Skip to content

Commit 1408924

Browse files
knilecrackclaude
andcommitted
Add test analysis documentation and editor configuration
- Add comprehensive test_summary.md documenting all 22 test failures - Add .editorconfig with Roslynator analyzer settings - Document test status: 97.6% passing (956/979 tests) - Categorize failures by severity and identify root causes - Provide recommendations for fixing priority issues Co-Authored-By: Claude Sonnet 4.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
1 parent be052f5 commit 1408924

File tree

2 files changed

+106
-0
lines changed

2 files changed

+106
-0
lines changed

.editorconfig

Lines changed: 10 additions & 0 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,10 @@
1+
[*.cs]
2+
3+
# RCS1139: Add summary element to documentation comment
4+
dotnet_diagnostic.RCS1139.severity = none
5+
6+
# RCS1044: Remove original exception from throw statement
7+
dotnet_diagnostic.RCS1044.severity = none
8+
9+
# RCS1102: Make class static
10+
dotnet_diagnostic.RCS1102.severity = suggestion

OpenXmlPowerTools/test_summary.md

Lines changed: 96 additions & 0 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,96 @@
1+
# Test Results Summary
2+
3+
## Overall Status
4+
- **Total Tests:** 979
5+
- **Passed:** 956 (97.6%)
6+
- **Failed:** 22 (2.2%)
7+
- **Skipped:** 1 (0.1%)
8+
9+
## Test Failures by Category
10+
11+
### 1. PowerToolsBlockExtensionsTests (1 failure)
12+
**Test:** `MustEndPowerToolsBlockToUseStronglyTypedClasses`
13+
**Error:** Assert.Single() failure - collection contained 2 items instead of 1
14+
**Severity:** Low - appears to be a test assertion issue
15+
16+
### 2. Excel Currency Formatting - CfTests (7 failures)
17+
**Issue:** Currency symbols have extra "-" prefix
18+
- Expected: "₩ -" → Actual: "-₩ -"
19+
- Expected: "£ -" → Actual: "-£ -"
20+
- Expected: "¥ -" → Actual: "-¥ -"
21+
- Expected: "€ -" → Actual: "-€ -"
22+
- Expected: "CHF -" → Actual: "-CHF -"
23+
- Expected: "$ -" → Actual: "-$ -"
24+
25+
**Severity:** Medium - Excel number formatting inconsistency
26+
27+
### 3. SpreadsheetWriter Tests (1 failure)
28+
**Test:** `SW002_AllDataTypes`
29+
**Error:** Cell validation errors for date values ('2012-01-09T00:00', '2012-01-08T00:00')
30+
**Severity:** Medium - date formatting validation issue
31+
32+
### 4. PresentationBuilder Tests (1 failure)
33+
**Test:** `PB006_VideoFormats`
34+
**Error:** `System.IO.IOException: Entries cannot be opened multiple times in Update mode`
35+
**Severity:** Medium - PowerPoint package access issue
36+
37+
### 5. DocumentBuilder Tests (1 failure)
38+
**Test:** `DB009_ShredDocument`
39+
**Error:** `System.Xml.XmlException: Data at the root level is invalid. Line 57, position 9`
40+
**Location:** ReferenceAdder.cs:119 in AddToc method
41+
**Severity:** Medium - XML parsing issue in TOC generation
42+
43+
### 6. WmlComparer Tests (11 failures)
44+
Most critical category with multiple types of failures:
45+
46+
#### Type A: Duplicate FontTable Relationship (3 failures)
47+
- WC002_Consolidate_Bulk_Test (RC/RC002-Image.docx)
48+
- WC003_Compare (RC/RC002-Image.docx)
49+
- WC001_Consolidate (RC/RC002-Image.docx)
50+
51+
**Error:** "The package/part 'MainDocumentPart{/word/document.xml}' can only have one instance of relationship that targets part fontTable"
52+
**Severity:** HIGH - package relationship corruption issue
53+
54+
#### Type B: Missing/Wrong Revision Count (6 failures)
55+
- WC-1720: Expected 7, Actual 6
56+
- WC-1710: Expected 7, Actual 6
57+
- WC-1500: Expected 2, Actual 10
58+
- WC-1660: Expected 5, Actual 0
59+
- WC-1670: Expected 5, Actual 0
60+
- WC-1750: Expected 6, Actual 0
61+
- WC-1760: Expected 6, Actual 0
62+
63+
**Severity:** MEDIUM to HIGH - comparison algorithm accuracy issues
64+
65+
#### Type C: Invalid PackageRelationship (1 failure)
66+
- WC-1240: "PackageRelationship with specified ID does not exist for the source part"
67+
**Error location:** WmlComparer.cs:4753 in MoveRelatedPartsToDestination
68+
**Severity:** HIGH - missing relationship handling issue
69+
70+
## Analysis
71+
72+
### Known Issues (from your list):
73+
1.**FIXED:** SplitOnSections body-level w:sectPr - This was addressed in our recent commit
74+
2. ⚠️ **REMAINING:** AdjustSectionBreak removes wrong w:sectPr
75+
3. ⚠️ **REMAINING:** MainDocumentPart/Comments part XDocument mutation
76+
77+
### Newly Identified Issues:
78+
1. **WmlComparer FontTable Duplication** - Multiple relationship instances being created (HIGH priority)
79+
2. **WmlComparer Revision Counting** - Incorrect revision detection in footnote/endnote scenarios
80+
3. **WmlComparer Relationship Handling** - Missing relationships in image comparison scenarios
81+
4. **ReferenceAdder TOC XML** - Invalid XML generation
82+
5. **PresentationBuilder Zip Access** - Concurrent file access issue
83+
6. **Excel Formatting** - Currency/date formatting issues
84+
85+
### Recommendations:
86+
1. **Immediate Priority:** Fix WmlComparer duplicate fontTable relationship issue (affects 3 tests)
87+
2. **High Priority:** Fix AdjustSectionBreak (known issue #2)
88+
3. **High Priority:** Fix XDocument mutation (known issue #3)
89+
4. **Medium Priority:** Address WmlComparer revision counting accuracy
90+
5. **Lower Priority:** Excel formatting and PresentationBuilder issues
91+
92+
## Next Steps
93+
Would you like me to:
94+
1. Investigate the WmlComparer fontTable duplication issue?
95+
2. Fix the second known issue (AdjustSectionBreak)?
96+
3. Analyze a specific test failure category?

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)