steps:** Use content to update GitHub Issue #240

‎docs/content/docs/contributing/design/_index.md‎

Lines changed: 9 additions & 0 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -18,6 +18,15 @@ The morphir-dotnet project uses a sophisticated AI skill framework (gurus) for c
1818
| [Guru Creation Guide](guru-creation-guide) | Step-by-step guide for creating new AI gurus |
1919
| [Technical Writer Skill](technical-writer-skill-requirements) | Requirements for the Technical Writer skill |
2020

21+
### Guru Specifications & Enhancements
22+
23+
| Document | Description |
24+
|----------|-------------|
25+
| [Issue #240 Enhancement Summary](issue-240-summary) | Quick reference for Elm-to-F# Guru enhancement with guru framework principles |
26+
| [Issue #240 Enhanced Specification](issue-240-enhanced) | Complete specification for Elm-to-F# Guru with proactive review, token efficiency, and maturity phases |
27+
| [Issue #240 Navigation Guide](ISSUE-240-README) | Navigation guide for all Issue #240 enhancement documents |
28+
29+
2130
## Product Requirements Documents
2231

2332
PRDs track feature requirements, design decisions, and implementation status:

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)