Skip to content

VERIFY.md

Latest commit

 

History

History
197 lines (135 loc) · 8.99 KB

VERIFY.md

File metadata and controls

197 lines (135 loc) · 8.99 KB

Verification Log

t1274 Verification — Resolve t1200 Merge Conflict

Status: RESOLVED — No conflict exists; t1200 deliverables fully merged

Investigation findings:

t1200 (IP reputation check agent) was broken into 6 subtasks, all of which merged successfully:

Subtask PR Status
t1200.1 Core orchestrator + free-tier providers #1856 MERGED
t1200.2 Keyed providers + SQLite cache + batch mode #1860 MERGED
t1200.3 Agent doc + slash command + index updates #1867 MERGED
t1200.4 Core IP reputation lookup module #1871 MERGED
t1200.5 CLI and agent framework integration #1883 MERGED
t1200.6 Output formatting, caching layer, rate limit handling #1911 MERGED

Deliverables verified on main:

  • .agents/scripts/ip-reputation-helper.sh — present
  • .agents/tools/security/ip-reputation.md — present

Root cause of t1274 dispatch: The supervisor recorded blocked:merge_conflict for the parent t1200 task. This was a false alarm — the parent branch (feature/t1200) had no divergent commits (it was at the same SHA as origin/main). All feature work was implemented via subtask branches. The parent t1200 task simply needs to be marked [x] complete by the supervisor since all subtasks have pr: proof-log entries.

Action taken: No code changes needed. This PR serves as the proof-log entry for t1274. The supervisor should mark t1200 complete based on all subtasks being [x] with merged PRs.

Proof-Log

t1274 verified:2026-02-20 pr:#2020

t1255 Verification — Cross-Repo Dispatch Investigation (Duplicate of t1253)

Status: DUPLICATE — closed, covered by t1253 / PR #1959

t1255 requested investigation of 15 webapp subtasks not being dispatched, with 3 verification points: (1) supervisor pulse scans all registered repos, (2) webapp tasks have correct repo path in supervisor DB, (3) cross-repo concurrency fairness (t1188.2) is functioning.

All 3 points were fully investigated and resolved by t1253 (merged PR #1959, 2026-02-19T11:11:21Z).

Root Cause (from t1253)

cmd_next in state.sh:1004-1017 filtered subtasks whose earlier siblings were "still active" using status NOT IN ('verified','cancelled','deployed','complete'). This omitted failed and blocked — both terminal states for sibling ordering purposes:

  • t007.1 was failed (3/3 retries exhausted), blocking t007.2-t007.8
  • t004.2 and t005.1 were blocked, preventing t004.3-t004.5 and t005.2-t005.6

Fix: Added 'failed' and 'blocked' to the NOT IN terminal states list in the sibling ordering SQL query (consistent with todo-sync.sh:1443 which already included both).

t1255 Verification Points — All Confirmed by t1253

Verification Point Finding
Supervisor pulse scans all registered repos TRUE — pulse scans all repos; issue was upstream in sibling filter
webapp tasks have correct repo path in supervisor DB TRUE — all 15 subtasks were in batch-20260218143815-69271
Cross-repo concurrency fairness (t1188.2) functioning TRUE — fairness logic in cmd_next is correct; sibling filter eliminated all webapp candidates before fairness ran

Other Hypotheses Ruled Out

  1. webapp tasks not in supervisor batch — FALSE
  2. Cross-repo fairness not routing to webapp — FALSE
  3. Parent task @marcus assignee blocking subtask dispatch — FALSE (cmd_auto_pickup checks subtask's own line, not parent's)
  4. Subtasks lack #auto-dispatch tags — FALSE (all subtasks had #auto-dispatch and were queued in supervisor DB)

Closes #1960

t1181 Verification — Action-Target Cooldown (Superseded by t1179)

Status: COMPLETE (superseded)

t1181 requested a cooldown mechanism to prevent the supervisor from acting on the same target within N cycles when the target's state hasn't changed. This requirement is fully satisfied by t1179 (cycle-aware dedup), which was merged in PR #1779.

Evidence

t1179 delivers every capability t1181 specified:

t1181 Requirement t1179 Implementation Location
last_acted map in supervisor DB state_hash column in action_dedup_log database.sh:153
Compute target state fingerprint _compute_target_state_hash() ai-actions.sh:103-199
Skip if same (target, action_type) with no state change _is_duplicate_action() cycle-aware check ai-actions.sh:278-311
Allow action if state changed State hash comparison, return 1 if changed ai-actions.sh:300-303
Configurable window AI_ACTION_DEDUP_WINDOW (default 5 cycles) ai-actions.sh:33
Stats/reporting dedup-stats subcommand with state change tracking ai-actions.sh:1774-1833

Why a separate cooldown layer is unnecessary

t1181 proposed a "third safety net" with a 2-cycle window alongside the 5-cycle dedup window. Since the dedup window (5 cycles) is a superset of the cooldown window (2 cycles), any action suppressed by a 2-cycle cooldown would already be suppressed by the 5-cycle dedup. The cycle-aware dedup IS the cooldown mechanism — it just uses a single, wider window instead of two overlapping windows.

