Skip to content

Commit 9daee60

Browse files
committed
feat(test): add E2E testing infrastructure with test mode authentication bypass
- Add Test Mode for authentication bypass in E2E testing and development - Implement TestModeAuthenticationHandler and TestModeAuthenticationMiddleware - Add TestModeOptions configuration class - Update Program.cs to conditionally register GitHub OAuth based on test mode - Update AuthorizationService to bypass team membership checks in test mode - Implement E2E testing framework with Playwright - Create 10xGitHubPolicies.Tests.E2E project with dual-host architecture - Add Page Object Model with DashboardPage for maintainable tests - Implement test data management utilities (RepositoryHelper, DatabaseHelper) - Add workflow tests covering complete policy enforcement scenarios - Extend GitHubService with 9 E2E testing methods - Repository operations: CreateRepositoryAsync, DeleteRepositoryAsync, UnarchiveRepositoryAsync - File operations: CreateFileAsync, UpdateFileAsync, DeleteFileAsync (2 overloads) - Issue operations: CloseIssueAsync, GetRepositoryIssuesAsync - Workflow operations: UpdateWorkflowPermissionsAsync - Add comprehensive test coverage - Contract tests: FileCrudContractTests, RepositoryCrudContractTests - Integration tests: FileCrudOperationsTests, IssueManagementTests, RepositoryCrudOperationsTests - Enhanced GitHubApiResponseBuilder for test data creation - Update documentation - Add docs/testing-e2e-tests.md with complete E2E testing guide - Update testing-strategy.md with E2E testing section - Update github-integration.md with new E2E testing methods - Update README.md with Test Mode configuration and E2E testing sections - Update CHANGELOG.md with version 1.4 details - Clean up - Remove obsolete plan file (.cursor/plans/githubservice-integration-contract-f95b8e0c.plan.md) - Update .gitignore to exclude TestResults directory - Update solution file to include new test projects
1 parent dfd7dba commit 9daee60

File tree

50 files changed

+5943
-1668
lines changed

Some content is hidden

Large Commits have some content hidden by default. Use the searchbox below for content that may be hidden.

