Skip to content

Commit 8f24686

Browse files
committed
feat: Update TODO documentation for Phase 10.5 completion, resolve NuGet package API exposure issues, and confirm extension method functionality
1 parent 6b6d40b commit 8f24686

File tree

1 file changed

+80
-12
lines changed

1 file changed

+80
-12
lines changed

doc/todo.md

Lines changed: 80 additions & 12 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -66,9 +66,11 @@ The NLWebNet library is now fully functional and feature complete with a modern
6666
-**Testing Framework**: Using MSTest 3.9.3 with NSubstitute 5.3.0 for comprehensive unit testing
6767
-**Production Ready**: All builds (Debug/Release) work correctly, with properly configured NuGet packaging
6868

69-
**Phases 1-9 are now complete.** The library provides a complete implementation of the NLWeb protocol with both traditional controller-based endpoints (legacy) and modern minimal API endpoints for improved performance and maintainability. The project includes comprehensive configuration management, CORS support, and extensive testing infrastructure with manual testing resources.
69+
**Phases 1-10.5 are now complete.** The library provides a complete implementation of the NLWeb protocol with both traditional controller-based endpoints (legacy) and modern minimal API endpoints for improved performance and maintainability. The project includes comprehensive configuration management, CORS support, and extensive testing infrastructure with manual testing resources.
7070

71-
**The project is ready for Phase 10 (Documentation & Packaging) and Phase 11 (Deployment & Production Readiness)** with a fully functional demonstration application running at `http://localhost:5037` and comprehensive configuration and testing infrastructure.
71+
**✅ MAJOR BREAKTHROUGH: NuGet Package API Issue RESOLVED** - The NLWebNet package is now fully functional with working extension methods accessible via `using NLWebNet;`. End-to-end testing confirms that consumer applications can successfully install the package, use the `AddNLWebNet()` and `MapNLWebNet()` extension methods, and run working HTTP servers.
72+
73+
**The project is ready for Phase 11 (Deployment & Production Readiness) and NuGet.org publication** with a fully functional demonstration application running at `http://localhost:5037`, a working NuGet package with confirmed extension method accessibility, and comprehensive configuration and testing infrastructure.
7274

7375
## Implementation Plan
7476

@@ -409,10 +411,10 @@ Comprehensive testing and validation infrastructure has been implemented coverin
409411
- [x] Configure package metadata in project file
410412
- [x] Update package metadata for production (repository URL, version, description, tags)
411413
- [x] Test package creation locally - package builds successfully
412-
- [x] Identify API surface area issue - Extensions namespace not exposed correctly in package
413-
- [ ] Fix package API exposure (Extensions namespace visibility)
414-
- [ ] Complete local package installation testing
415-
- [ ] Publish to NuGet.org (delayed to later phase)
414+
- [x] **RESOLVED**: API surface area issue - Extensions accessible via `using NLWebNet;`
415+
- [x]**COMPLETED**: Package API exposure working correctly
416+
- [x]**SUCCESS**: Complete local package installation testing with working extension methods
417+
- [ ] Publish to NuGet.org (ready for publication)
416418

417419
#### Technical Findings
418420

@@ -422,20 +424,86 @@ Comprehensive testing and validation infrastructure has been implemented coverin
422424
- ✅ Package includes README.md, symbols (.snupkg), and proper NuGet metadata
423425
- ✅ Only minor warning about prerelease dependency on ModelContextProtocol package
424426

425-
**API Surface Area Issue Identified:**
427+
**✅ API Surface Area RESOLVED:**
428+
429+
-**Extensions accessible**: Use `using NLWebNet;` (standard Microsoft pattern)
430+
-**`AddNLWebNet()` extension method**: ✅ WORKING - discoverable and functional
431+
-**`MapNLWebNet()` extension method**: ✅ WORKING - discoverable and functional
432+
-**Core library**: All models and services accessible and functional
433+
-**Package structure**: Follows Microsoft.Extensions.* best practices
434+
-**Prerelease versioning**: Now properly marked as 1.0.0-beta.1 due to MCP dependency
426435

427-
- ❌ Extensions namespace (`NLWebNet.Extensions`) not accessible from consuming projects
428-
-`AddNLWebNet()` and `MapNLWebNet()` extension methods not discoverable
429-
- ✅ Core library (models, services) likely accessible but not tested yet
430-
- 📋 **Root Cause**: Potential issue with public API exposure or package content inclusion
436+
**✅ End-to-End Validation COMPLETE:**
431437

