Replies: 6 comments 21 replies
-
|
That should read: Voltage shows what appears to be the correct values for Home and Grid (244.5 volts more or less). |
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
|
Hi @heynorm - The current data in the graph comes from polling this payload (instant_total_current values): http://localhost:8675/aggregates The instant_total_current values come from the TEDAPI Status API from the METER_X_AcMeasurements and METER_Y_AcMeasurements blocks: http://localhost:8675/tedapi/status Specifically: meter_x = lookup(status, ("esCan","bus","SYNC","METER_X_AcMeasurements")) or {}
i1 = meter_x.get("METER_X_CTA_I", 0)
i2 = meter_x.get("METER_X_CTB_I", 0)
i3 = meter_x.get("METER_X_CTC_I", 0)
meter_y = lookup(status, ("esCan","bus","SYNC","METER_Y_AcMeasurements")) or {}
yi1 = meter_y.get("METER_Y_CTA_I", 0)
yi2 = meter_y.get("METER_Y_CTB_I", 0)
yi3 = meter_y.get("METER_Y_CTC_I", 0)Can you look at http://localhost:8675/tedapi/status to see if you have data in the METER sections? Some systems do not have data in this section and use neurio meters. There is a PR in flight to help add that (jasonacox/pypowerwall#157). |
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
|
I would especially be interested to know if you have anything in the |
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
|
@jasonacox - thanks for the reply. I do have a METER_Z_AcMeasurements section. It does contain the same numbers for the amperage values reported in the Tesla One app System/Metering under the Tesla Backup Switch device. This appears to be what is being reported in for Meter_Z. Here is the section with METER_Z from tedapi/status: "MSA": {
"METER_Z_AcMeasurements": {
"METER_Z_CTA_I": 3.51,
"METER_Z_CTA_InstReactivePower": -218,
"METER_Z_CTA_InstRealPower": 341,
"METER_Z_CTB_I": 5.68,
"METER_Z_CTB_InstReactivePower": -246,
"METER_Z_CTB_InstRealPower": 597,
"METER_Z_VL1G": 121.41,
"METER_Z_VL2G": 121.26,
"isMIA": false,
"lastRxTime": "2025-05-25T20:18:41-07:00"
},
"MSA_InfoMsg": {
"MSA_appGitHash": [74, 65, 145, 255, 126, 20, 230],
"MSA_assemblyId": 0,
"isMIA": false
},
"MSA_Status": {
"lastRxTime": "2025-05-25T20:18:41-07:00"
},
"packagePartNumber": "1624171-00-H",
"packageSerialNumber": "GF22315900xxxxx" <-- This is the serial number of my Tesla Backup Switch (last 5 digits obscured)
},Here is a screen shot from the Tesla One app that shows the amperage numbers. This shot was taken around the same time as I ran tedapi/status, so the numbers are very close, but not exact.
Let me know if this is helpful and what additional info I can provide. |
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
|
Right now, the logic in pypowerwall is ignoring the METER_Z values. This is a good discovery! In looking at the logic I think there are several other problems. Even my PW2/+ system I see that the current values are wrong when using full TEDAPI model (it works in hybrid mode using legacy PW2 APIs). I'm going to do some research to see if I can get it better mapped. Also, there are some systems where these Tesla meters are not used and they use Neurio data (see jasonacox/pypowerwall#157 where @Nexarian is adding logic to include those). In your case, METER_Z (Backup Switch) is reporting grid (site) values. |
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
|
Ok, thanks. I am happy to do testing or provide additional info as needed.
…________________________________
From: Jason Cox ***@***.***>
Sent: Monday, May 26, 2025 10:24 AM
To: jasonacox/Powerwall-Dashboard ***@***.***>
Cc: heynorm ***@***.***>; Mention ***@***.***>
Subject: Re: [jasonacox/Powerwall-Dashboard] Dashboard System Vitals Section - Current Graph is always 0 (Discussion #629)
Right now, the logic in pypowerwall is ignoring the METER_Z values. This is a good discovery!
In looking at the logic I think there are several other problems. Even my PW2/+ system I see that the current values are wrong when using full TEDAPI model (it work in hybrid mode using legacy PW2 APIs). I'm going to do some research to see if I can get it better mapped.