50 files changed

+5943
-1668
lines changed
Lines changed: 173 additions & 0 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,173 @@
1+
# E2E Testing Implementation Plan
2+
3+
## Overview
4+
5+
This plan outlines the implementation of End-to-End (E2E) testing infrastructure for the 10x GitHub Policy Enforcer using Playwright with .NET. The implementation follows a phased approach, focusing on what needs to be accomplished rather than detailed implementation steps.
6+
7+
## ✅ Completed Phases
8+
9+
### Phase 1: E2E Test Project Setup ✅
10+
**Status: COMPLETED**
11+
12+
- Created E2E test project `10xGitHubPolicies.Tests.E2E`
13+
- Added required NuGet packages (Playwright, NUnit, EF Core, FluentAssertions)
14+
- Configured project references to main application
15+
- Set up Playwright browser installation
16+
- Added to solution file
17+
18+
### Phase 2: Test Infrastructure Classes ✅
19+
**Status: COMPLETED**
20+
21+
- **E2ETestBase**: Base class inheriting from `PageTest` with proper service configuration
22+
- **TestDataManager**: Service for creating test repositories with various compliance states
23+
- **TestCleanupService**: Service for cleaning up test data from database and GitHub
24+
- **GitHubService Extensions**: Extended GitHub service with E2E-specific methods
25+
26+
### Phase 3: Page Object Models ✅
27+
**Status: COMPLETED**
28+
29+
- **DashboardPage**: Page object model for dashboard interactions
30+
- Methods for navigation, scanning, violation counting, filtering
31+
- Proper Playwright integration with async/await patterns
32+
33+
### Phase 4: Basic E2E Tests ✅
34+
**Status: COMPLETED**
35+
36+
- **CompleteE2EWorkflowTests**: Comprehensive test covering:
37+
- Test repository creation (compliant and non-compliant)
38+
- URL accessibility testing (authenticated vs unauthenticated)
39+
- Database connectivity verification
40+
- GitHub API integration testing
41+
- Complete cleanup verification
42+
43+
### Phase 5: Configuration and Setup ✅
44+
**Status: COMPLETED**
45+
46+
- **Playwright Configuration**: `playwright.config.ts` with proper browser setup
47+
- **User Secrets Integration**: E2E tests use same GitHub App configuration as main app
48+
- **Service Registration**: Proper DI container setup with all required services
49+
- **Test Execution**: Successfully running against live application
50+
51+
## 🎯 Current Status
52+
53+
The E2E testing infrastructure is **FUNCTIONAL** and successfully:
54+
55+
1. ✅ Creates test repositories on GitHub
56+
2. ✅ Tests web application URLs (authenticated/unauthenticated)
57+
3. ✅ Verifies database connectivity
58+
4. ✅ Tests GitHub API integration
59+
5. ✅ Performs complete cleanup of test data
60+
6. ✅ Runs against live application instance
61+
62+
## 📋 Remaining Tasks
63+
64+
### Phase 6: Application Authentication Bypass
65+
**Status: PENDING**
66+
67+
**What to accomplish:**
68+
- Refactor application to support test mode without authentication
69+
- Configure application to bypass OAuth for E2E testing
70+
- Ensure all dashboard functionality works without user authentication
71+
- Set up test mode configuration and environment detection
72+
73+
**Key requirements:**
74+
- Add test mode configuration option
75+
- Bypass authentication middleware in test mode
76+
- Ensure all services work without authenticated user context
77+
- Configure application to run in test mode for E2E testing
78+
79+
### Phase 7: Enhanced E2E Scenarios
80+
**Status: PENDING**
81+
82+
**What to accomplish:**
83+
- Implement authenticated user workflow testing (now possible without OAuth)
84+
- Add policy violation detection and action verification
85+
- Create repository scanning workflow tests
86+
- Add dashboard interaction tests with real data
87+
88+
**Key scenarios to test:**
89+
- Complete scan workflow from dashboard trigger to results
90+
- Policy violation creation and GitHub action execution
91+
- Repository compliance status updates
92+
- Dashboard interactions without authentication barriers
93+
94+
## 🏗️ Architecture Overview
95+
96+
### Test Structure
97+
```
98+
10xGitHubPolicies.Tests.E2E/
99+
├── E2ETestBase.cs # Base test class with service setup
100+
├── TestDataManager.cs # Test repository creation/management
101+
├── TestCleanupService.cs # Test data cleanup
102+
├── CompleteE2EWorkflowTests.cs # Main E2E workflow tests
103+
├── WorkflowTests.cs # Additional workflow scenarios
104+
├── Pages/
105+
│ └── DashboardPage.cs # Page object model
106+
└── playwright.config.ts # Playwright configuration
107+
```
108+
109+
### Service Integration
110+
- **GitHubService**: Extended with E2E-specific methods
111+
- **Database**: Direct EF Core integration for verification
112+
- **Configuration**: User secrets integration for GitHub App
113+
- **Playwright**: Browser automation for UI testing
114+
115+
## 🎯 Success Criteria
116+
117+
### ✅ Achieved
118+
- [x] E2E test project builds and runs successfully
119+
- [x] Test data manager creates and cleans up repositories
120+
- [x] Application URLs are properly tested
121+
- [x] Database connectivity is verified
122+
- [x] GitHub API integration works correctly
123+
- [x] Complete test data cleanup is performed
124+
125+
### 🎯 Remaining Goals
126+
- [ ] Application authentication bypass implementation
127+
- [ ] Test mode configuration and setup
128+
- [ ] Authenticated user workflow testing (without authentication)
129+
- [ ] Policy violation detection and action verification
130+
- [ ] Complete scan workflow testing
131+
- [ ] Dashboard interaction testing
132+
133+
## 📊 Test Coverage Areas
134+
135+
### ✅ Covered
136+
- **Infrastructure**: Service setup, configuration, connectivity
137+
- **GitHub Integration**: Repository creation, file operations, cleanup
138+
- **Web Application**: URL accessibility, basic navigation
139+
- **Database**: Connection verification, data cleanup
140+
141+
### 🎯 To Be Covered
142+
- **Application Configuration**: Test mode setup and authentication bypass
143+
- **User Workflows**: Dashboard interactions without authentication
144+
- **Policy Enforcement**: Violation detection, action execution
145+
- **Scanning Process**: Complete scan workflow, result verification
146+
- **Test Mode Operations**: Application behavior without OAuth
147+
148+
## 🔧 Technical Implementation Notes
149+
150+
### Key Design Decisions
151+
1. **Real GitHub Integration**: Tests use actual GitHub API, not mocks
152+
2. **User Secrets**: E2E tests share GitHub App configuration with main app
153+
3. **Service Reuse**: Extended existing GitHubService rather than creating test-specific services
154+
4. **Comprehensive Cleanup**: Both database and GitHub data are cleaned up
155+
5. **Live Application Testing**: Tests run against actual running application
156+
6. **No Authentication**: Application runs in test mode without OAuth requirements
157+
158+
### Configuration Requirements
159+
- GitHub App with required permissions
160+
- Database connection string
161+
- User secrets properly configured
162+
- Application running on https://localhost:7040
163+
- Application configured to run without authentication for E2E testing
164+
165+
## 🚀 Next Steps
166+
167+
1. **Refactor application for test mode** - Implement authentication bypass for E2E testing
168+
2. **Configure test mode environment** - Set up application configuration for test mode
169+
3. **Implement dashboard workflow testing** - Test authenticated workflows without OAuth
170+
4. **Create policy violation scenarios** - Test the complete policy enforcement workflow
171+
5. **Add scanning workflow tests** - Test complete scan process from trigger to results
172+
173+
The foundation is solid and functional. The next critical step is refactoring the application to support test mode without authentication, which will enable comprehensive E2E testing of all dashboard functionality.
File renamed without changes.

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)