432-
**Next Steps (for future phases):**
438+
- ✅ Package installs successfully in consumer projects
439+
- ✅ Extension methods work with IntelliSense and compilation
440+
- ✅ Test consumer application builds and runs successfully
441+
- ✅ All functionality verified: service registration, endpoint mapping, HTTP server startup
442+
443+
**Ready for Phase 11:**
433444

434445
1. Debug package content to ensure Extensions namespace is properly included
435446
2. Verify all public APIs are accessible from package consumers
436447
3. Complete end-to-end package testing with working extension methods
437448
4. Resolve prerelease dependency warning if needed for production release
438449

450+
### Phase 10.5: API Exposure Investigation & Fix ✅
451+
452+
#### Status: **COMPLETED SUCCESSFULLY**
453+
454+
- [x] **Root Cause Analysis**:
455+
- [x] Examined package contents (.nupkg) and verified namespace inclusion
456+
- [x] Reviewed project file settings for public API exposure
457+
- [x] Validated assembly metadata and namespace declarations
458+
- [x] **Root Cause Identified**: Extension classes compiled to base `NLWebNet` namespace, not `NLWebNet.Extensions`
459+
- [x] **Extension Method Accessibility**:
460+
- [x]**FIXED**: `AddNLWebNet()` extension method is now discoverable and functional
461+
- [x]**FIXED**: `MapNLWebNet()` extension method is now discoverable and functional
462+
- [x] Confirmed extension method visibility modifiers and namespace structure are correct
463+
- [x] Validated with .NET 9 target framework
464+
- [x] **Package Content Verification**:
465+
- [x] Extracted and inspected .nupkg contents - all files/namespaces present
466+
- [x] Verified all required assemblies are included in package
467+
- [x] Checked package dependencies and assembly references - all correct
468+
- [x] Reviewed MSBuild output - only minor prerelease dependency warning
469+
- [x] **Fix Implementation**:
470+
- [x]**SOLUTION**: Use `using NLWebNet;` instead of `using NLWebNet.Extensions;`
471+
- [x] Applied Microsoft.NET.Sdk with FrameworkReference pattern (best practice)
472+
- [x] Cleaned up redundant package references
473+
- [x] Rebuilt and tested package locally - **SUCCESS**
474+
- [x]**VERIFIED**: Extension methods work perfectly in test consumer project
475+
- [x] **End-to-End Validation**:
476+
- [x]**COMPLETED**: Successful package installation test
477+
- [x]**VERIFIED**: All public APIs are accessible (core library + extensions)
478+
- [x]**CONFIRMED**: Extension method IntelliSense and compilation working
479+
- [x]**VALIDATED**: Minimal API endpoint registration works correctly
480+
- [x]**SUCCESS**: Test application runs on <http://localhost:5000>
481+
482+
#### **BREAKTHROUGH FINDINGS**
483+
484+
**✅ Extension Methods Working**: The NLWebNet package correctly exposes extension methods, but they are accessible via `using NLWebNet;` rather than `using NLWebNet.Extensions;`. This is actually the **correct and standard pattern** used by Microsoft.Extensions.* libraries.
485+
486+
**✅ Package Structure Validated**: The package includes all necessary components:
487+
488+
- Core models and services in `NLWebNet` namespace
489+
- Extension methods accessible from base namespace
490+
- All dependencies properly resolved
491+
- Framework references correctly configured
492+
493+
**✅ Consumer Integration Success**: Test consumer project successfully:
494+
495+
- Installs NLWebNet package from local source
496+
- Builds without errors using `using NLWebNet;`
497+
- Extension methods `AddNLWebNet()` and `MapNLWebNet()` work correctly
498+
- Application starts and runs successfully
499+
- [ ] Verify all public APIs are accessible (core library + extensions)
500+
- [ ] Test extension method IntelliSense and compilation
501+
- [ ] Validate minimal API endpoint registration works correctly
502+
- [ ] **Production Readiness**:
503+
- [x]**RESOLVED**: ModelContextProtocol prerelease dependency - NLWebNet marked as 1.0.0-beta.1
504+
- [ ] Final package validation before publication
505+
- [ ] Update documentation with confirmed usage patterns
506+
439507
### Phase 11: Deployment & Production Readiness
440508

441509
- [ ] Library production features:

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)