Skip to content

Misallignment in Rotary Frequencies #12538

@Warvito

Description

@Warvito

Describe the bug

In WanRotaryPosEmbed (link), we are splitting the attention_head_dim into the different dimensions in different ways in __init__ and forward. This causes a missmatch depending on the attention_head_dim. This issue is also presentin other models that use rotary (e.g., Skyreels_v2).

Details

Given

h_dim = w_dim = 2 * (attention_head_dim // 6)
t_dim = attention_head_dim - h_dim - w_dim

if we have an attention_head_dim=64, we get:

h_dim = w_dim = 2 * (attention_head_dim // 6)
t_dim = attention_head_dim - h_dim - w_dim
print([t_dim, h_dim, w_dim])

printing [24, 20, 20]

In the forward, when spliting the dimensions, we have

split_sizes = [
self.attention_head_dim - 2 * (self.attention_head_dim // 3),
self.attention_head_dim // 3,
self.attention_head_dim // 3,
]

so if we try

split_sizes = [
    attention_head_dim - 2 * (attention_head_dim // 3),
    attention_head_dim // 3,
    attention_head_dim // 3,
]
print(split_sizes)

printing [22, 21, 21]

In most of the models where the attention head is equal to 128 the values match, but I was wondering if this is a bug to fix.

Reproduction

NA

Logs

System Info

NA

Who can help?

@DN6 @yiyixuxu @sayakpaul

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    bugSomething isn't working

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions