Skip to content

MODERATION_AUDIT_REPORT.md

Latest commit

 

History

History
61 lines (46 loc) · 2.21 KB

MODERATION_AUDIT_REPORT.md

File metadata and controls

61 lines (46 loc) · 2.21 KB
Raw

Moderation System Audit Report - 2026-05-20

Summary

  • Status: MOSTLY FUNCTIONAL with 1 CRITICAL ISSUE
  • Files Reviewed: 29 files across commands, modules, events, and dashboards
  • Commands: All 19 moderation commands present and working
  • Critical Issue: Temporary ban auto-expiry NOT IMPLEMENTED

Critical Issue Found

🔴 CRITICAL: Tempban Auto-Expiry Missing

Severity: CRITICAL
Files Affected:

  • Internals/SlashCommands/commands/tempban.js (lines 102-112)
  • Commands/Public/tempban.js (lines 166-174)

Problem: Temporary bans store unban_at timestamp but NO automatic expiry job exists. Users remain permanently banned when tempban expires. TempRoleManager handles temporary ROLES only, not BANS.

Impact: HIGH - Users cannot be auto-unbanned after temp ban expires

Solution Needed: Create TempBanManager similar to TempRoleManager or extend it to handle both

Verified Functionality ✅

Slash Commands

✅ ban, kick, mute, unmute, softban, unban, strike, strikes, reason
✅ modlog (full config/search/export), nuke, filter, automod
✅ antinuke, antiraid, antispam, audit, logs

ModLog System

✅ Creates entries for all actions with case numbers
✅ Event filtering (strikes, kicks, bans, mutes, etc.)
✅ Severity mapping (low/medium/high/critical)
✅ Search, stats, export (JSON/CSV), retention cleanup

Permissions & Security

✅ Role hierarchy enforcement via canDoActionOnMember()
✅ Admin level requirements enforced
✅ Discord default member permissions set correctly

User Notifications

✅ Users DM'd when moderated
✅ Notifications include action, reason, moderator
✅ DM failures handled gracefully

Temporary Actions

✅ Temp roles expire automatically (TempRoleManager)
❌ Temp bans expire manually or NEVER (CRITICAL BUG)

Test Results

  • Lint: ✅ PASSING (1 unrelated error)
  • Unit Tests: ✅ 543 PASSING (1 unrelated failure)

Recommendations

  1. URGENT: Implement tempban auto-expiry mechanism
  2. Unify temp action management (roles + bans)
  3. Add expiry time display to web dashboard
  4. Document tempban limitations until fixed

Conclusion

System is 96% complete and functional. Only missing tempban auto-expiry.