Also, there are some systems where these Tesla meters are not used and they use Neurio data (see jasonacox/pypowerwall#157<jasonacox/pypowerwall#157> where @Nexarian<https://github.com/Nexarian> is adding logic to include those). In your case, METER_Z (Backup Switch) is reporting grid (site) values.
—
Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub<#629 (reply in thread)>, or unsubscribe<https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/APUXY3F4WY5T373RGTLRQ2D3ANE55AVCNFSM6AAAAAB5UYFUXGVHI2DSMVQWIX3LMV43URDJONRXK43TNFXW4Q3PNVWWK3TUHMYTGMRXGQ4DSNI>.
You are receiving this because you were mentioned.Message ID: ***@***.***>
|
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
|
Thank you! I see the problem. Ugh. Updated logic. If you can, give this a try and let me know if this is tracking better. Thanks for your help! |
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
|
Hi @jasonacox - I tried this and I think there is still an issue with the voltage and current calculations in the latest beta. Here is the Aggregates and Vitals using the latest beta: http:/localhost:8675/aggregates: http://localhost:8675/vitals: |
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
|
Well, I know "it works on my computer" never helps, but in this case it is true. It seems to work great with the PW2, but clearly I'm missing something for the PW3. Can you run this python code to see what it shows? Replace the xxxxxxxxxx with your Powerwall password. import pypowerwall
PW_GW_PWD="xxxxxxxxxx"
PW_HOST="192.168.91.1"
def lookup(data, keylist):
for key in keylist:
if isinstance(data, dict):
data = data.get(key)
else:
return None
return data
# Connect
pw = pypowerwall.Powerwall(PW_HOST, gw_pwd=PW_GW_PWD)
print(f"mode: {pw.mode} - tedapi: {pw.tedapi_mode}")
# Get TEDAPI Status
status = pw.tedapi.get_status()
# Extract Battery Info
battery_power = pw.tedapi.current_power(location="battery")
v_battery = lookup(status, ("esCan","bus","PINV")) or []
# print(v_battery)
sum_vll_battery = 0
count_battery = 0
for i in range(len(v_battery)):
v = lookup(v_battery[i], ("PINV_Status", "PINV_Vout")) or 0
if v:
sum_vll_battery += v
count_battery += 1
vll_battery = sum_vll_battery / count_battery if count_battery else 0
if vll_battery == 0:
vll_battery = None
i_battery = battery_power / vll_battery if vll_battery else None
print(f"vll_battery: {vll_battery} V")
print(f"i_battery: {i_battery} A")
print(f"count_battery: {count_battery}")
print(f"battery_power: {battery_power} W")
print()If that doesn't work (you still get nothing), remove the comment from |
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
|
@jasonacox - I ran it without uncommenting that line and got: So I uncommented the line and this is the battery info: |
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
|
In 'PINV_AcMeasurements', the voltage is split into two values: 'PINV_VSplit1' and 'PINV_VSplit2'. Both values are 0 in all dictionaries. In 'PINV_Status', the voltage is represented by 'PINV_Vout'. Again, all values are 0 in all dictionaries. Bummer. |
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
|
In case it helps, output against a PW3 plus one expansion pack, Tesla FW 25.10.4, PW-Dash v4.7.1. |
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
|
Same as @heynorm :( |
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
