Press the x in your browser during a recording but force leave the meeting, why ?

[MarcoScammacca]

What happened?

I noticed that if I press the x in the Chrome window during a Jitsi recording, a popup appears asking if I want to continue or cancel the closing operation. I like this, but in reality, I'm no longer in the meeting and I lose the recording... Why am I being kicked out of the meeting? I expected that by canceling the operation, I could get back into the meeting and continue recording... is that okay?

Platform

• Chrome (or Chromium based)
• Firefox
• Safari
• Other desktop browser
• Android browser
• iOS browser
• Electron app
• Android mobile app
• iOS mobile app
• Custom app using a mobile SDK

Browser / app / sdk version

144.0.7559.133

Relevant log output

chrome-extension://invalid/:1  GET chrome-extension://invalid/ net::ERR_FAILED
Image
(anonime) @ checkChromeExtensionsInstalled.web.ts:11
(anonime) @ checkChromeExtensionsInstalled.web.ts:9
(anonime) @ checkChromeExtensionsInstalled.web.ts:20
(anonime) @ checkChromeExtensionsInstalled.web.ts:21
fO @ checkChromeExtensionsInstalled.web.ts:21
componentDidUpdate @ ChromeExtensionBanner.web.tsx:71
wl @ react-dom.production.min.js:261
vl @ react-dom.production.min.js:260
yl @ react-dom.production.min.js:259
(anonime) @ react-dom.production.min.js:283
kc @ react-dom.production.min.js:281
lc @ react-dom.production.min.js:273
qa @ react-dom.production.min.js:127
cc @ react-dom.production.min.js:274
(anonime) @ middleware.any.ts:85
_listener @ StateListenerRegistry.ts:31
p @ redux.js:220
(anonime) @ index.js:20
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:20
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:193
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:19
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:14
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:23
(anonime) @ middleware.any.ts:40
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:21
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:77
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:60
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:72
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:43
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:52
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:28
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:155
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:7
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:37
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:22
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:66
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:50
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:35
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:19
(anonime) @ middleware.any.ts:52
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:60
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:273
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:48
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:21
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:11
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:18
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:31
(anonime) @ middleware.any.ts:39
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:41
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:117
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:26
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:132
(anonime) @ middleware.any.ts:73
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:27
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:17
(anonime) @ middleware.any.ts:24
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:18
(anonime) @ middleware.any.ts:18
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:32
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:16
Jae @ middleware.ts:560
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:232
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:15
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:42
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:30
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:63
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:8
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:53
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:50
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:176
(anonime) @ middleware.any.ts:606
(anonime) @ middleware.any.ts:72
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:158
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:177
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:112
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:226
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:90
(anonime) @ middleware.any.ts:35
(anonime) @ middleware.any.ts:38
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:99
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:65
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:18
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:10
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:74
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:174
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:13
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:73
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:61
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:9
(anonime) @ middleware.tsx:12
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:12
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:114
(anonime) @ middleware.tsx:17
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:37
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:56
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:99
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:20
(anonime) @ middleware.any.ts:45
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:16
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:35
(anonime) @ middleware.any.ts:118
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:152
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:22
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:14
(anonime) @ middleware.any.ts:23
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:43
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:176
Kae @ middleware.ts:417
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:397
_listener @ StateListenerRegistry.ts:31
p @ redux.js:220
(anonime) @ index.js:20
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:20
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:193
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:19
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:14
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:23
(anonime) @ middleware.any.ts:40
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:21
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:77
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:60
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:72
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:43
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:52
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:28
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:155
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:7
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:37
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:22
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:66
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:50
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:35
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:19
(anonime) @ middleware.any.ts:52
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:60
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:273
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:48
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:21
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:11
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:18
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:31
(anonime) @ middleware.any.ts:39
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:41
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:117
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:26
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:132
(anonime) @ middleware.any.ts:73
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:27
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:17
(anonime) @ middleware.any.ts:24
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:18
(anonime) @ middleware.any.ts:18
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:32
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:16
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:295
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:15
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:42
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:30
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:63
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:8
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:53
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:50
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:176
(anonime) @ middleware.any.ts:85
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:158
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:177
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:112
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:226
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:90
(anonime) @ middleware.any.ts:35
(anonime) @ middleware.any.ts:38
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:99
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:65
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:18
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:10
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:74
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:174
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:13
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:73
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:61
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:9
(anonime) @ middleware.tsx:12
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:12
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:135
(anonime) @ middleware.tsx:17
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:37
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:56
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:99
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:20
(anonime) @ middleware.any.ts:45
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:16
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:35
(anonime) @ middleware.any.ts:118
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:152
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:22
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:14
(anonime) @ middleware.any.ts:23
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:43
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:245
dispatch @ redux.js:636Comprendi l'errore
