Skip to content

Conversation

@rameerez
Copy link
Owner

@rameerez rameerez commented Aug 4, 2025

Fixes ArgumentError in production environments with eager loading

Problem

SecurityController was calling skip_before_action :authenticate_api_keys_user! but the actual callback defined in ApplicationController is :authenticate_api_keys_owner!

Solution

Fixed the callback reference to use the correct method name, aligning with the gem's owner-agnostic design.

Changes

  • Bump version to 0.2.1
  • Update CHANGELOG.md with fix details

Closes #2

Generated with Claude Code

- Fix SecurityController callback reference issue
- Resolves ArgumentError in production with eager loading

Fixes #2

Co-authored-by: rameerez <[email protected]>
@claude
Copy link
Contributor

claude bot commented Aug 4, 2025

Claude finished @rameerez's task —— View job


Pull Request Review

I'll review this PR focusing on code quality, potential bugs, performance, security, and test coverage.

Todo List:

  • Read repository guidelines (CLAUDE.md) - No specific CLAUDE.md found
  • Examine changed files (CHANGELOG.md, version.rb)
  • Review the actual SecurityController fix context
  • Check ApplicationController for callback definition
  • Assess code quality and best practices
  • Evaluate potential bugs and issues
  • Consider performance implications
  • Review security concerns
  • Check test coverage
  • Provide comprehensive feedback

Review Summary

This PR correctly fixes a critical bug in the SecurityController where the wrong callback method name was being used in skip_before_action.

Code Quality & Best Practices ✅

Excellent fix implementation:

  • The change from :authenticate_api_keys_user! to :authenticate_api_keys_owner! aligns perfectly with the gem's owner-agnostic design introduced in v0.2.0
  • Proper version bump following semantic versioning (patch increment for bug fix)
  • Well-structured CHANGELOG entry with clear description and issue reference
  • Clean git history with descriptive commit messages

Bug Analysis ✅

Critical production bug fixed:

  • Root cause: app/controllers/api_keys/security_controller.rb:8 was calling skip_before_action :authenticate_api_keys_user! but app/controllers/api_keys/application_controller.rb:18,24 defines authenticate_api_keys_owner!
  • Impact: Would cause ArgumentError in production with eager loading when Rails tries to validate the callback exists
  • Solution: Correctly references the actual callback method defined in the parent controller

Performance Considerations ✅

No performance impact:

  • This is purely a method name fix with no algorithmic changes
  • Fixes a runtime error that would prevent the controller from loading
  • No additional overhead introduced

Security Concerns ✅

Security implications properly handled:

  • The fix maintains the same security behavior - skipping authentication for the best_practices static informational page
  • No change in authorization logic or scope
  • Continues to properly inherit from ApplicationController which enforces authentication via before_action :authenticate_api_keys_owner!

Test Coverage ❌

Missing test coverage for this scenario:

  • No tests found specifically for SecurityController
  • The production bug suggests this controller path isn't covered by integration tests
  • Recommendation: Add a test case that verifies the best_practices action is accessible without authentication, which would have caught this callback reference error

Example test that should be added:

# test/controllers/api_keys/security_controller_test.rb
class ApiKeys::SecurityControllerTest < ActionDispatch::IntegrationTest
  test "best_practices page accessible without authentication" do
    get "/api_keys/security/best-practices"  # or whatever the mounted path is
    assert_response :success
  end
end

Architecture Notes 📋

Well-designed owner-agnostic pattern:

  • The v0.2.0 refactor to support any owner model (User, Organization, Team, etc.) is well-implemented
  • ApplicationController properly uses configurable authentication methods from ApiKeys.configuration
  • The callback naming convention (authenticate_api_keys_owner!) is consistent and clear

Recommendation

Approved with suggestion: This is a solid bug fix that resolves a critical production issue. The only improvement would be adding test coverage for the SecurityController to prevent similar regressions.


@rameerez rameerez merged commit d9a4f83 into main Aug 4, 2025
1 check passed
@rameerez rameerez deleted the claude/issue-2-20250804-2224 branch August 4, 2025 22:29
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

ArgumentError: Before process_action callback :authenticate_api_keys_user! has not been defined when eager loading in production

2 participants