Attempt to align and cleanup some jmx metrics

[SylvainJuge]

This is an attempt to fix a few errors and inconsistencies that I've found in the JMX metrics captured with the JMX Metric Insight feature.

I have intentionally limited the scope to tomcat, jetty and wildfly, but similar changes might be applied to other systems as a follow-up.

• clarify the strategy for pre-defined metrics
• simplify metric prefix for tomcat to tomcat. for consistency with jetty, wildfly, ...
• fix tomcat busy/idle threads, as explained in this discussion.
• rename metrics to use singular form to fit (experimental) metrics semconv recommendations.
• rename units to use singular form to fit (stable) units semconv recommendations.
• move tomcat request-related metrics to tomcat.request.* namespace for consistency with wildfly.request.*
• align tomcat on system.network.io with tomcat.network.io for transferred bytes
• align wildfly on system.network.io with: wildfly.network.io for transferred bytes (only direction attribute had to be changed).

For the overall strategy, I agree that covering every metric of every platform is not possible nor something we aim to. For example, with Wildfly the db pool exposes more than 50 attributes that could be captured as metrics.

I think one of the important things that could make this type of mapping somehow manageable over time is to use the following strategy for metric names and their attributes:

• use or align to semconv when it fits
• keep the MBean attribute name otherwise: it allows to preserve the semantics of the observed system without having to try re-defining common metrics or deal with subtle implementation details.

Checklist & follow-ups

• wildfly.db.client.connection check with impl. that state can be a partition active/idle/wait (in which case using a single metric + attribute would make sense), but the wildfly documentation seems to imply it's not the case.
• wildfly.db.client.connection should use the db.client.connections.state from semconv for the connectíon state.
  • update: plural form was removed in semconv in Rename db.client.connections.* attributes to db.client.connection.* semantic-conventions#1125, to be released in 1.27.
• fix case for wildfly.db.client.transaction.NumberOfTransactions should probably be using MBean attribute so numberOfTransactions
• maybe try to fix the database semconv metrics attributes to use singular form, for example db.client.connections.pool.name should probably be renamed to db.client.connections.pool.name
  • update: already covered in Rename db.client.connections.* attributes to db.client.connection.* semantic-conventions#1125

[PeterF778]

Unless I'm missing something, the metric will have a metric attribute which will always have the same constant value. What is really the point of having such an attribute?

[SylvainJuge]

You are correct here, having a constant metric attribute only makes sense to provide breakdown of the same metric, occurences of wildfly.db.client.connection.usage should be renamed to wildfly.db.client.connection.count. I am currently trying to validate with the implementation if there is an overlap between the connection states or if it's an effective partition (in which case we can provide a breakdown).

[SylvainJuge]

When looking at the implementation and the wildfly test cases it seems that we have:

• "available" seems close to the definition of "idle"
• "in use" seems close to the definition of "busy"
• "active" seems to mostly be the sum of "available" + "in use"
• for "wait count", I haven't found any proper definition besides the docs

https://github.com/wildfly/wildfly/blob/841fea771567a71d06490a0d7e9a398dc6fdf5c0/testsuite/integration/basic/src/test/java/org/jboss/as/test/integration/jca/statistics/DataSourcePoolClearStatisticsTestCase.java#L69

https://github.com/wildfly/wildfly/blob/841fea771567a71d06490a0d7e9a398dc6fdf5c0/testsuite/integration/basic/src/test/java/org/jboss/as/test/integration/jca/capacitypolicies/ResourceAdapterCapacityPoliciesTestCase.java#L143

Given that both InUseCount and IdleCount refer to physical connection states in documentation, they effectively form a partition and then using a common metric with a constant attribute for idle | used makes sense.

For WaitCount this is about the number of logical connections that are waiting for a physical connection, so it would also make sense to use the same metric with a custom wait constant attribute.

When aggregating and removing attributes this would return the total number of logical connections to the database pool, and only a subset with either idle or used attribute value would be the physical connections.

I have updated this PR to match this in fb71fa1

[PeterF778]

Originally, JMX Metric Insight borrowed the metric definitions from JMX Metric Gatherer, and was bug-for-bug compatible. This was caused equally by our laziness as by the desire to allow users to transition smoothly to in-process metric collection.
I do not know how popular JMX Metric Insight is, but I know from experience that changes to metric names/attributes can sometimes be painful for the users. Perhaps it will be helpful for the customers if we keep the old metric configuration files around for some time as tomcat_old or tomcat_legacy etc.

[SylvainJuge]

Originally, JMX Metric Insight borrowed the metric definitions from JMX Metric Gatherer, and was bug-for-bug compatible. This was caused equally by our laziness as by the desire to allow users to transition smoothly to in-process metric collection. I do not know how popular JMX Metric Insight is, but I know from experience that changes to metric names/attributes can sometimes be painful for the users. Perhaps it will be helpful for the customers if we keep the old metric configuration files around for some time as tomcat_old or tomcat_legacy etc.

I completely understand the duplication strategy here, but it's probably time to remove the duplication and simplify things:

• there are a couple of issues about this Consolidate/reuse JMX implementation from instrumentation opentelemetry-java-contrib#736 and Unify metric collection between JMX Metrics Gatherer and JMX Metrics Insight #9765
• JMX gatherer supports more target systems than the JMX insight
• changing anything requires two PRs in two repositories, for example JMX metrics for Tomcat with 'Tomcat' JMX domain #10115 and In Tomcat Version 10.1.19 Spring Boot 3.2.4 Tomcat Bean Name Is Tomca… opentelemetry-java-contrib#1269
• it seems to me that the static yaml file definition covers what is currently captured through groovy scripts in JMX gatherer (I could be completely wrong on this one)

Until we have such duplication removed, we will have to backport such changes in the contrib repo. Implementation-wise, a common implementation would likely reside in the contrib repo and be included in the instrumentation agent (there are already similar dependencies for the aws and gcp resource providers).

Regarding compatibility, I really don't know what should be the best approach here, all the JMX metrics are very dependent on implementation details, having any formal definition in semconv and stability status for them is not possible. Maybe keeping previous iterations of the yaml files could provide this.

[SylvainJuge]

Status following June 20th SIG meeting:

• we need to first align the implementations in contrib/instrumentation while preserving current metrics compatibility
• we can provide updated version of the metrics in the instrumentation side with opt-in to use those new definitions (by default on the current state for compatibility)
• switching to the new metrics could be aligned with the next major that should be around the stable database semconv.
• this PR will stay in draft until then, parts of it will of course be reused along the way.

[SylvainJuge]

This PR is now stale and alignment work is being handled by individual per-system PRs.

• Jmx unit semconv alignment - Tomcat #13650
• enhance & align jetty jmx metrics #14067
• align wildfly metrics with semconv #14208

So we can now close this PR.