Skip to content

docs: Add user-facing documentation for MCP Evaluation Framework (PR 1377) #1400

@rysweet

Description

@rysweet

Problem

PR 1377 introduced a Generic MCP Evaluation Framework but lacks user-facing documentation in the docs/ directory. Current documentation is framework-internal (in tests/mcp_evaluation/) and technical specs (in Specs/).

Requirements

Create comprehensive user-facing documentation:

1. MCP Evaluation Guide (docs/MCP_EVALUATION_GUIDE.md)

  • Audience: amplihack users evaluating MCP integrations
  • Content:
    • What is MCP evaluation and why use it
    • When to evaluate (decision criteria)
    • Quick start with mock adapter
    • Evaluating real MCP tools
    • Interpreting results and making decisions
    • Troubleshooting

2. Adapter Creation Guide (docs/MCP_ADAPTER_CREATION.md)

  • Audience: Developers adding new MCP tool evaluations
  • Content:
    • Adapter interface requirements
    • Configuration file format
    • Metrics collection patterns
    • Testing adapters
    • Real example walkthrough
    • Common patterns

3. README Update

Add feature section linking to MCP Evaluation Guide after line 103

Success Criteria

  • User can understand when to use MCP evaluation
  • User can run mock evaluation in < 5 minutes
  • User can interpret results and make integration decisions
  • Developer can create custom adapter in < 30 minutes
  • No need to read framework internals to use it

Related

Labels

  • documentation
  • enhancement

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions