🚀 10 Enhancement Ideas for amplihack - Analysis from Trace Files and PRs

[rysweet]

🚀 10 Enhancement Ideas for amplihack

Based on comprehensive analysis of claude-trace files, 100+ recent PRs, DISCOVERIES.md, and existing capabilities, here are 10 enhancement proposals to make amplihack even more powerful.

Enhancement 1: Session Replay and Analysis Tool 📹

Problem Identified: Claude-trace files contain rich session data (1.6GB+ in trace logs), but there's no tool to systematically analyze session patterns, identify common failure modes, or replay sessions for debugging.

Evidence: From trace files like log-2025-11-24-19-59-27.jsonl (85MB+), sessions contain full request/response chains with timing data that could reveal optimization opportunities.

Proposed Solution:

• Create /amplihack:replay <session-id> command to summarize and analyze session transcripts
• Build session-pattern-analyzer skill to identify common pitfalls and success patterns
• Auto-generate "session health reports" with token usage trends, error rates, and agent performance metrics
• Integrate with existing transcript-system for persistence

Estimated Effort: Medium (3-4 days)
Priority: HIGH - directly improves developer experience and debugging

---

Enhancement 2: Agent Performance Dashboard 📊

Problem Identified: While we have 30+ specialized agents, there's no visibility into which agents are most effective, which are underutilized, and which patterns lead to success.

Evidence: DISCOVERIES.md mentions "agent orchestration works for complex debugging" but we lack metrics. Recent PRs (#1600) parallelize SDK calls but don't track agent-level performance.

Proposed Solution:

• Track agent invocation counts, success rates, and average completion times in .claude/runtime/metrics/
• Create agent-performance-reviewer agent to analyze metrics and suggest improvements
• Add /amplihack:dashboard command showing agent utilization heatmap
• Identify "dead" agents that haven't been used in 30+ days

Estimated Effort: Medium (2-3 days)
Priority: MEDIUM - improves system understanding and optimization

---

Enhancement 3: Smart Context Window Management 🧠

Problem Identified: PreCompact hook exists but context management is reactive rather than proactive. Sessions often hit context limits before action is taken.

Evidence: context_management skill exists but lacks predictive features. DISCOVERIES.md mentions "Context Preservation Implementation Success" but doesn't prevent context exhaustion.

Proposed Solution:

• Add context-budget-monitor that predicts when 70% capacity is reached
• Create proactive-summarization skill that auto-condenses conversation before limits hit
• Implement "context health indicator" in statusline showing projected messages remaining
• Auto-archive low-relevance context while preserving critical requirements

Estimated Effort: Medium (3 days)
Priority: HIGH - prevents context exhaustion issues

---

Enhancement 4: Cross-Session Learning System 🎓

Problem Identified: Each session starts fresh without learning from past sessions. Patterns identified in DISCOVERIES.md must be manually documented rather than auto-learned.

Evidence:

• DISCOVERIES.md has 15+ entries of learned patterns manually documented
• Power-steering analyzes sessions but doesn't learn across them
• No mechanism to transfer "what worked" from successful sessions

Proposed Solution:

• Create session-insights-extractor that runs at Stop hook to capture learnings
• Build persistent "learned patterns database" in .claude/data/learnings/
• Inject relevant past learnings at SessionStart based on task similarity
• Create /amplihack:learnings command to view and manage captured insights

Estimated Effort: High (5-6 days)
Priority: HIGH - multiplies value of every session

---

Enhancement 5: Workflow Step Compliance Enforcement 🚦

Problem Identified: Agents skip workflow steps despite clear instructions. Issue #1607 identified this as recurring problem, leading to Step 0 (Workflow Preparation) being added.

Evidence:

• DEFAULT_WORKFLOW.md now has 22 steps with Step 0 specifically to prevent skipping
• DISCOVERIES.md documents "Workflow step skipping as a recurring problem"
• Power-steering checks exist but only at session end

Proposed Solution:

• Add real-time workflow step validator that runs at each PostToolUse hook
• Track step completion in .claude/runtime/workflow_state.json
• Block PR creation if mandatory steps (10, 16-17) haven't been completed
• Create visual workflow progress indicator: [████░░░░░░] Step 7/22

Estimated Effort: Medium (3 days)
Priority: HIGH - addresses documented pain point

---

Enhancement 6: Automated Dependency Conflict Resolution 🔧

Problem Identified: CI failures from dependency conflicts and version mismatches cause 20-30 minute debug cycles.

Evidence:

• DISCOVERIES.md "CI Failure Resolution Process Analysis" documents 45-minute complex debugging
• "Environment mismatches: Local (Python 3.12.10) vs CI (Python 3.11)" caused significant delay
• pre-commit-diagnostic and ci-diagnostic-workflow exist but are reactive

Proposed Solution:

• Create dependency-drift-detector that proactively checks for version mismatches
• Add pre-push hook that compares local environment to CI configuration
• Auto-generate .python-version and lock files when drift detected
• Integrate with fix-agent templates for common dependency issues

Estimated Effort: Medium (2-3 days)
Priority: MEDIUM - reduces CI failure debugging time

---

Enhancement 7: Multi-Repository Orchestration 🌐

Problem Identified: amplihack currently focuses on single-repository workflows. Modern projects often span multiple repos requiring coordinated changes.

Evidence:

• Worktree management is single-repo focused
• No cross-repo dependency tracking
• PM Architect manages projects but not inter-repo coordination

Proposed Solution:

• Extend PM Architect to track cross-repo dependencies
• Create multi-repo-coordinator skill for atomic cross-repo changes
• Add /amplihack:monorepo command for coordinated multi-repo PRs
• Track cross-repo breaking changes and migration requirements

Estimated Effort: High (5-7 days)
Priority: MEDIUM - needed as projects scale

---

Enhancement 8: Intelligent Test Selection 🎯

Problem Identified: Full test suites run even for small changes, wasting time. No smart test selection based on code changes.

Evidence:

• Workflow Step 12 runs all pre-commit hooks and tests
• No impact analysis determines which tests are affected
• Large test suites slow down iteration cycles

Proposed Solution:

• Create test-impact-analyzer that maps code changes to affected tests
• Implement tiered test strategy: fast → impacted → full suite
• Add /amplihack:test-smart command for intelligent test selection
• Track test reliability scores to skip flaky tests in fast iterations

Estimated Effort: Medium (4 days)
Priority: MEDIUM - improves developer velocity

---

Enhancement 9: Visual Code Flow Diagrams 📈

Problem Identified: Complex codebases lack visual documentation. Understanding code flow requires manual exploration.

Evidence:

• visualization-architect agent exists but isn't auto-triggered
• mermaid-diagram-generator skill exists but requires manual invocation
• No auto-generated architecture diagrams on major changes

Proposed Solution:

• Auto-generate code flow diagrams when new modules are created
• Create architecture-drift-detector that flags when diagrams are stale
• Add /amplihack:visualize <path> command for on-demand diagram generation
• Integrate with PR reviews to auto-include architecture impact diagrams

Estimated Effort: Medium (3 days)
Priority: LOW - nice-to-have for documentation

---

Enhancement 10: Agent Consensus Voting for Critical Decisions 🗳️

Problem Identified: For security-sensitive or architectural decisions, single-agent recommendations may have blind spots.

Evidence:

• multi-agent-debate agent exists but is underutilized
• n-version-validator provides parallel implementations but not voting
• DISCOVERIES.md "Pattern Applicability Analysis" discusses when voting vs expert judgment is appropriate

Proposed Solution:

• Create /amplihack:consensus <decision> command for multi-agent voting
• Implement weighted voting based on agent expertise domain
• Auto-trigger consensus for security, auth, and data-handling changes
• Track consensus accuracy over time to calibrate agent weights

Estimated Effort: Medium (3-4 days)
Priority: MEDIUM - improves critical decision quality

---

Summary

#	Enhancement	Priority	Effort	Impact
1	Session Replay and Analysis	HIGH	Medium	Debugging
2	Agent Performance Dashboard	MEDIUM	Medium	Observability
3	Smart Context Window Management	HIGH	Medium	UX
4	Cross-Session Learning	HIGH	High	Multiplier
5	Workflow Step Enforcement	HIGH	Medium	Quality
6	Dependency Conflict Resolution	MEDIUM	Medium	CI Speed
7	Multi-Repo Orchestration	MEDIUM	High	Scale
8	Intelligent Test Selection	MEDIUM	Medium	Velocity
9	Visual Code Flow Diagrams	LOW	Medium	Documentation
10	Agent Consensus Voting	MEDIUM	Medium	Quality

Recommended Priority Order

Phase 1 (Quick Wins):

1. Enhancement 5: Workflow Step Enforcement - addresses documented pain point
2. Enhancement 3: Smart Context Management - high impact on daily usage
3. Enhancement 1: Session Replay Tool - enables debugging of other issues

Phase 2 (Strategic):
4. Enhancement 4: Cross-Session Learning - multiplies value over time
5. Enhancement 6: Dependency Conflict Resolution - reduces CI pain

Phase 3 (Scale):
6. Enhancement 7: Multi-Repo Orchestration
7. Enhancement 8: Intelligent Test Selection
8. Enhancement 2: Agent Performance Dashboard

Phase 4 (Polish):
9. Enhancement 10: Agent Consensus Voting
10. Enhancement 9: Visual Code Flow Diagrams

---

Generated from analysis of 100+ recent PRs, 1.6GB+ claude-trace logs, and comprehensive DISCOVERIES.md review

Labels: enhancement, roadmap, hackathon-2025