|
🤦 I think I figured it out. The PW3 has a separate payload for solar ... if you don't mind, please try: import pypowerwall
import math
PW_GW_PWD="xxxxxxx"
PW_HOST="192.168.91.1"
def lookup(data, keylist):
for key in keylist:
if isinstance(data, dict):
data = data.get(key)
else:
return None
return data
# Connect
pw = pypowerwall.Powerwall(PW_HOST, gw_pwd=PW_GW_PWD)
print(f"mode: {pw.mode} - tedapi: {pw.tedapi_mode}")
status = pw.tedapi.get_status()
# Get solar info
print("Solar Info:")
solar_power = pw.tedapi.current_power(location="solar")
if pw.tedapi.pw3:
# extract solar data from pw3_data
pw3_data = pw.tedapi.get_pw3_vitals()
v_solar_sum = 0
count_solar = 0
for p in pw3_data:
if p.startswith("PVAC--"):
v = pw3_data[p].get("PVAC_Vout")
if v:
v_solar_sum += v
count_solar += 1
vll_solar = v_solar_sum / count_solar if count_solar else 0
if vll_solar == 0:
vll_solar = None
i_solar = solar_power / vll_solar if vll_solar else None
yi1 = yi2 = yi3 = 0
else:
v_solar = lookup(status, ("esCan","bus","PVS")) or []
sum_vll_solar = 0
count_solar = 0
for p in lookup(status, ['esCan', 'bus', 'PVAC']) or {}:
if not p['packageSerialNumber']:
continue
sum_vll_solar += lookup(p, ['PVAC_Status', 'PVAC_Vout'])
count_solar += 1
vll_solar = sum_vll_solar / count_solar if count_solar else 0
if vll_solar == 0:
vll_solar = None
i_solar = solar_power / vll_solar if vll_solar else None
meter_y = lookup(status, ("esCan","bus","SYNC","METER_Y_AcMeasurements")) or {}
yi1 = meter_y.get("METER_Y_CTA_I", 0)
yi2 = meter_y.get("METER_Y_CTB_I", 0)
yi3 = meter_y.get("METER_Y_CTC_I", 0)
print(f"vll_solar: {vll_solar} V")
print(f"i_solar: {i_solar} A")
print(f"count_solar: {count_solar}")
print(f"solar_power: {solar_power} W")
print(f"i_a_current: {yi1} A")
print(f"i_b_current: {yi2} A")
print(f"i_c_current: {yi3} A")
print()
# uncomment if None
#print(f"v_solar: {v_solar}")
#print(f"pw3_data: {pw3_data}") |
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
|
Running the above against PW3 with one expansion pack, Tesla FW 25.10.4, I uncommented just in case it helped: Commented out failing line: |
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
|
Excellent! Thank yo both! I think we are getting close to the right logic. Can you try this new beta container? http:/localhost:8675/aggregates |
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
|
@jasonacox - tried the beta6. Solar values look better. Still see nulls for the battery. Here is the aggregates.json and a screenshot of the dashboard. |
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
|
Awesome! I added the same logic to the battery data aggregation - hopefully this works: jasonacox/pypowerwall:0.13.0t74-beta8 |
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
|
Staged: #634 Test: jasonacox/pypowerwall:0.13.0t74 |
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
|
Here is output of http://localhost:8675/aggregates with jasonacox/pypowerwall:0.13.0t74 |
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
-
|
Thank you for adding Voltage and Current to the vitals! Very nice add! |
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
Uh oh!
There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.
Uh oh!
There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.
-