ShellCheck verification

ai-actions.sh: 0 errors, 0 warnings (5 info-level SC2016/SC1091 — intentional)
database.sh: 0 errors, 0 warnings, 0 info

Conclusion

VERIFY_COMPLETE — t1179 (PR #1779) fully satisfies the t1181 requirement. No additional code changes needed. The prior t1181 branch commits (3 commits on origin/feature/t1181) are superseded and should not be merged.

t1081 Verification — Daily Skill Auto-Update Pipeline

Status: COMPLETE

All 4 subtasks verified with merged PRs. Parent task t1081 is fully satisfied.

Subtask Verification

Subtask Description PR Merged Files Changed
t1081.1 Add daily skill check to auto-update-helper.sh cmd_check() #1591 2026-02-17 23:57 UTC auto-update-helper.sh (+488/-339)
t1081.2 Add --non-interactive support to skill-update-helper.sh #1630 2026-02-18 03:21 UTC skill-update-helper.sh (+106/-27)
t1081.3 Update auto-update state file schema #1638 2026-02-18 03:28 UTC auto-update-helper.sh (+23/-8)
t1081.4 Update AGENTS.md and auto-update docs #1639 2026-02-18 03:37 UTC AGENTS.md (+7/-1)

Requirements Coverage

Requirement Delivered By Verified
24h freshness gate in auto-update-helper.sh t1081.1 (#1591) Yes — check_skill_freshness() with configurable AIDEVOPS_SKILL_FRESHNESS_HOURS
Call skill-update-helper.sh --auto-update --quiet t1081.1 (#1591) Yes — called in cmd_check() after version check
--auto-update and --quiet flags in skill-update-helper.sh t1081.2 (#1630) Yes — plus --non-interactive for full headless support
State file: last_skill_check, skill_updates_applied t1081.3 (#1638) Yes — in auto-update-state.json, displayed in cmd_status()
Documentation updated t1081.4 (#1639) Yes — AGENTS.md documents daily skill refresh and repo version wins

Integration Assessment

No additional integration work needed. The subtasks collectively deliver:

  • Layer 1 (t1081): Users get fresh skill docs locally within 24h via cron auto-update
  • Opt-out: AIDEVOPS_SKILL_AUTO_UPDATE=false
  • Configurable frequency: AIDEVOPS_SKILL_FRESHNESS_HOURS=<hours>

Unblocks

  • t1082: Maintainer skill-update PR pipeline (blocked-by:t1081)

Proof-Log

t1081 verified:2026-02-18 pr:#1591,#1630,#1638,#1639

t1276 Verification — Subtask-aware queue analysis and orphan issue intake

Status: COMPLETE — All deliverables merged in PR #2026

Root Cause (Strategy 4 head -50 bug):

cmd_auto_pickup() Strategy 4 collected parent IDs with head -50 | sort -u. With 242 #auto-dispatch parents in TODO.md (mostly completed), open parents with subtasks (t1120, t1264) were beyond position 50 and never processed. Their subtasks (t1120.1, t1120.2, t1120.4, t1264.2) were invisible to the dispatcher despite the parent having #auto-dispatch.

Deliverables:

Deliverable File PR Status
Fix Strategy 4 head -50 limit .agents/scripts/supervisor/cron.sh #2026 MERGED
Subtask-aware runners-check queue depth .agents/scripts/commands/runners-check.md #2026 MERGED
3 orphan issue TODO entries (t1277-t1279) TODO.md #2026 MERGED
3 stale GH issues closed (GH#1970, #1973, #2014) TODO.md (pr: refs added) #2026 MERGED

Fix verification:

  • cron.sh Strategy 4 now uses grep -oE 't[0-9]+' | sort -u with no head limit
  • Comment at line 764 documents the previous bug and fix
  • runners-check.md reports: total open (parents + subtasks), dispatchable (tagged + inherited), blocked, claimed

Stale GH issues closed:

Issue Task State
GH#1970 t1260: Fix setup.sh launchd schedulers CLOSED
GH#1973 t1261: Fix dispatch stall CLOSED
GH#2014 t1273: Supervisor sanity-check CLOSED

Proof-Log

t1276 verified:2026-02-21 pr:#2026