Removing netmasks in web ui from individual IP addresses #14900
artiomello
started this conversation in
Ideas
Replies: 0 comments
Sign up for free
to join this conversation on GitHub.
Already have an account?
Sign in to comment
Uh oh!
There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.
Uh oh!
There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.
-
Hi,
As suggested by @jeffgdotorg, initiating a discussion regarding a FR #14654.
As mentioned in the original FR, my suggestion is to remove netmasks from individual IPs in the WEB UI, perhaps using a toggle in the settings.
The reasoning for that is, (I'm assuming) unless you're working with network equipment specifically, you're not going to use a netmask when designating an IP address. Now, I'm not a network engineer, so that world is pretty much obscure to me, but coming from a system/infrastructure administration point of view - the only time I would use a netmask next to an IP address is to define a subnet/prefix, not an individual address. And every single time I do see a IP/netmask pair out of the context - I immediately see it as a such and have to use an IP calculator to double check if it's a network or an actual IP address that I'm looking at.
From that perspective, having every single IP address with a mask, especially when looking at the IP Address section for a specific prefix - I already have the prefix/subnet information at the top of the page. To me it's completely redundant. And for less IT savvy people (e.g. service desk using it as a plain IPAM tool) - even less so, as it might add an unnecessary confusion.
Here are my answers to your questions from the comments in FR:
Which tools do you use that omit masks when listing individual IP addresses?
As far as I can remember, not a single one I've used during the past 6 years have required me to define an individual IP using a CIDR notation, perhaps with the exception of configuring IPs in Ubuntu Linux. But even there, I believe, it depends on how you do it. Also, we're deploying VMs using Ansible and even there a mask is a separate property.
What kinds of tasks occupy you during your workday?
Administration of VMware clusters, Windows Servers, Azure, O365, automated deployment of VMs, some Linux and a few other systems here and there.
Hope that helps.
Beta Was this translation helpful? Give feedback.
All reactions