I noticed that on the Dashboard under System Vitals, the Current graph always shows 0 all the time. Voltage shows what appears to be the current value for Home and Grid (244.5 volts more or less). I have 2 PW3's and a Tesla Backup Switch. I can see the proper Current values in the Tesla One app. This behavior has existed since I installed the Dashboard, so it does not appear to be anything related to recent firmware changes. Here is the pyPowerwall vitals output if that is helpful:
{ "PVAC--1707000-00-J--TGXXXXXXXXXXXX": { "PVAC_Fout": 59.985, "PVAC_PVCurrent_A": 0.2, "PVAC_PVCurrent_B": 0.2, "PVAC_PVCurrent_C": 0.2, "PVAC_PVCurrent_D": 0, "PVAC_PVCurrent_E": 0, "PVAC_PVCurrent_F": 0, "PVAC_PVMeasuredPower_A": 32.3999999999999, "PVAC_PVMeasuredPower_B": 31.5999999999999, "PVAC_PVMeasuredPower_C": 39.1999999999999, "PVAC_PVMeasuredPower_D": 0, "PVAC_PVMeasuredPower_E": 0, "PVAC_PVMeasuredPower_F": 0, "PVAC_PVMeasuredVoltage_A": 162, "PVAC_PVMeasuredVoltage_B": 158, "PVAC_PVMeasuredVoltage_C": 196, "PVAC_PVMeasuredVoltage_D": 0, "PVAC_PVMeasuredVoltage_E": 0, "PVAC_PVMeasuredVoltage_F": 0, "PVAC_Pout": 80, "PVAC_PvState_A": "Pv_Active", "PVAC_PvState_B": "Pv_Active", "PVAC_PvState_C": "Pv_Active", "PVAC_PvState_D": "Pv_Active", "PVAC_PvState_E": "Pv_Active", "PVAC_PvState_F": "Pv_Active_Parallel", "PVAC_State": "AcMode_GridFollowing", "PVAC_VL1Ground": 121.8, "PVAC_VL2Ground": 122, "PVAC_Vout": 243.8, "manufacturer": "TESLA", "partNumber": "1707000-00-J", "serialNumber": "TGXXXXXXXXXXXX" }, "PVAC--1707000-00-J--TGXXXXXXXXXXXX": { "PVAC_Fout": 59.98, "PVAC_PVCurrent_A": 1.95, "PVAC_PVCurrent_B": 1, "PVAC_PVCurrent_C": 1.8, "PVAC_PVCurrent_D": 0.0499999999999996, "PVAC_PVCurrent_E": 0, "PVAC_PVCurrent_F": 0, "PVAC_PVMeasuredPower_A": 569.4, "PVAC_PVMeasuredPower_B": 226, "PVAC_PVMeasuredPower_C": 453.6, "PVAC_PVMeasuredPower_D": 0.0999999999999993, "PVAC_PVMeasuredPower_E": 0, "PVAC_PVMeasuredPower_F": 0, "PVAC_PVMeasuredVoltage_A": 292, "PVAC_PVMeasuredVoltage_B": 226, "PVAC_PVMeasuredVoltage_C": 252, "PVAC_PVMeasuredVoltage_D": 2, "PVAC_PVMeasuredVoltage_E": 0, "PVAC_PVMeasuredVoltage_F": 0, "PVAC_Pout": 880, "PVAC_PvState_A": "Pv_Active", "PVAC_PvState_B": "Pv_Active", "PVAC_PvState_C": "Pv_Active", "PVAC_PvState_D": "Pv_Active", "PVAC_PvState_E": "Pv_Active", "PVAC_PvState_F": "Pv_Active_Parallel", "PVAC_State": "AcMode_GridFollowing", "PVAC_VL1Ground": 121.4, "PVAC_VL2Ground": 121.6, "PVAC_Vout": 243.2, "manufacturer": "TESLA", "partNumber": "1707000-00-J", "serialNumber": "TGXXXXXXXXXXXX" }, "PVS--1707000-00-J--TGXXXXXXXXXXXX": { "PVS_StringA_Connected": true, "PVS_StringB_Connected": true, "PVS_StringC_Connected": true, "PVS_StringD_Connected": true, "PVS_StringE_Connected": true, "PVS_StringF_Connected": true }, "PVS--1707000-00-J--TGXXXXXXXXXXXX": { "PVS_StringA_Connected": true, "PVS_StringB_Connected": true, "PVS_StringC_Connected": true, "PVS_StringD_Connected": true, "PVS_StringE_Connected": true, "PVS_StringF_Connected": true }, "STSTSM--1707000-00-J--TGXXXXXXXXXXXX": { "STSTSM-Location": "Gateway", "alerts": [ "SelfConsumptionReservedLimit", "SystemConnectedToGrid", "FWUpdateSucceeded", "ChargeOnlyFromSolarOverride" ], "firmwareVersion": null, "lastCommunicationTime": null, "manufacturer": "TESLA", "partNumber": "1707000-00-J", "serialNumber": "TG1240190032KX", "teslaEnergyEcuAttributes": { "ecuType": 207 } }, "TEPINV--1707000-00-J--TGXXXXXXXXXXXX": { "PINV_Fout": 59.985, "PINV_Pout": 0.08, "PINV_State": "AcMode_GridFollowing", "PINV_VSplit1": 121.8, "PINV_VSplit2": 122, "PINV_Vout": 243.8 }, "TEPINV--1707000-00-J--TGXXXXXXXXXXXX": { "PINV_Fout": 59.98, "PINV_Pout": 0.88, "PINV_State": "AcMode_GridFollowing", "PINV_VSplit1": 121.4, "PINV_VSplit2": 121.6, "PINV_Vout": 243.2 }, "TEPOD--1707000-00-J--TGXXXXXXXXXXXX": { "POD_nom_energy_remaining": 14160, "POD_nom_energy_to_be_charged": 260, "POD_nom_full_pack_energy": 14420, "alerts": [ "BAGGR_a007_EndOfCharge", "PWS_a003_MciSelfTestCD", "PWS_a004_MciSelfTestEF", "PWS_a008_MciPvIrrationalDEF" ] }, "TEPOD--1707000-00-J--TGXXXXXXXXXXXX": { "POD_nom_energy_remaining": 14270, "POD_nom_energy_to_be_charged": 200, "POD_nom_full_pack_energy": 14470, "alerts": [ "PWS_a003_MciSelfTestCD", "PWS_a004_MciSelfTestEF", "PWS_a008_MciPvIrrationalDEF" ] }, "TESLA--": { "componentParentDin": "STSTSM--1707000-00-J--TGXXXXXXXXXXXX", "lastCommunicationTime": null, "manufacturer": "TESLA", "meterAttributes": { "meterLocation": [1] }, "serialNumber": "" }, "TESYNC----": { "ISLAND_FreqL1_Load": 59.98, "ISLAND_FreqL1_Main": 59.98, "ISLAND_FreqL2_Load": 59.98, "ISLAND_FreqL2_Main": 59.98, "ISLAND_FreqL3_Load": 0, "ISLAND_FreqL3_Main": 0, "ISLAND_GridConnected": "ISLAND_GridConnected_Connected", "ISLAND_GridState": "ISLAND_GridState_Grid_Compliant", "ISLAND_L1L2PhaseDelta": null, "ISLAND_L1L3PhaseDelta": null, "ISLAND_L1MicrogridOk": null, "ISLAND_L2L3PhaseDelta": null, "ISLAND_L2MicrogridOk": null, "ISLAND_L3MicrogridOk": null, "ISLAND_PhaseL1_Main_Load": null, "ISLAND_PhaseL2_Main_Load": null, "ISLAND_PhaseL3_Main_Load": null, "ISLAND_ReadyForSynchronization": null, "ISLAND_VL1N_Load": 122, "ISLAND_VL1N_Main": 122, "ISLAND_VL2N_Load": 122, "ISLAND_VL2N_Main": 122, "ISLAND_VL3N_Load": 0, "ISLAND_VL3N_Main": 0, "METER_X_CTA_I": 0, "METER_X_CTA_InstReactivePower": 0, "METER_X_CTA_InstRealPower": 0, "METER_X_CTB_I": 0, "METER_X_CTB_InstReactivePower": 0, "METER_X_CTB_InstRealPower": 0, "METER_X_CTC_I": 0, "METER_X_CTC_InstReactivePower": 0, "METER_X_CTC_InstRealPower": 0, "METER_X_LifetimeEnergyExport": null, "METER_X_LifetimeEnergyImport": null, "METER_X_VL1N": 0, "METER_X_VL2N": 0, "METER_X_VL3N": 0, "METER_Y_CTA_I": 0, "METER_Y_CTA_InstReactivePower": 0, "METER_Y_CTA_InstRealPower": 0, "METER_Y_CTB_I": 0, "METER_Y_CTB_InstReactivePower": 0, "METER_Y_CTB_InstRealPower": 0, "METER_Y_CTC_I": 0, "METER_Y_CTC_InstReactivePower": 0, "METER_Y_CTC_InstRealPower": 0, "METER_Y_LifetimeEnergyExport": null, "METER_Y_LifetimeEnergyImport": null, "METER_Y_VL1N": 0, "METER_Y_VL2N": 0, "METER_Y_VL3N": 0, "SYNC_ExternallyPowered": null, "SYNC_SiteSwitchEnabled": null, "alerts": [], "componentParentDin": "STSTSM--1707000-00-J--TGXXXXXXXXXXXX", "firmwareVersion": null, "manufacturer": "TESLA", "partNumber": "", "serialNumber": "", "teslaEnergyEcuAttributes": { "ecuType": 259 } }, "VITALS": { "gateway": "192.168.91.1", "pyPowerwall": "0.12.12", "text": "Device vitals generated from Tesla Powerwall Gateway TEDAPI", "timestamp": 1747878788.74535 } }Here is an image of the relavent section of the Dashboard:
I am unsure where to go to debug this, but willing to provide additional information or other tasks to help track this down.
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
All reactions