Doesn't work with apollo server v3

[PinkaminaDianePie]

It doesn't work after migrating to apollo server v3, no errors is thrown, but no directives actually produce errors in info.validationErrors

[cabelitos]

@PinkaminaDianePie could you please provide a minimal reproducible example?
thank you.

• Which directive are you using?
• A simple example would be nice

[PinkaminaDianePie]

@cabelitos hi, that's an issue for all of the directives.
Steps to reproduce:

1. In the root of apollo-validation-directives repo run yarn add apollo-server @graphql-tools/schema
2. In the examples/value-validation-directives.ts file replace import { makeExecutableSchema } from 'graphql-tools'; by import { makeExecutableSchema } from '@graphql-tools/schema';
3. Run yarn example:value-validation - there will be TS error on schemaDirectives: { listLength, pattern, range, stringLength }, line. Removing this line will allow the project to start, but it will obviously fail all of the tests.

Note that using latest '@graphql-tools/schema'; package is recommended by the Apollo v3 migration guide here: https://www.apollographql.com/docs/apollo-server/migration/#schemadirectives so downgrading @graphql-tools/schema back to the old graphql-tools sounds as a not that good option - it might cause some issues with other Apollo server v3 features later.

[cranberyxl]

Has anyone figured out a way to use these directives with apollo server 3?

[adavis]

Has anyone figured out a way to use these directives with apollo server 3?

Did you ever get this to work? Or did you find a workaround? Thanks

[cranberyxl]

We have not sorted it out. We either need to find a way to adapt v2 plugins to v3, find a v3 plugin that does this, or port the functionality that we use to our own plugin.

[DDDKnightmare]

This option may be a good temporary workaround, if you are still using graphql@^15.x

[oliveirarleo]

We are implementing it right now.

[PinkaminaDianePie]

@oliveirarleo btw if you have limited time/money, you can use this one instead: https://www.npmjs.com/package/graphql-constraint-directive