chrome-extension://invalid/:1  GET chrome-extension://invalid/ net::ERR_FAILED
Image
(anonime) @ checkChromeExtensionsInstalled.web.ts:11
(anonime) @ checkChromeExtensionsInstalled.web.ts:9
(anonime) @ checkChromeExtensionsInstalled.web.ts:20
(anonime) @ checkChromeExtensionsInstalled.web.ts:21
fO @ checkChromeExtensionsInstalled.web.ts:21
componentDidUpdate @ ChromeExtensionBanner.web.tsx:71
wl @ react-dom.production.min.js:261
vl @ react-dom.production.min.js:260
yl @ react-dom.production.min.js:259
(anonime) @ react-dom.production.min.js:283
kc @ react-dom.production.min.js:281
lc @ react-dom.production.min.js:273
qa @ react-dom.production.min.js:127
cc @ react-dom.production.min.js:274
(anonime) @ middleware.any.ts:85
_listener @ StateListenerRegistry.ts:31
p @ redux.js:220
(anonime) @ index.js:20
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:20
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:193
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:19
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:14
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:23
(anonime) @ middleware.any.ts:40
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:21
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:77
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:60
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:72
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:43
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:52
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:28
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:155
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:7
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:37
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:22
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:66
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:50
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:35
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:19
(anonime) @ middleware.any.ts:52
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:60
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:273
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:48
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:21
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:11
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:18
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:31
(anonime) @ middleware.any.ts:39
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:41
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:117
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:26
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:132
(anonime) @ middleware.any.ts:73
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:27
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:17
(anonime) @ middleware.any.ts:24
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:18
(anonime) @ middleware.any.ts:18
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:32
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:16
Jae @ middleware.ts:560
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:232
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:15
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:42
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:30
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:63
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:8
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:53
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:50
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:176
(anonime) @ middleware.any.ts:606
(anonime) @ middleware.any.ts:72
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:158
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:177
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:112
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:226
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:90
(anonime) @ middleware.any.ts:35
(anonime) @ middleware.any.ts:38
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:99
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:65
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:18
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:10
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:74
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:174
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:13
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:73
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:61
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:9
(anonime) @ middleware.tsx:12
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:12
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:114
(anonime) @ middleware.tsx:17
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:37
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:56
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:99
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:20
(anonime) @ middleware.any.ts:45
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:16
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:35
(anonime) @ middleware.any.ts:118
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:152
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:22
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:14
(anonime) @ middleware.any.ts:23
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:43
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:176
Kae @ middleware.ts:417
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:397
_listener @ StateListenerRegistry.ts:31
p @ redux.js:220
(anonime) @ index.js:20
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:20
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:193
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:19
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:14
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:23
(anonime) @ middleware.any.ts:40
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:21
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:77
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:60
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:72
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:43
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:52
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:28
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:155
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:7
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:37
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:22
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:66
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:50
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:35
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:19
(anonime) @ middleware.any.ts:52
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:60
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:273
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:48
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:21
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:11
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:18
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:31
(anonime) @ middleware.any.ts:39
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:41
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:117
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:26
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:132
(anonime) @ middleware.any.ts:73
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:27
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:17
(anonime) @ middleware.any.ts:24
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:18
(anonime) @ middleware.any.ts:18
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:32
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:16
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:295
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:15
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:42
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:30
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:63
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:8
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:53
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:50
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:176
(anonime) @ middleware.any.ts:85
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:158
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:177
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:112
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:226
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:90
(anonime) @ middleware.any.ts:35
(anonime) @ middleware.any.ts:38
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:99
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:65
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:18
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:10
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:74
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:174
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:13
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:73
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:61
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:9
(anonime) @ middleware.tsx:12
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:12
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:135
(anonime) @ middleware.tsx:17
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:37
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:56
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:99
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:20
(anonime) @ middleware.any.ts:45
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:16
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:35
(anonime) @ middleware.any.ts:118
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:152
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:22
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:14
(anonime) @ middleware.any.ts:23
(anonime) @ middleware.web.ts:43
(anonime) @ middleware.ts:245
dispatch @ redux.js:636Comprendi l'errore
middleware.web.ts:22 2026-02-20T15:12:58.711Z [INFO] [app:base-app] <PressureObserver.<anonymous>>:  Compute pressure state changed: [{"source":"cpu","state":"nominal","ownContributionEstimate":0.10608742314896144,"time":30493.400000035763}]

Reproducibility

• The problem is reproducible on meet.jit.si

More details?

No response

[raghuramala54]

I'd like to work on this. Will submit a PR.

[raghuramala54]

sorry I missed the corner cases which is the state is not being maintained, I will check and address it again in next PR.

[raghuramala54]

Hi @damencho I made the appropriate changes on lib-jitsi-meet and created a PR. I also tested it by linking the lib-jitsi-meet locally and tested with my new changes to lib-jitsi-meet.

jitsi/lib-jitsi-meet#2990

Could you please review it for me.