SQL Feature Review: Comprehensive Analysis and Prioritized Recommendations for Opteryx

REVIEW_SUMMARY.txt

@@ -0,0 +1,129 @@
+================================================================================
+SQL FEATURE REVIEW SUMMARY FOR OPTERYX
+================================================================================
+
+Review Date: October 15, 2025
+Review Base: sqlparser-rs v0.59.0 Dialect trait
+Reviewer: GitHub Copilot - Code Analysis
+
+================================================================================
+KEY FINDING
+================================================================================
+
+After comprehensive review of sqlparser-rs Dialect trait methods and analysis
+of Opteryx's current implementation, the conclusion is:
+
+🎯 OPTERYX ALREADY HAS A SOLID SQL LANGUAGE BASE
+
+Only 5 additional features are recommended (listed below), as Opteryx already
+supports most common SQL operations needed for analytical queries.
+
+================================================================================
+CURRENT OPTERYX CAPABILITIES (Already Supported)
+================================================================================
+
+✅ Core DML: SELECT, FROM, WHERE, GROUP BY, ORDER BY, LIMIT
+✅ Joins: INNER, LEFT, RIGHT, CROSS
+✅ Set Operations: UNION, INTERSECT, EXCEPT  
+✅ Subqueries & CTEs: Subqueries in FROM, WITH clauses
+✅ Aggregations: Functions with FILTER clause
+✅ Modern Features:
+   - Array operations (@>, @>>)
+   - SELECT * EXCEPT (column)
+   - PartiQL subscripting (field['key'])
+   - Numeric underscores (10_000_000)
+   - MATCH() AGAINST() text search
+   - Custom operators (DIV)
+
+================================================================================
+TOP 5 RECOMMENDED ADDITIONS (Prioritized)
+================================================================================
+
+1. WINDOW FUNCTIONS WITH NAMED WINDOW REFERENCES ⭐⭐⭐
+   Dialect: supports_window_clause_named_window_reference
+   Impact: MEDIUM
+   Value: High - Critical for analytics (ROW_NUMBER, LAG, LEAD, etc.)
+   Example: SELECT *, ROW_NUMBER() OVER w1 FROM t WINDOW w1 AS (...)
+
+2. LAMBDA FUNCTIONS (Higher-Order Functions) ⭐⭐⭐
+   Dialect: supports_lambda_functions  
+   Impact: HIGH
+   Value: High - Array transformations without UDFs
+   Example: SELECT TRANSFORM(arr, x -> x * 2) FROM table
+
+3. DICTIONARY/MAP LITERAL SYNTAX ⭐⭐
+   Dialect: supports_dictionary_syntax OR support_map_literal_syntax
+   Impact: MEDIUM
+   Value: Medium - Complements struct/JSON support
+   Example: SELECT {'key': 'value', 'num': 123} AS config
+
+4. GROUP BY ENHANCEMENTS (ROLLUP, CUBE, GROUPING SETS) ⭐⭐
+   Dialect: supports_group_by_expr, supports_order_by_all
+   Impact: MEDIUM-HIGH
+   Value: Medium - OLAP operations for hierarchical aggregations
+   Example: SELECT region, SUM(sales) FROM t GROUP BY ROLLUP(region)
+
+5. IN () EMPTY LIST SUPPORT ⭐
+   Dialect: supports_in_empty_list
+   Impact: LOW
+   Value: Medium - Handles edge cases in dynamic queries
+   Example: SELECT * FROM t WHERE col IN () -- Returns empty set
+
+================================================================================
+IMPLEMENTATION ROADMAP
+================================================================================
+
+Phase 1: Quick Win
+  → IN () Empty List Support (1-2 days)
+
+Phase 2: Core Analytics  
+  → Named Window References (1-2 weeks)
+  → Dictionary/Map Literals (2-3 weeks)
+
+Phase 3: Advanced Features
+  → GROUP BY Enhancements (3-4 weeks)
+  → Lambda Functions (4-6 weeks)
+
+================================================================================
+FEATURES NOT RECOMMENDED
+================================================================================
+
+❌ supports_connect_by - Hierarchical queries (niche)
+❌ supports_match_recognize - Pattern matching (too complex)
+❌ supports_outer_join_operator - Oracle (+) syntax (legacy)
+❌ supports_execute_immediate - Dynamic SQL (security risk)
+❌ supports_dollar_placeholder - $1 style params (prefer named)
+❌ Most vendor-specific syntaxes (Opteryx targets portable SQL)
+
+================================================================================
+DELIVERABLES CREATED
+================================================================================
+
+1. src/opteryx_dialect.rs
+   - Added 149 lines of inline documentation
+   - Detailed rationale for each recommendation
+   - Implementation impact assessments
+
+2. SQL_FEATURE_RECOMMENDATIONS.md  
+   - 306-line comprehensive reference document
+   - SQL examples for each feature
+   - Use cases and implementation roadmap
+   - Testing strategy
+
+3. This summary document (REVIEW_SUMMARY.txt)
+
+================================================================================
+CONCLUSION
+================================================================================
+
+Opteryx has a mature SQL implementation suitable for analytical workloads.
+The 5 recommended features would enhance capabilities without overwhelming
+complexity. Priority should be given to Window Functions (Priority 1) and
+Lambda Functions (Priority 2) as these deliver the highest value for
+analytical use cases.
+
+The small number of recommendations (5 vs potential 80+ dialect methods)
+validates that Opteryx's language design is already well-aligned with
+modern analytical SQL requirements.
+
+================================================================================